Behavior Corner
Children really do have to learn how to behave, and they have to learn how to behave across the board, including in Church. Yes, children misbehave and we need to be tolerant, but also yes, they should try not to and we can get them in a better position.
Everyone has their strategies for Church (I do too), but step back for a minute.
Let’s not talk about that part of it. Let’s talk about the big picture.
How can we ask a little tike who does not really know what happens when you go out of the room, or anything about when the next meal is, or where his clothing that’s on his body comes from, to sit still and not holler for an hour once every seven days?
So, long before we get into strategies and tactics, we have to address daily acclimation to the quite foreign notion that this little bundle of energy coupled with ignorance can and will rein himself in.
Obviously it will take some time, and at first a lot of it will be you, the parent, not expecting too much… but also expecting more and more… discipline, thought of as normal experience in self control and awareness of others.
The prevailing ideology today is permissiveness and placation masquerading as “gentle parenting.”* Parents are deathly afraid of being judged and for the most part, try to placate children instead of simply teaching them, in a developmentally appropriate manner, to notice the world around them and to meet reasonable expectations, including by using sharp words and even a spank now and again.
*Or the equally ridiculous reaction, where small children are rigidly disciplined with no insight on the part of parents at all; however, this is much less common.
Honestly, we expect more of our dogs than of our kids.
But no “trainer” is going to come and get your child into shape, nor would you want that, of course.
Instead, build into your daily life with your child times when he has to sit still, listen to you, not speak, and pay attention to what is going on outside of himself. Alternated, of course, with running around outside and yelling their heads off. Again, these are the little things of life.
During the day, the expectation that a three-year-old can start learning not to burst into a room shouting; an eighteen-month-old can sit in a stroller for a walk; a two-year-old can imitate your whisper; a six-year-old can sit for a lesson.
This is why I say it’s important to ask him to put on a jacket when going outside, if the weather requires it. He can take it off later, but honestly, do you not see that this is training? We are living in a world where we don’t have to wear one thing we don’t want to, but is that healthy? How will he behave at a funeral or wedding? How will getting out the door on the day of an important event play out if every normal day is Mom giving in?
Toddlers don’t want to put on their jackets and mittens or put on their shoes or what have you. Sometimes it doesn’t matter, but actually, a lot of times it does. He has to have practice for the times it does! It’s unfair to expect obedience in important things when you never require it otherwise.
There is a way to make it “just what we do” and not a struggle. I know there is because generations of children did it… and no, they weren’t “repressed”! They had far less emotional difficulties than children today do. Stability and knowing what’s require of one go a long way to mental health, actually.
Why would we adopt the standards of a society that has so clearly failed its children? Why would we follow their advice?
Practice in little things so you can reasonably expect big things.
I can’t even get into the issue of how weird our society has become with the bottom falling out of normal interactions in public — instead of going to the grocery store or post office and seeing and dealing with lots of people in a pleasant manner, we just do everything by clicking. I am not sure how our kids are going to learn how to greet the postman or not clamor for treats in some building out and about. We have to think about it…
My main point here is to be sure to have each day require something of your child — with cheerfulness and a sense of confidence — at various points, so that on Sunday he’s not suddenly expected to sit up in his church clothes and be quiet, with no practice.
“Now it’s time to put these toys away and get ready for lunch. I’ll help you.”
“Go back out and come in again without slamming the door, and speak in a lower voice!”
“Please ask to be excused.”
“Now it’s time to rest quietly.”
You have to practice too. You have to ask it of yourself. It’s called being a responsible parent!
Knitting Corner
I finished the socks last week and started a couple of things in that antsy way when you can’t really settle down. I’m trying not to buy more yarn right now, and the effort of fitting a pattern I want to do with the yarn I have is making me unsettled.
The socks:
The kitty (I got hung up on the short rows but I think I’m past it — the pattern didn’t make sense to me but I’m just plowing through):
The Good Mouse (I’m using some of the yarn I have, from the Musselburgh hats).
Another pair of scrappy socks for a child, but… who?
Those two projects (to give a grandiose name) are outside by the fire — today is maple sap boiling day! — so I can’t show you, but I will probably post on Instagram and catch up next week.
bits & pieces
- The fading art of hand embroidery –– for liturgical vestments; we women have to keep these beautiful crafts alive!
- For your high school student: A good primer on causes, from a scientific and philosophical point of view.
- By the way, every once in a while I have to remind you of this book, speaking of science and philosophy: Vestige of Eden, Image of Eternity: Common Experience, the Hierarchy of Being, and Modern Science by Daniel Toma (affiliate link)
- I remember reading in Annie Dillard’s book, An American Childhood, her memory of her mother exclaiming “check the oxygen!” — it relates to this sad episode and amazing discovery by a brave doctor: Excessive oxygen as cause of blindness in premature infants. It’s an important memory, because the ophthalmologist Dr. Arnall Patz, didn’t follow “settled science” but made his own observations and saved babies from blindness.
from the archives
liturgical living
follow us everywhere!
Here is all the info:
Visit me at The School for Housewives and recommend it to your young friends!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them has moved over to Substack! — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing! The old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts.
There you will find the weekly podcast done by Phil and me, called On the Home Front. Do let us know what you think!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
I keep this site ad-free, but you can support me these ways:
Using my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit.
Buying me a skein or two of yarn! (This will appear on your credit card as “Domus Enterprises” — please remember!)
Thank you!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen: Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
My old podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) if you haven’t heard them.
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest







Preach!
As almost all my kids are now grown, I can only reaffirm Auntie Leila’s words here about practicing the behavior. Learning how to sit at dinner is one of the very best things you can do to help your littles. Of course, you have to start with very low expectations, but increase them as the child grows. By the time he is 4 or 5, the neurotypical kid should be able to sit at the table with you for at least 15 minutes (and he should be able to do his nightly chore — unloading the silverware or carrying laundry baskets or whatever, directly after). He should be able to behave with manners without constant reminders.
This means you have to discipline your own self to have a sit-down dinner together as a family most nights of the week. I cannot stress to young moms how important it is to make this a priority. Sometimes I look back and think that dinner together literally held everything together through all the years of homeschooling, sickness, husband working full time and in school in the evenings, no money, messy house, messy life. I have to say that, aside from the sacramental life, this one practice is the one that will produce the greatest rewards if stuck to no matter what.
Good advice and advice I have explored at length.
But let’s not use that “neurotypical” jargon, okay? Let’s re-read The Miracle Worker and resolve not to provide easy excuses for our children.
Amen! We’re there and have come to just say – you start where you start. A nudge here, a little help there. But my most challenged child will eventually need to (and likely be able to) use a spoon and fold a napkin, (I love that part of Miracle Worker best!! When the mother is stupefied and nearly in tears hearing that her daughter folded her napkin), and just plain sass can be plenty of a problem for the easy ones some days. Life, and dinner, can be so messy, but the small successes are sweet. Hugs!
Yes!
And it’s good to have our challenged children grow in awareness of things and especially people around them — according to their abilities. They still have an inner life. They still must not be self-centered. These are matters of prayer, but so important. We can be the means of unlocking a great spirit.
Yes! I think about this all the time. It’s frighteningly easy to think that our days at home with little ones only matter in terms of keeping them alive, hence the staying in PJs all day and eating off paper plates tragedies. But home is a place for the Littles to practice being Big in a place with a big safety net!
Thanks for talking about this 🙂
Would LOVE to hear more thoughts on helping kids succeed in church – we have a 3 y.o. and a baby, hopefully more in the future, and I am always looking for good insight on this topic.
Some ideas:
1. If your parish is family friendly (sadly some aren’t), sit right up front. Being able to see can be a huge help to young kids in following and not going right to naughtiness. And when you have to take someone to the back, everyone understands. When child is in back, no running around. Make it clear that Mama or Daddy is still praying. Kneel at the consecration, even when in the back, and have the child do so too for as long as he can without shrieking. Remember that kids under the age of 2 are really little more than babies and you just have to be gentle and consistent while they get the picture.
We used to bring snacks but quit that. We found that the promise of a Sunday treat after Mass, for reasonable behavior, did help the over 3 yo kids. But every kid is different.
Special books with really good pictures. Don’t get ugly cartoony pictures of Bible stories. Pictures that absorb a child’s interest.
Best for new parents, which you still are: sit behind a family with slightly older kids who DO behave! the reason you have to work on this now is that younger kids will often observe and copy what they see older kids doing. Your two littles right now might benefit from that good peer pressure. And they will, God willing, later be the oldest brother and sister, who will model this good behavior to your younger ones, and your job then will be easier!
As I said in the post, today we are not talking about strategies.
I would prefer the comments not devolve into “snacks vs. snacks” etc.
There is a larger point to be made!
I wrote about it here, but as I say, the first step is the OTHER six days! For real!
https://likemotherlikedaughter.org/2023/11/ask-auntie-corner-baby-sleep-church-behavior-and-more/
That was me replying to Rachel above! My computer autofilled her name! 😉
I will try to edit it.
This is SOOOO true! I have to shout it! We have had a terrible month of two funerals, a thousand miles of driving (no, I just did the math…2,500 miles over two trips), lots of sitting around, being polite and grave, being good guests, dinners, services…. My four children, 7 and younger, rose to the demands and then some, just amazed me and my husband. We were just marveling about their behavior, saying this is it, this is where all that dragging them to Mass, all that calling them back to the table, all that sitting quietly while we wait our turn, this is where we cash that all in and it really matters. They could run around pleasantly, chat politely, sit mostly quietly, and be in the room for some really important moments. Excuse my gushing, but I’m really proud of these kids and it has been such a terrible stretch. But it all started at the dinner table – and we keep going forward from here.
Thank you! What a lovely post. Encouraging as we’re seeing fruit with older kids and right in the trenches with the little ones. Having enough good behavior in church so parents can actually worship is such a blessing. One of the huge gifts of the liturgy! Having the same words, so I don’t have to hold anything besides the wiggler, and so I can think them over in the middle of the night wakings when things are actually quiet. Hang in there, everyone! A little at a time.
Following your archive links, I’m loving the book on temperaments. Thank you!
Thank you for the point of view! It’s so helpful to see things in larger context. Many comments mentioned dinner–we’re still dinner with the barbarians phase (like the really terrible ones). Question: can you please provide your jewels of wisdom for various age ranges? My worst behaved child right now is my almost 8 year old! I can handle the toddler just fine. Send help!
You have to be strict. Your husband has to be strict and you have to let him.
Set out the expectations, choose one or two things to work on, and make them happen.
“Go to your room” is a fine punishment. No explanations — remember, the expectations were set beforehand, kindly and with assurance that you’re on his side.
I don’t know what’s going on, but for me, nothing progresses until children can learn to express themselves without “attitude” — so being polite (“this is not my favorite, thank you, I did have a bite” vs. “I hate this stuff”) is the starting point for a child this age.
If he comes to the table with a good attitude and no sulking, things will go much better.
I think you will find that the root problem is focusing on self instead of others. “Ask your dad how his day went” can be a magical remedy, as is asking that child to get up to get things for the sibling who has a need, wipe the baby, etc.
Don’t forget “kid quiet time” — 10 minutes of focusing on eating and remaining silent so mom and dad can have a conversation!
I love all the advice and I love the first photo of your kitchen. You really achieved your vision, Auntie Leila! Those amazing windows all around the sink!
Thank you! I love how the kitchen turned out and am very grateful for it. The window…
“Honestly, we expect more of our dogs than of our kids.”
Ouch. I have been working over the past year to right the ship after being infected with some “gentle parenting” philosophy when my oldest (now 3) was a baby. It’s amazing how much more pleasant he is with firmer discipline and boundaries. Low and behold, he declared a few months ago he would “not go cry room at all” and has mostly been making it through our long liturgies.
Thank you for the wisdom you offer us millennial-and-younger moms! It is truly dispiriting sometimes the way ill-behaved children are over-running our lives. It is so hard to have conversations with other mothers in social gatherings because of the interrupting, whiny children. Yet we so desperately need to talk to each other!
Your point about millennial moms and conversations being interrupted constantly resonated with me! Boy, its a real problem. Why is it exactly you think? Often times I would love to visit with a friend, but I don’t because I know the friends kids will be so disruptive….and these are good families! Kids constantly wanting something and the house is totally filthy afterwards. I wonder if I just need to accept it for the good of getting to know a friend, but its exhausting! I remember in my homeschool group growing up never talking or going over to the adults 🙂 too busy playing with the kids! My mom would tell us to leave her alone unless we were bleeding lol sigh. Its so different now and I am not sure always how to navigate.
One of my pet peeves is talking to a friend then their kid comes over and the parent just completely cuts our conversation and is absorbed in the kid wanting this or that. The world revolves around the kid! I gotta work on fighting it with my own.
Oh my! I thought the messy aftermath of a visit was just my pet peeve and poor management. Maybe there is more at play. That i and our Friends have fallen into a pattern of not expecting much from our kids
It makes me feel very grateful to my parents because this is precisely how they raised me and my siblings. And it is hopefully how I will raise my future children.
I love all the advice. Some of us have been here 10+ years now! I would love to hear more about teens. I guess they are kind of like giant toddlers. But it’s so hard. I have one boy who is turning into someone I don’t recognize. The small rebellions of disobedience (will not wear a coat for love or money), the moodiness, the isolating himself from the rest of the family, the constant obsession with girls…I have tried and tried to tell him it’s not time yet, but he’s obsessed! Help!
Time for Dad! Dad has to step in and talk to him. Some issues have to be framed as “you live here and so have to be respectful” and only Dad can really have this conversation, though Mom can say her piece when she knows she’s backed up in their private conversations.
Search this blog for 13-year-old boys and also chastity and dating.
Does he have other things to think about? I look back on my boy- crazy self and cringe! I was a “good girl” etc but really cringe at how much time I spent obsessing over boys! some of it is the age, some is my romantic nature fueled by books and movies, but some of it is I really didn’t have other things that engaged my attention. I stopped playing an instrument, I couldn’t draw, I wasn’t in nature enough to observe, school was easy…No idea how different boys are but just a thought.
Dear Emma, Thank you for responding! He has tons of homework (and difficulty staying on task) that keeps him busy all night and everyday. He is constantly listening to sad or romantic songs, depending on his mood. He takes care of our pets and has chores. He has always been very sensitive to beauty since a small child (when we first joined the Catholic church from a Protestant background, he looked around at the Catholic church we were in for the first time with stars in his eyes and said, “Mommy, how do you spell beautiful?”) He’s very creative and a true romantic, a poet at heart.
He participates in theater and choir after and before school (which is mostly comprised of girls), thus the ever present problem. The thing is he really loves theater and choir, and I’m afraid to pull him from these things.
I just don’t know how to deal with this. My husband doesn’t really do “talks.” He has plainly told me he doesn’t know what to do either… and has a natural tendency to avoid conflict. I’m not sure the hubs completely agrees with me on the waiting to date thing which doesn’t help. He has tried to consider what I have to say about it, but it makes it harder that he doesn’t feel as strongly about it as I do.
It’s like the boy is just falling for any girl that looks his way. When she moves away (he seems to only fall in love with seniors), his heart is broken, and he repeats the cycle with some new girl. We have two years left of high school. It has been hell every single day. He is highly emotional/moody/dramatic and falls hard for people (repeatedly). His moods are either very up or very down. People keep telling me this is just “normal” teen behavior or development. I’m just not convinced.
We’re trying to get the boy to go running with my husband to at least get more time with him to have opportunities for “talks”, but it’s hard with the homework and the practices and the sheer stubbornness of the boy who is not athletically inclined (or interested) in the least to either exercise or spend time with his family.
Exercise is super important especially for those not playing sports. My husband’s dad made him do this! If you’re an “arts kid,” fine, but your health matters. (It also matters for emotional health and moods!!) our local summer swim team is not very competitive, they just swim an hour a day all summer- is there something like that near you?
Can you pull the plug on the sad/romantic music??? Homework is not so engaging as other tasks like building things or painting things- would he want to do either?
Does he need to go to school??
Just some thoughts from someone whose oldest is 11… take it for what it’s worth…
I always think how Mass has been so instrumental in my children’s lives for obvious reasons but also because it’s taught them to be quiet and respectful, and they see other children doing the same! They are 5 and 3.5 and both sit quietly through the TLM. I used to take them out if they got loud and never made a big deal out of it. Now my 3.5 yr old son goes to daily 7 AM Mass with my husband some days. And he just went to the men’s group meeting with him and sat for an hour at the picnic table and ate snacks while they all talked. He’s also totally loud at home and at the park. He just understands when to be quiet!
For those interested in more info on hand embroidery, you might want to check out the website Needle n’ Thread by Mary Corbet. I’ve met her in person and she is a wonderful Trad. Catholic woman who’s been embroidering for years and also does vestment embroidery too. In a world where many crafting social media accounts or websites are just enthusiastic amateurs only one or two steps ahead of the total newbie, she is the real deal if you want to learn embroidery. (And I say this as someone who also knows embroidery and was taught as a child.)