Happy New Year! We are still enjoying Christmas and I hope you are too!
I wanted to revisit the question that came up and was much discussed in the comments: whether grocery delivery is “worth it.”
First let me say that my point in the post was not about making the cost-benefit analysis of “my sanity vs. saving some bucks” — it’s a great perk to be able to pick up your order or even have it brought to your house when needed and your sanity is worth a lot.
I do not quibble with a rational determination that this is money well spent, if you have it!
The subject was more about hidden risks involved in collecting data and sharing it to fix prices. It was more of a broader observation of the effect of electronic commerce.
I want to be sure, though, to encourage you to consider the importance of doing things in person — the importance for your children’s development.
Children learn and grow in many ways, and one of those ways is by being taken out and about, having to talk to strangers, making eye contact, and seeing things in the world. They learn self control when you remind them as you enter the store that you are expecting them to help you and not ask for things (and haves the fun of finding out that you will buy them something nice as a treat if they behave).
You also learn to overcome your trepidation about taking a little or many littles on an outing.
You start not with a giant Costco run (though you will get there) but with a quick trip for a few items you may have forgotten at your local store. Yes, it takes some time to suit everyone up after making sure they went to the bathroom (or got diapers changed) and had a snack. Yes, it can be tiring.
But gee, I remember having a lot of fun with my kids when we went to the store once I had figured all the logistics out. And they became quite helpful carrying sacks for me and reminding me of things we were lacking. The little boys enjoyed pretending to be garbage men, hanging off the side of the cart. The newly proficient in writing had made the list and would read it to me as we went along. The older ones would push the extra cart. And I like to think we gave the people at the store something to talk about!
I am actually concerned that children have increasingly little contact with a world not tailored to meeting their perceived needs. I am concerned that we aren’t stretching our interaction muscles — that we are choosing a very small bubble over the wide world (which is really just our neighborhood).
I am concerned that the wide world is just never seeing children. It’s not good for them either.
Someone made the comment (not sure where) that grocery delivery was the norm in mid-century America. Well — I would say it wasn’t unusual in a city or town. I can remember milk delivery.
Most mothers shopped in person both more and less than we do today: More, because they bought their meat fresh from the butcher (if they didn’t raise it themselves, which in town, they did not) and veggies and eggs from the market several times a week. People’s fridges were small. Less, because they had a less varied diet and relied more on stocked-up foods, and yes, sometimes the merchant would deliver.
But when they did get things delivered, you have to understand the context: Children walked to school, played outside all day, were expected to behave at the library, where they often went by themselves or with their friends, and interacted with adults quite a bit, running to the neighbors’ houses and having paper routes.
Moms had prams and walked with their small children to pick things up. And of course, if you needed a toaster or wrench, you went to the store that carried what you wanted to buy — you didn’t have it droned in from Amazon.
My mother told about being sent by my grandmother to the corner store in the city (New York) to pick something up, quite alone — she was five years old. That was around 1941.
No personal data was collected when the grocer delivered, other than his own mental notes about your preferences; stores didn’t conspire to fix prices, a practice that hurts the family.
People were not in their own little self-sufficient suburban pods with children doing everything remotely, never speak to an adult not in their own household, getting everything delivered and never going out to buy a thing — or for that matter, out at all.
We often lament our new circumstances and how unwelcoming they are to children. As a result of the lockdown, a bad, long-time trend of a childless public life got way worse.
The only way to change that is to challenge ourselves to provide experiences for our children with more organic involvement in the community through ordinary errands. And remember, if you want your children to behave at Church, they simply have to have practice during the week.
If they haven’t been required to get through the supermarket without constant reprimands, and to enter the post office without whining, how will they sit through the liturgy once every seven days?
Anyway, I feel very much that I alone am left to tell you. There is something drastically unhealthy about never leaving the house with the children.
You will have to figure out your own situation and where or when you can manage it and have it not be an awful experience, whether due to your worries, the children’s behavior, or the scariness of the environment.
You will have to have the confidence to take what I am saying and apply it to your world as you see fit. But I have to say it.
It’s great, not having to do go out when one is sick or in some other dire situation, but let’s not go overboard. Mothers are not victims; we are willing to stretch and challenge ourselves and have a rough time at first, in order to give our children healthy experiences.
bits & pieces
- A beautiful poem for Christmas
- Some considerations about the religious implications of a practice that is more mutilation than hygiene — as done today in hospitals.
- My husband is leaving the part of his job that is posting the daily news but expanding the rest of it!
- If you are interested in the topic of Just War, you might be interested in his course on Substack
from the archives
Ask Auntie Leila: The new baby and the toddler.
I have a new planner and am pretty excited about it, but here’s a post with some thoughts on not focusing too much on efficiency.
liturgical living
Tomorrow is the feast of the Epiphany in the Ordinary Calendar and The Holy Name of Jesus in the Traditional Calendar. Keep your Christmas!
A little heads up to order candles now to have them in good time for Candlemas, February 2. I like these tapers for everyday use, and these votives (affiliate links). This little business is run by friends of ours and their beeswax candles are wonderful.
follow us everywhere!
Here is all the info:
Visit me at The School for Housewives and recommend it to your young friends!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them has moved over to Substack! — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing! The old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts.
There you will find the weekly podcast done by Phil and me, called On the Home Front. Do let us know what you think!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
I keep this site ad-free, but you can support me these ways:
Using my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit.
Buying me a skein or two of yarn! (This will appear on your credit card as “Domus Enterprises” — please remember!)
Thank you!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen: Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
My old podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) if you haven’t heard them.
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest















You’re not alone in this–Jonathan Haidt is banging a similar drum! He has a stat that only 50% of kids in the US have walked down a grocery isle alone (much less going to a neighborhood store alone) by the time they’re 10 years old.
That said, I don’t do grocery delivery but I do shop alone, now that I don’t have to drag them all along. I think there are many other opportunities to interact with adults! Doctor’s appointments, pharmacy pick up, Mass, choir, the library, grabbing milk at the gas station, co-op classes or school, errands to the neighbors, etc. I worry that some poor overwhelmed mom is going to use her last reserves of energy on making Aldi a teachable moment. Though I do see your point also!
Sometimes, as that rare reward that my kids need, I give them $1.31 each and let them lose in Dollar Tree while I read my book in the car. It’s great! (Though fosters consumerism, another issue I think…) The kids can also bike to a few stores, even in our less-than-ideal sidewalkless suburbia.
And when my 10 year old son is restless, I try to think of the cheapest thing we could possibly “need” at the nearby Walgreens and send him off on his bike!
I do wish people did more of this; even from a basic safety perspective, drivers are much less used to looking for bikers and walkers, since there are so few.
But also, read the actual stats on the risks involved in sending your kids off alone, if you’re worried. Social media and such make us as a society blow the risks way out of proportion! So many of my friends seem to think their kid will get kidnapped if he goes on an errand alone…
I’m not necessarily advocating for sending a child off alone. Again, the context matters — when there were neighbors on the porches and cops on the corners (as even I recall), that makes a difference. Moms at home make a difference. With empty communities, I don’t think it’s a great idea, most of the time.
Again, everyone needs to use common sense and have confidence in her own assessment of the situation!
Okay, the cop on every corner thing! So that was real? My husband and I have been watching a lot of classic Hollywood films lately and over time something we noticed is that there were always friendly cops just ambling around able to be summoned at a moments notice for some kind of minor “disturbance” (like a noise or someone sitting on a bench for a suspiciously long time). And yes, very young children running about who often seem to know the policemen by name. Was that more less how it used to be? (Of course with the provision that these are Hollywood depictions)
Yes! I was a child in New Haven, CT, a moderately sized city. My mother let me ride my bike all over, and she would always say, “if you have trouble with anything, ask a policeman.” I was about 10-14 and this was the early 70s.
There were cops walking around.
How would you ask a policeman today?
Sad.
Rarely do I vehemently disagree with a topic that you post about, but the article on circumcision certainly hit poorly. To start, I would far rather emulate what was done to Christ for my own children than not. The Bible verses referenced in the article were weak fodder, they really seem to say “either is fine”. But, my own personal experiences with this…as a young woman (currently 47, 4 children) I babysat for an infant that was uncircumcised and let’s just say, when he had a bowel movement, it was traumatic for all of us to get him clean, and this was with particular instructions from his mother that involved qtips to clean out, ahh, hard to reach places. Prior to that experience I had gone back and forth on circumcision. After that, I was firmly decided that any son of mine would indeed be circumcised. Little boys do not tend toward the best hygiene at the best of times. But, though the genetic disorder is rare, circumcision probably saved my nephew’s life as an infant. Because he was still in hospital when they did the procedure they realized quickly that he had some sort of clotting disorder and it took a blood transfusion to save his life. If he had experienced an injury (including bruising) after being sent home, he probably would have died. So, at least for me and mine, not circumcising seems like a foolish choice and one that is not mandated, one way or the other by scripture.
An important point the article brings out is that hospital circ is NOT the same as ritual circ — it is far more invasive, so the argument about Our Lord is moot unless the parents are engaging a mohel (which some do, and that is what I would suggest if it’s going to be done). Also, that the ritual procedure is done eight days after birth, not at birth (or the day after), for important health reasons that are not wise to overlook.
I don’t know if people are aware of the serious risks involved from a procedure carried out, remember — on a healthy child. Here is an overview: https://med.stanford.edu/newborns/professional-education/circumcision/complications.html — again, the child is healthy before these outcomes come into play.
If you read the story of the baby who became the fulcrum of Dr. John Money’s trans empire, you discover that the whole thing was the result of a botched circumcision — the cauterization (again, not what was done to Our Lord) went wrong and basically, the infant’s organ was cooked and had to be removed. He then was victimized by an evil and opportunistic professional. The story is written by a journalist; it’s called As Nature Made Him, and the point of it is what happened afterwards, but it did strike me at the time that he was healthy until this horrible intervention.
In addition, purposely making a child bleed only to discover he will need a blood transfusion is rather risky and sounds unethical to me. There is a reason the ritual requires the child to be 8 days old.
Further, I can attest that there is zero reason to worry about hygiene. Easy peasy as long as you just proceed without forcing anything.
I must agree about hygiene, I have three sons, who are intact, and diaper changes were never any more complicated than what I had to do for other little boys I had cared for (babysitting, etc) or for my girls. My husband is from a part of the (Christian) world where circumcision is not routinely practiced. What do we suppose people do in countries where this was never a thing? The male organ is just a normal body part, we don’t need to fix/repair it by default. (Obviously there are individual cases where something might need to be addressed, but that’s true of any body part isn’t it.)
It’s truly just not an issue at all to clean them. I have no idea what that is about.
The things I think most people do not understand, and maybe I’ll find other resources to post another time:
1. the hospital procedure is qualitatively different from the ritual one and not in a good way (and it’s clear that the ritual one is not for Christians)
2. there are significant risks
3. not mentioned in the article (if I recall correctly) is that the foreskin and tissues are harvested and sold! This is a clear violation of bodily integrity and basic ethics!
Care and cleaning during diaper changes for an uncircumcised baby should never involve qtips! Yikes. No wonder it was traumatic every time! My midwives and pediatrician told me never to try and retract the foreskin to clean, but just to clean it as if it were a finger.
We’ve never had any issues or problems, except for the natural process of the foreskin retracting around age 2 (which is described in the Fish Eaters article linked within the one above)— this causes skin cells to shed and they sometimes get a little stuck and cause some irritation. Again, solved by little baths in warm, plain water /no soap. (Also, avoid wipes with artificial scents as this seems to really irritate!).
Exactly. That q-tip thing was concerning, for sure.
Scented wipes and soaps with lots of irritants (ie bubble bath) should also not be used for little girls. Lots of little girls out there with irritation and even vaginal fungus that manifests as always touching themselves, to the anxiety of parents, all due to using these products.
Honestly, I think you could do with widening your worldview a little. Almost no one in England is circumcised and we do not have widespread health or hygiene problems because of it.
I have changed two of my baby boys’ nappies so far with zero problems. And zero Q tips! That sounds painful and disgusting! Just wiping is fine!
It’s a cultural choice, not a true hygiene issue. Just like different toilet designs are cultural choices (I understand American toilets have a lot more water in them?) and not genuine hygiene issues.
Circumcise if you want, but be aware that you’re just making a cultural choice, and other cultures do not have the same expectations in that department. Many (most?) people in the UK are horrified at the idea of routine circumcision (although accepting of it as a religious practice).
Oh my. I don’t know what to say about this perceived hygiene issue, except that it’s completely 100% not my experience. I have three intact sons and there has never, ever been the slightest problem. We don’t need special tools or techniques to keep them clean… honestly, for any expectant mother wondering what decision to make in this regard, don’t think that leaving your boys alone is unhygienic. I promise it is not.
Merry Christmas still! It’s lovely to see all your pictures of real life at your home. It looks so cozy!
I agree about errands. Though I have had to write out a battle plan of who to buckle first and how to get us out the door efficiently, and this more than once as we added kids (now up to 6 boys, 10 to baby), it’s worth it. We’ve been told many times that it’s a blessing to see us in the grocery store. It’s certainly noteworthy – not many big families in our town. It almost always starts a quick chat with someone. And the boys are used to being “ambassadors,” as we call it, for Christ, for big families, for homeschoolers. We should be human but give our honest best. My two bigs, 10 and 8, have really loved being sent to the grocery store down the street, one crossing away. I send them with cash in their own special wallet, and always as a pair. We practiced that crossing a lot! I’d rather add risk gradually than turn them lose at 18 and hope for the best. I know I’m not alone in that.
About introductions and such, I want to work on that so much. That’s a wish for the new year.
Wishing you God’s blessings in the new year and always!
I agree wholeheartedly about sending children on errands. I’m grateful that when mine were young we lived in neighborhoods where it was easy to do this, and I loved taking the children shopping and involving them in decision making.
The story was told me — I don’t remember it — that my mother drove to the store but stayed in the car, when she was in (I hope early) labor with my brother. She sent me in alone to buy a mop, when I was six years old!
My difficulty in taking the children out to grocery shop is the sheer amount of time it takes! When you take everything into account, it’s an entire half day.
I already feel like most of my week is triage – what can be dispensed with that I wish we could actually do? I don’t feel like I can dedicate an entire half day every week, fortnight or even month just to schlepping to and from the supermarket.
That said, we shopped in person much more before I started homeschooling. We did used to do a weekly in-person shop back when it was a walk away and not a drive, and everyone could fit in one buggy!
And my children ARE well-behaved when we do go. The big ones got used to it way back when, and the little ones pick it up from them.
What I do get embarrassed about is the sheer amount of space we take up. One trolley, maybe a buggy too, four kids eight and under trailing along with one hand on one of the aforementioned wheeled conveyances… If we’re in the aisle, ain’t nobody getting past us! Being homeschoolers, we do go at quiet times, but I still feel like I’m taking up more than my fair share of square footage and the children seem impervious to the need to squeeze over to let others past.
No doubt if we went regularly, I/we/they would get more used to simply existing in public, but… I don’t feel I can afford the time!
I do make them greet the supermarket delivery man, though, and help me unload the shopping. So… partial credit?! 🙂
Well, it’s funny, because one thing about being the mom of a couple of littles is the sense of time stretching out and not knowing how to get through the day. Many moms lament the feeling that without resorting to videos, they don’t know how to survive or keep their children occupied.
Thus, it’s not actually a bad idea to have an outing once a week that does take up half the day!
Later, when there’s more to do, one can re-adjust.
Again, have confidence in your decisions about what is best for your use of time!
Yes! For me (2.5 year old and new 1 year old), our grocery trip is our “outing” of the day. Aldi is a lifesaver in so many ways (small store, carts with two seats, amazing prices). I also have found how important it is to go in the morning. I know things will change in each season, but for now we enjoy a well-planned grocery trip each week.
Oh my, you’re right, I’d completely forgotten about that yawning sense of endless time! Even though it was a few scant years ago! I don’t miss it one bit!!!
But having reflected further, I do appreciate the point you’re making, and I think I got bogged down in grocery shopping particularly.
My eldest answers our door nicely to the postman and to guests. We all go to the dentist. I took three kids six and under to almost all of my midwife appointments last pregnancy and they did great! (Books and colouring and a pep talk beforehand did wonders.) They speak to people at church (well, except my ultra-shy middle, but she’s working on it). I try to book us onto free guided tours when we go places and my eldest asks pleasant and perceptive questions (while my 4yo picks her nose in the background, but quietly!!) We homeschoolers go to a lot of museums!
I was struck by it particularly when my sister-in-law suggested we go someplace and was horrified when she realised my husband would not be coming too. I’m not sure if/when/where she takes her two-under-three out by herself… at all, really. But I was baffled by the idea that I can’t handle my own kids in public by myself. In a children’s museum of all places, where everything is to touch! I’m not sure if we’re going to go, as I truly think she is terrified of me going without my husband being there too, but he can’t come (and frankly it’s not how I’d like him to spend his limited time off).
It’s been a journey to get to this point, but it’s easier to take my four out now (eight and under) than when I just had a 3yo and a 1yo and NO ONE could look out for anyone else. Now the 8yo can mind the 1yo for a second while I help the 4yo with her coat – and three quarters of my kids can do their own shoes and go for longer than an hour between toilet stops and even sit on the toilet by themselves! Different world from two in nappies or one half potty trained!
Stay the course, moms of only preschoolers and under! You can do it!
One thing I do sometimes is bring all the kids to pick up the grocery curb-side order, but then since I have inevitably forgotten to add something to the order, we all go in to get a small number of items. That brings the time factor down but also gives the children the thrill of going in to the store, as truly they are so disappointed when it’s only a pickup!
But now I’m wondering whether, maybe every other week, I bring them all to do the full shop…. Hmm!
Your tree, Leila! Absolutely charming! Happy New Year.
Thanks! It was the scrawniest on the lot haha but it cleaned up nicely!
I agree wholeheartedly about the necessity of kids getting out and seeing the world, and the world seeing them! I took all 4 of the kids to their dentist appointment this week (the baby was just there for moral support)- I always get comments about their excellent behavior at the dentist, and this time I had a great conversation with the young male hygienist who told me he was #3 of 11 kids, and he wants a big family too!
One favorite place when my oldest were toddlers was Home Depot, as there is so much there to grab their attention, but not much to beg me to get for them 😉
It does make me despair for humanity when I see parents give their kid a device to distract them as they walk the aisles of a store! We can do better than this, surely.
Did you take a pause on children who were particularly difficult in stores? My two year old son is vehemently protesting the shopping cart, but also can’t be trusted to behave well out of it. At the current moment it seems like we enter a store only to leave it immediately
Please please heed my advice to be confident in your own knowledge of your own circumstances!! Only you know if it’s worth it to you at whatever stage you are in!
But I will say this: go to the snack aisle and get a package of pretzel rods, not the store brand which is somewhat dry and crackery; the good plain kind. Open it up and give one to whatever toddler, infant sitting up in the carriage, or child of the age of reason who could use it.
A pretzel rod doesn’t smear and disintegrate like graham crackers or get all over like raisins. It lasts quite a while. You can pay at the counter when you check out. You will likely also need a water bottle.
That is all.
I used to make the deli counter my first stop at the grocery store. Each child would get a slice of fresh-cut cheese (the deli workers used to hand these out as a “sample cut” when I was buying cheese – but if not, you can always ask!)
This would give everyone something to look forward to when waiting in line at the deli, and something to work on through the first half of the store. The second half of the store usually involved the produce, frozen, and dairy – and was always less stressful to me than the interior aisles full of inviting boxes & cans, or the meat display where I’d be trying to get my youngest to stop poking the packages.
I think this is important, Auntie Leila! Thanks for the reminder about bringing children into the world via errands.
To those citing difficulties of their circumstances: as a mother of 8 (senior in HS down to newborn), I think you can mull over this suggestion for your season of life; at the end of this pregnancy I wouldn’t bring my rambunctious three year old anywhere—he was much faster than me & knew it, and my energy levels were sapped! But that doesn’t mean he never goes on errands—Dad would bring him along to the hardware store on occasion, and he’ll go again once this baby grows up a bit. Key is, I think, to keep this in mind: it’s good for children to get out in the world, and good for the world to see them out! So next time you hesitate, think “maybe I could this time?” Or maybe not—“maybe another time!” But don’t give up on the idea altogether. There is so much to be learned in the grocery aisles! And this goes for older kids too—they learn to compare prices, know where things are, read labels, etc so they can shop for you (with toddler in tow if you’re lucky!) in the future.
And now that I don’t have to bring all my kids with me to shop—bigs at home can watch littles—often an errand with mom is a special privilege (and a big help to me!). There are many ways to live this in the many stages of a growing family.
I used to take all my kids grocery shopping because my husband worked all the time (I was grateful for that) and I had to. I had so many awkward and embarrassing things happen.
One time in Winco, my two year old’s octopus arm swiped a glass jam jar when I was focused on shopping and I had to request “clean up on aisle 4”.
Another time (on 4th of July in a busy store) a different 2-3 year old popped the bottom off a canister of Comet bleach and the powdered bleach got all over the tritip, groceries, etc. The grocery store replaced it all for free (they were so kind) and it was so embarrassing.
My last straw was when I was 8 months pregnant with baby #4, and also had 3 kids under 4 years old, and the 3 year old jumped on the side of the cart pulling the whole thing down. Miraculously I grabbed it (8 months pregnant) before my 1 1/2 year old hit the floor. He was buckled in, and literally his head was an inch from the floor as I held the heavy cart and tried to unbuckle him. After that I didn’t shop with all my kids for 6-8 years 😅. I just went late at night alone or did curbside.
Today, I love taking the 1 year old and anyone who is over 4-5 years old that doesn’t need constant potty breaks. Public bathrooms are so gross and 2 year olds love to visit them at every store!
I have so many thoughts on this because I never had a mom or husband to help me. You are right, it does eventually get easier.
Today with kids age 1-15 it is actually fun for my middles to go with me to Costco. Or it’s fun to leave the baby at home and take my teen boys and take advantage of their muscles. But the idea that mothers should/can take all their kids grocery shopping week after week for a big family (who needs tons of groceries) is so overly positive/optimistic! I admire your optimism but I am so grateful for curbside pickup for the years when you have many unpredictable littles.
Enjoyed your anecdotes, and of course as a mother of 7 I have many similar ones!
I am not loving the “overly optimistic” part at the end, though.
As I said over and over: be confident in your own rational assessment of your options and circumstances. This is not an either/or discussion and I don’t want to have to make disclaimers all the time.
I have a particular message to offer here and I trust everyone understands it.
I also wanted to come back and say I love your overall principles and focus on the big picture. There are two huge benefits to shopping with your kids (that I never considered or appreciated til now)… #1 older kids don’t need large amounts of time unsupervised at home (like preteen or teen boys, or any child depending on temperament.) It leads to sneakiness with internet, electronics, ice cream because they know for certain mom will be gone for x amount of hours. So for that reason I like to take my middle kids (even if they “can” stay home safely.) I’m already out of the house enough running kids to music lessons, appointment or therapy, so I see the huge benefit of mom being home/or the whole family going out together.
#2 The second benefit of doing shopping with kids, is by doing weekday shopping I was always able to avoid shopping on Sundays. That was really important to my husband and I, so we don’t make people work on Sundays. His job required him to work Monday-Saturday (agriculture) so I was often tempted to shop alone on Sundays, but I’m glad now that I never made that the solution. So we all do the best we can, but there are definitely huge benefits to figuring out how to shop with kids.
Oh, the bathroom trips! I became very adept at those and knew where the bathrooms were in EVERY store we frequented. It was the main reason I stopped shopping at our closest grocery store for about 5 years – the only bathrooms were for “staff” (although they would kindly let us use them), and up a flight of stairs. Not something I wanted to handle when pregnant, or with a toddler who is “gotta go NOW”.
This is a thinking ahead thing. You have to be sure to get them to the potty before leaving, and then be strict beforehand and REWARD them afterwards! Five M&Ms will do the trick haha… a small price to pay for not having to go to the public restroom at every stop.
I realized after Covid that my poor little one born early in 2021 had basically never been inside a store!! She was thrilled to go grocery shopping as a toddler! lol.
At my current stage, I mostly leave the errands and shopping to Daddy, since the newborn hates the car and would just scream all the way through any shopping trip. But the kids love going with him, and it’s great time spent with him, especially since I’m home with everyone 24/7 and he works long hours. Looking forward to the time when we start sending older kids in alone to shop! For now, we hand them a basket and ask them to go in pairs to get a few things in a different area of the store and meet back with us (or Dad) at a certain point. They love it and it saves us time!
I also agree about the point above that when you have all littles , errands are especially helpful and necessary to get through long days! I did lots and lots of these with 2 under 2, then 3 3 and under, etc. Great learning experiences for all of us, and I have the fondest memories of my 3 girls and all the little places we went together. Now with homeschooling 4 big kids and needing to dedicate lots of the day to that, I’m happy to employ curbside weekly and do other errands with different kids to get 1:1 or 1:2 time, or let Daddy take them as I mentioned. Lots of ways to get kids into the world, and as Auntie Leila says, people mostly get a big kick out of seeing a gaggle of kids enjoying real life with a parent!
Yes! My youngest was born in June of 2019 and was a delayed talker. He is the youngest of 6, so his “uh!” had at least 5 people to do or give him what he wanted, but I still think most of his trouble was that he didn’t go to the grocery store or even church in person during that formative baby/toddler year. He wasn’t passed around to all the little old ladies, he didn’t play with kids other than his siblings, he didn’t have the opportunity to have shoppers or clerks goo and ga over him once a week in the store. He’s fine now, but all of the kids love going to Costco (to get snacks) and the grocery store where they have “missions” to bring back to me in the cart.
I am the oldest of 11 and my Mom took us all to do the grocery shopping every week until I was 12 and able to babysit some of my siblings, then she would only tale some of them. We would bag our own groceries: and were very proud of doing it correctly: never smashing delicate items, and keeping categories together. I still unload my cart in order, keeping categories together. My Dad would take a few of us to get 3-5 forgotten items and we made it a game: everyone get their assigned items and meet at the checkout in 5 minutes. Whenever he paid cash, he challenged us to figure out the change before it appeared on the screen. And I still stop to determine price/unit the way he taught me.
I shop now with my oldest [9] and my youngest [8 months]. My oldest loves to fetch items while I wait at the deli, or peruse the meat counter. She has also exchanged items at the courtesy booth. I made it a point to remember the names of many of the workers at our usual store, so my kids say hello, Miss or Mr. Blank. But Walmart I do pickup, or shipping if possible, because it is bigger and…yuckier.
Also, since online shopping is necessary sometimes, my husband trained our children to greet deliverymen at the door, and say thank you. We also keep water bottles in our fridge during the summer to offer the deliverymen, which most of them appreciate. And we are on a first-name basis with our mailman.
Thank you, Auntie Leila, I needed to hear this. I have a 3 yr old and a 5 month old, and when the 3 yr old was about 12-18 months, I did take her on errands but without fail, I was always getting scolded by strangers for letting my child run down an aisle or something. It’s like I’d watch her the whole time, and then just in that brief 90 second window where I’m reading a label, someone has to see that, assume I’m a negligent mother and come over to make a snide comment. I even had a lady come up to my car and scold me when I was buckling my daughter in. So I stopped taking her places and let my husband do the grocery shopping. She does go with him frequently and greatly enjoys it, but you’re post has made me rethink my position on errands. I still appreciate having a husband who grocery shops (I know many women would love that!!) but I’m going to start making more of an effort to go to say, the library or craft store. My daughter clearly needs work talking to people, so glad to hear there’s a solution for that outside of endless playdates. (Our friends and family are all very spread out).
I’m really enjoying this conversation and wanting to chime in on your point about the strangers scolding. I do take my kids out, and we do work on life skills. So there’s that. However, we live in a resort town. Most of winter is wonderful. I find the workers at stores are the most kind, least judgy, and used to seeing kids around. But in the summer, when the summer residents come to their cottage (or 3rd or 4th home here), the comments are …not nice. I know I need to grow a thicker skin, but I also wonder what my kids think. Do they notice the comments? “That’s alot of kids” and “You have your hands full” are the most pleasant. I feel like I should stand up for my kids more but I am not a quick thinker and tend to freeze. Does anyone have any thoughts on this? I am doing my best to educate my kids, with my husband’s help when he’s not working. And I do see that often if i have the time to engage, there is the chance to just love someone, evangelize, and be friendly when out and about. But when it feels like it’s at my kids’ expense, what to do? (The oldest is 10 and we have 5 kids).
I get the same way when people make remarks such as “ you’re busy!” For a long time I just kind of used to chuckle and say “yeah” or something, but I eventually realized that a couple of stock, pro-kid responses such as “yes, but they’re so much fun!” Or “they’re a such a jolly crew” to have at my disposal was helpful. Occasionally people go so far as to say something legitimately rude like “you know you can do something about that!” Which really doesn’t warrant a civilized response, but for my children’s sake I still try to say something like“but they’re so lovely, who wouldn’t want so many!”
It’s often ingratiating and annoying but I just figure that people are trying to engage with something they don’t often see (a family with 4 kids in my case lol).
My Dad (with 11 kids) had some great comebacks, my favorite being: to “are these all your kids?!?” He would reply “These are only the ones in favor.”
Yes, I have to say I only once or twice ever encountered outright rudeness. Usually it was positive or borderline, and you are right, people are just trying to interact, and they are rather clueless about how to do it.
I would really advise everyone to put the best construction on whatever is said. People are trying to be funny, I guess, and then it comes out rude. I draw the line for indulgence at the point where the kids are hearing something negative and they need to hear mom’s response as an antidote. So that’s where you have to be clever, as you say! “We like them!” “God is good!” “Well, we do love each other a lot” (to anything remotely like do you know how to stop that, which is more of a bad conscience than anything!).
I have one response I give to every such comment: “We like them!”
It gets the message across while being absolutely unarguable. I mean, they can’t tell me that I don’t like my own kids, can they? And what a nice thing for my kids to hear! And it’s applicable to pretty much any snotty comment people can come up with, without sounding snide or rude itself.
“You have your hands full!”
“We like them!”
“Gosh, what a lot of kids.”
“We like them!”
“They must keep you busy.”
“We like them!”
I mean, really, what can anyone say back to that? And I’ve sometimes had it turn into a really nice and sometimes sad conversation.
“Wow, four kids!”
“We like them!”
“Yeah, I was one of four, we had such a lot of fun. We only had one, I wish we’d had more.”
I’m not a quick thinker, not confrontational, often rather shocked at people commenting on me in public. Having one sole stock response means I’m never at a loss for words.
(I have another stock response for really rude people, both adults and children: “I don’t really think that’s appropriate, do you?” Works for anything, tone of voice varies. But that’s for when I want to REALLY clap back! About once a year!)
I love “I like them.”
I would say to “you have your hands full” or “so many kids!” — God is good. When they say, “God bless you” in that “you’re crazy” way, I would say, “He has blessed me.”
It’s interesting to see people’s reaction when you praise Him in that situation.
Someone once told me, “Three blessings is ENOUGH.” I felt so bad for her! Now we have 5.
My saddest moment was when a woman at a restaurant looked at our bunch and said, loudly, WITH HER KIDS RIGHT THERE, “Oh God, my two are trouble enough!” or something so negative to that effect.
No wonder everyone is walking around feeling unwanted…
Sometimes I will respond to “You’ve got your hands full”, with, “It’s a good start”. I tried it out just now in response to all of the suggestions and it suited (and it sounds a little bit cheeky, which I liked).
If it helps, it really did feel like to me (growing up in an area where negative remarks about numbers of children were pretty free)- it felt like as my parents added more and more children there came a point, eight? nine? where most of the negativity dropped off. Either the numbers, or the older children growing older, I think people who normally felt like vocalizing figured my folks were too set in their ways and were not going to be dissuaded.
My parents were really good at letting is know we were their favorite people in the world so the negativity pretty much rolled off of us. And in our part of the world positivity has been pretty much the societal norm, my favorite being the dear older woman who remarked at my small entourage of preschoolers, infant and toddler, “You look like you need another one”.
So great!
Merry Christmas! Another benefit to in-person shopping for my children is understanding how money, sales, coupons, and unit prices work. Sometimes it goes better than others ie. eating their way through Costco. Other times, it’s not pretty but what doesn’t kill us, makes us stronger! Children don’t have to be particularly quiet or still in the grocery store and as you recommend, can snack their way through. It stretches us so that outings with small children aren’t hard and can be mostly fun. I have such admiration for military wives who have to do ALL of the things solo for months at a time. We can be a witness in our anti-family culture, if we normalize a gaggle of relatively well behaved children, with a cheerful mother in public. People comment because they notice…even if what they say is sometimes rude, they see us and that matters.
My friend has nine children and my favorite thing ever is that they all go grocery shopping together as a family after Mass on Sunday (since they live far from their favorite grocery stores and our parish is close to them).
Some get dropped at one store with dad and the others go with mom into the other. The oldest three are paired with the youngest three and I love that the 13 yr old boy walks around with the 3 yr old boy and they eat samples together til it’s time to go.
The 12 yr old boy gets half the grocery list and a cart and the mom tackles the other half. They come together at checkout and he also bags everything because he knows how it should all be organized so it’s put away efficiently at home by an older girl.
Said older girl came over as a mother’s helper one day and organized my pantry so well! I love this family.
I had forgotten those days, Leila – but you state it so well! It was worthwhile to bring kids shopping and on other errands, even if it was easier without them. I did usually try to limit it to 1-2 kids for a long trip like the grocery store, and put some kind of treat at the end (for them AND for me!)
Last year my oldest started driving. And I realized that she hadn’t been on many errands since COVID shutdowns when she was 12. So, we set about doing a LOT of that, and forcing her to step out of her comfort zone and run errands “alone” (with me in the car) – to the library, to pick up a few groceries, and even to put gas in the car. It only took a few months and now she’s confident to enter that aspect of the world like an adult. She and I have speculated that many kids in highschool and college are so uncomfortable with simple errands like this, and that explains some of the explosion of DoorDash (and other delivery services) among that group.
The lockdown was so destructive.
It grieves me!!
You handled the consequences there just right.
I also have a few happy comments to add. My friend who has 7 children had a family rule that whenever mom or dad left the house, a kid went with them. I don’t know how they did the rotation. This gave the kids lots of time out and lots of regular dates with a parent. I really like this plan and we use it often.
Also I remember my mom regularly picking up a snack for us at the start of grocery shopping which we would eat in the cart. I remember thinking as a very young child, how my mom understood how things worked so well, that she could just take something and pay for it later, and was so calm and cheerful when we were out. Of course those weren’t my child thoughts, but the general impression. The world seemed too big and mysterious to me, when we ventured farther than our tiny corner store and our safe street where everyone knew me.
After I had my second I became kind of immobilized by exhaustion and started to think it was just completely impossible to take my two under two out of the house by myself. Eventually I really started to miss the outside world too much and it dawned on me that it was one of those things that I just had to force myself to do so that I could figure out how to make it work by actually doing it. Now it is such a nice little outing for us all just to go grocery shopping and really helps add some variety to our week.
Forcing yourself and thinking things through — not to mention learning from experience, even painful experience — is underrated!
Opportunity for growth!
I’m a data privacy lawyer, and the point about data collection unfortunately doesn’t only apply to home delivery; if you’re using a loyalty card at the store, or even paying by card at the store, home delivery isn’t providing any ‘extra’ data to the store. So I wouldn’t avoid it for that reason.
That said, taking kids on errands is part of life and can be good for them (not least because they learn that the world doesn’t revolve around them). There’s no reason why families shouldn’t do both, and goodness knows we needed enough groceries to do both. I particularly enjoyed home delivery when I was pregnant, as the delivery guy would lift heavy packages for me. In my country it gets carried right into your kitchen, which is wonderful and has its own set of social interactions for the kids to watch.
As I understood it, the argument in the video was about a third party managing data across all the stores and the implications for competition.
Yes, when you use a loyalty card you are allowing the store to collect information about what you are buying and so on. You make a decision that getting rewards and discounts is worth it to you, and the store promises you to keep things private. It’s of course hard to know what other uses that data is being put to and whether you can trust that.
But there is another level here having to do with consolidating all those actions on the consumer’s part for a third or more universal party. (I don’t think those making the video had hard conclusions about it all.)
There is definitely an issue with ordering one’s goods online, especially food, where you can’t compare apples with apples so to speak (as you can compare a particular brand of toaster, for instance, very quickly). The point being made is that the actual price might be changing for you, based on your habits.
This is more an economic issue in a larger sense. Where food prices are extremely sensitive — demand is quite inelastic — and have very low margins for profit, the incentive is to tamper with demand and, most of all, information. That’s why the trend in the past quarter century has been to process food more and more: you can make more on oats if you put them in some fancy form in an appealing box than if you offer them straight up as a grain in a cardboard package.
As I understand it, removing price consciousness, which online ordering provides the opportunity for the store to do, maximizes this advantage.
Mothers simply need to be aware that the price being shown on the screen might be tailored to them. You might be shown, say, $4 per pound for that beef and I might be shown $4.50 — and how would we know? But if a third party is managing the information, no one has the incentive to tell us – that’s price fixing. It takes away Acme’s incentive to lower their price as against Giant’s.
This is a new situation, and not at all like going to the store and seeing the item’s price as it is offered to everyone. Not to mention the ones in a bin, nearing their expiration (but not too close to it), on clearance. I know that my margins, in my budget, rely on being able to pick up those things. (For instance, the grocery store I usually shop at offers lots of meat marked down as it nears its sell-by date and has bins in a certain aisle with half-price items they are clearing out.) Everyone should know that when you shop online, those deals are never going to be offered to you.
It’s all about information. When you have the information, you can then make your determination rationally that yes, it’s worth it to me to pay an extra dollar on that item because it will come to my door and my kids are sick, or no, we all need to get out and get some air.
I don’t think many of us were thinking that we might not be paying the same amount for something as another mom ordering the same thing, or even if that’s not the case right now, that our habits could make it possible in the future.
I was thinking about this very topic recently because I still take a gaggle of my kids shopping most of the time and I usually get really positive reactions that give me a nice boost. I tend to see even neutral comments as positive though because I am very extraverted and am happy when people actually talk to me! I concentrate on taking the youngest with me instead of leaving them home with the handy teenagers (I now have) because my teenagers are so awesome because I took them shopping and I want the younger set to be just as awesome. I noticed when I am always leaving my younger kids with my older kids instead of interacting with them that the quality of parenting is somewhat diminished. Lots of time I take everybody anyways because I like the company and it is good for everyone to get out and about and see the world (especially homeschoolers). Homeschoolers used to have a reputation as being very social because they got to talk to lots of different types of people going about with their parents. I fear this reputation is no longer justified.
What do you all do about scandal, little eyes seeing immodesty in public? Do I worry unnecessarily? Do I keep them home and protect them? Talk about it that we live differently out of respect for ourselves,bout neighbors, and our Lord? As has been discussed, there are lots of benefits to learning to handle oneself in public. We have a 6 year old, 3 year old, and 1 year old. I bring them with me for most errands I mostly do have groceries delivered for the time savings.
I guess I’d be curious what you mean! But I bet it comes down to not taking your kids (or even not going yourself) to places where things are that bad! I pretty much avoid the public library with the kids during June/pride month but otherwise we go together and I am in charge of what we check out. Once my kids are more fluent readers I’m sure I’ll have to be more concerned with certain things like objectionable displays at the library or elsewhere, supermarket tabloids, etc. I’m trying to imagine other aspects that wouldn’t be covered by “avoid going to sketchy places” and “talk about situations that come up in age appropriate ways”
My mom does talk about the situation when I was young which I don’t remember at all. I guess our parish would have newspapers for sale outside that lots of people picked up on their way into Mass (this seems very weird to me idk!) and my mom would have to flip over the papers of those sitting in front of us for fear that I, a precocious reader, would see the details of the Clinton-Lewinsky trial!
I understand the problem. But really, the only solution to never seeing that sort of thing is never leaving the house!
I think it’s better not to make it a bigger deal than it is. Advertisements featuring scantily clad women or inappropriate text? Ignore them. Your children will see that you don’t live your life like that. If they ask? Simple answers.
“Why is that lady in her underwear?” “Some people think it’s appropriate to appear like that in public. We don’t do that in our family.”
That said, one thing I love about living rurally is that we never see billboards any more! I once wrote to the local transport network when we lived in the city about advertisements for adult “supplements”. They wrote back and apologised.
Little by little, remind them that there are lots of things we can’t help seeing but should try not to look at and think about. This is “custody of the eyes” and applies to everyone, actually, about all sorts of things. It’s a habit to build. You can also be alert to if something has actually disturbed them. Having a time (like tucking them in bed) when you can ask, “Is anything bothering you? You can tell me” — and then you have the opportunity to say that we don’t have to think thoughts that others have burdened us with, but that God makes us free. We can think about the beautiful things. But that you know it can hurt to see ugly and bad things.
And of course, we don’t want to inflict bad things on them intentionally! But sometimes it’s unavoidable.
Some places are way worse than others. People make fun of me for living in Massachusetts, such a liberal state, but I would say our billboards on the highway are a lot more modest and fewer altogether than in many supposedly more conservative states I’ve driven in!
Thank goodness the pride/rainbow thing seems to be on the wane, but then, Halloween seems to be getting worse. We have to pray and really try to protect our children but also get them out and about. Only you can know your circumstances!
So glad you are bringing up the circ topic. It is barbaric and not biblical (the way it’s done now). Teach hygiene, don’t slice up innocent babies. The church actually forbids non therapeutic amputations, so that’s something to consider too.
As far as errands go, there are plenty of ways to socialize a kid without most of them. There’s not even such a thing as a local store for many of us. I dont think it’s necessary to go back to the 90s to create opportunities for well adjusted kids. Things evolve. I have a great community where the kids have ample opportunity to see people and behave. (In part this is thanks to my parents who DID have to take us on ALL the errands in the 90s because we were home schooled and there was no internet! But they should have not HAD to do this. They should have had better school options. Why is this the standard?) I don’t have to take everyone out, so I don’t. Things change with different generations. Usually, but not always for worse.
I’ve always taken my children out but lately I feel that shopping during the day is just violating their privacy. People constantly ask them (not me), “Don’t you have school?” There is only one weekday we might do errands during the day, and I tend to shy away from it. We have full days of lessons during weekdays, so I’m not trying to fill hours anymore – but I do look back on all those hours at Costco and Hobby Lobby with little ones under school age fondly!
However, we’ve also had lovely conversations in stores with people who say things like they also had 5 children, or are 1 of 11 children, etc (also plenty of rude comments). I’m not nervous about or annoyed with my children, I’m mostly concerned about adults in their business. Is this something I just need to get over? I don’t know.
So much depends on your circumstances, and only YOU know what they are. Certainly, so much negativity is not going to be good.
I will say that one time I had most of my kids with me and as we were checking out, the girl looked at me not in a very smiling way and said, “Do you live across from the high school?” (The store was in a different town so I got on my guard right away.)
“Yes…” (guardedly)
“I see you every day when I’m in my math class. I see your kids playing outside. They look so happy. I want that some day.”
So all I can say is that you don’t necessarily know what is behind those looks.
But as always, put your children first and use your best judgement!
Thank you so much for the circ link! More moms need to hear that this is an issue, because even being aware that you don’t have to let this happen is huge. I am forever grateful to the mom who, before I had met my husband or knew I was going to get married, was willing to be the “weirdo” who didn’t allow her sons to be circumcised and was willing to say so. I thought there was something wrong with her until I got past my mental block, broadened my perspective a little, and learned what the procedure actually entailed. Now, with two boys so far, I am mystified that anyone thinks this is okay or even morally licit to do without clear and emergent medical necessity. Cleanliness with an intact baby is so easy, I can’t believe that’s an argument: just wipe the outside and otherwise leave it alone. When he is older, if you have water, you can keep any child clean—end of story. The downsides are legion, the benefits are negligible or nonexistent, and finally, there’s a reason they don’t allow the mother in the room during the procedure…
Honestly, it shocks me that so many ostensible conservatives are defensive of this. We can’t stand gender reassignment surgeries, why? Because they mutilate healthy body parts. Now, circ doesn’t necessarily entail the same denial of male and female identity, but it’s still mutilation of a healthy body part, and I would argue on the same spectrum but with fewer complicating ideological factors. Let’s be consistent in our rhetoric here!