{Baby Jesus is going back in the drawer, don’t worry. He’s just there because this post will be up after Christmas!}
Today I’m tying up some Advent ends. We will take a break and see you in the New Year! Keep up your Advent — tomorrow and in the coming early week. It’s well worth it to stand athwart the premature celebration, all the better to rejoice when the time is right.
So much nice conversation in the comments from last week’s post! Thank you for sharing all your Twelve Days Days of Christmas thoughts. It does my heart good!
Regarding Christmas dinner and starting new traditions, I loved all the comments there too.
Over the years I noticed the difference between Thanksgiving and Christmas, feast-wise, especially because I am always going to be trying to maximize holiday food.
The difference: Thanksgiving has its certain dishes (for us New Englanders, it’s written in stone, so I’ve gone with that), and abundance is what it’s all about.
If I’m not serving many different side dishes and relishes and at least four kinds of pie, am I even a Pilgrim. Thanksgiving is all about the food.
On Christmas, there is so much going on liturgically, magically, visually, and especially gift-wise, including all the little stocking treats, and Mom is so stretched in so many ways, and children are so very, very tired from waking up at the crack of dawn to race downstairs, that I found it was best to have a sort of rich simplicity.
A big breakfast, yes, but preferably one that can be made in advance, like Night-Before Breakfast Casserole and Chocolate Babka.
If you notice you receive a lot of date-nut/cranberry sort of breads, stollen, panettone, etc, from wonderful friends, you realize your job is to get some protein into them and it will all be very festive without a ton of effort.
Our dinner is appetizers like home-cured salmon, liver pâté, lots of nice cheeses and charcuterie, stuffed mushrooms brought by a guest, not me, etc.
I prefer a big roast to turkey, as we have had our fill of turkey at Thanksgiving and a bird actually requires more attention than a roast beef, roast leg of lamb, or pork loin (or porchetta) with an easy wine-enriched gravy. I like to emphasize a generous main dish over many side-dishes, for which the candy-laden appetite is not amenable.
We have had goose or duck, but I’d rather leave that for another day of Christmas. A festive salad, scalloped potatoes, and rolls. Dessert is Plum Pudding and of course all the cookies and chocolates the children have been looking forward to.
Our Suki for years had to deal with her surgeon husband being on call on Christmas Day. Her solution was to offer an extended, hearty charcuterie-appetizer spread, from which he could be called away and not actually ruin anything. This has become their family tradition, even now when he is senior enough to get the day off.
I encourage you, if you are still thinking about it, to reach back into whatever ethnic heritage you might have. Children really need that continuity! They love to know that this is what Grandma served or that is what Grandpa had.
I also encourage you to make Christmas Eve meatless. You can do it. Feasting is truly more meaningful if we give something up, for the sake of God, first. The “rules” are really reminders to adhere to this universal pattern. We are readying ourselves for the encounter that will shortly occur.
Traditional Christianity can turn even a small deprivation into something joyful — that’s where the “seven fishes” custom comes from. We can’t help making an abstinence situation into an act of generosity, and that’s a good thing. However, I would also say it’s good to keep it simple when you’re one mom with no aunties and grandmas around to do their thing. One fish is plenty! And it can be sardines. You don’t need your kitchen to be chaotic all day every day in this season. Quite the contrary.

As to the question of Midnight Mass, which also came up in the comments, this might vary from year to year, but it’s worth going for if the circumstances allow. Be practical, but also don’t worry about turning things upside down once a year!
If you lay the coats on the pew (and sit where it’s not too bright), often the littles will just go to sleep. They will always remember the feeling of being carried into the house as they wake up just a little, only to be tucked into their cozy beds. On the other hand, they may refuse to fall asleep at Mass and lesson learned for next year!
Midnight Mass means a slow Christmas morning, although, be forewarned, your hyped-up children will undoubtedly still wake up at some ungodly hour. However, once having opened a few presents and had their breakfast, they may be able to be coaxed into naps early. Another reason to keep the dinner festive but simple.
If you don’t go to Midnight Mass, you can perhaps get them to bed early on Christmas Eve (“Santa only comes when you are asleep!”), have your cozy morning, and then head out for a later Mass during the day. And as I say, it will probably change from year to year and that’s fine. Once the older kids get older, they will tell you what they want to do and you will just have to do it! You didn’t know they would eventually run things, did you!
bits & pieces
- The Death and Burial of Br. John Aidan Cook — a beautiful reflection on the short life of a humble man
- Exquisite Rot: Spalted Wood and the Lost Art of Intarsia
- In case you are fighting this “religious exemption” battle: ‘Checkmate’: U.S. Supreme Court Delivers Huge Win for Religious Exemptions
from the archives
A post I wrote some time ago, with pictures from our Christmas Eve and a reflection on the mystery.
liturgical living
Fourth of the O Antiphons, O Clavis David (O Key of David).
Tomorrow: Fourth Sunday of Advent!
follow us everywhere!
Here is all the info:
Visit me at The School for Housewives and recommend it to your young friends!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them has moved over to Substack! — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing! The old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts.
There you will find the weekly podcast done by Phil and me, called On the Home Front. Do let us know what you think!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
I keep this site ad-free, but you can support me these ways:
Using my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit.
Buying me a skein or two of yarn! (This will appear on your credit card as “Domus Enterprises” — please remember!)
Thank you!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen: Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
My old podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) if you haven’t heard them.
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest





Although I am Pennsylvania Dutch by upbringing, our go-to Christmas dinner for decades has been tamales. I learned how to make them from a friend who grew up in New Mexico, and when possible we get together early in December and make many dozens to freeze. On Christmas morning, you pop an appropriate number in a steamer pot, turn it on low, and dinner is ready whenever you are. In fancy years there can be rice and beans on the side, but salsa and sour cream are enough. You do need to check the water level in the steamer occasionally…
I look forward to the day when we can go to Midnight mass with our children. Right now we live half an hour away from our church and the children really cannot stay awake that late so we have small meatless meals until we go to the 6:00 mass and then get home around 8pm and…it’s Christmas! (Or close enough). We usually have an Acadian meat pie warming up in the oven on low with charcuterie and cookies and then we put on the Christmas music we’ve been waiting all Advent to listen to, decorate the tree together and open Christmas jammies and off to bed. I think the children have come to anticipate that tradition as much (or more for our oldest!) than Christmas morning. A blessed last week of Advent to you and yours, Auntie Leila!
That sounds perfect! Truly!
You didn’t know they would eventually run things, did you!
I have been reading your writing for many years and I have been blessed by your thoughtful encouragement this Advent in your school for housewives. I smiled when I read this post tonight because 10 minutes ago I was sitting with my husband in the kitchen sipping tea while my oldest daughter 22 was making her third batch of homemade glass candy with her 15 year old sister sous chef and her 12 year old brother dusting with powder sugar. And as I watched them it occurred to me- they are doing this now! We are sitting and not even asking! They are just doing the traditions enthusiastically on their own while we watch!
I didn’t realize it- they would eventually run the preparations!
Aw, what a blessing! See??
XOXO
Would you please kindly provide the recipe for those cookies with the chopped nuts? Thank you. Refrigerator cookies? Those cookies look scrumptious. Merry Christmas!
Yes! These are my husband’s mother’s Butterscotch Cookies.
I will transcribe as written (she absolutely just scrawled out the recipe when I asked her for it, and I will tell you now that she made it with pecans for me, since I’m allergic to walnuts, and I do not remember her ever putting chocolate chips in it — in the photo you see I made it with almonds, which is what I had, and if you do this, add 1/4 tsp. almond extract):
Mix:
I
1 c. brown sugar
1 egg well beaten
1/2 c. butter softened
+
II
1 3/4 c. flour sifted with
1/4 tsp. salt
1/2 tsp. soda
1/2 tsp. vanilla
Add 1 c. walnuts chopped fine
1/2 c. or more choc. chips
Line a bread pan with wax paper
Put mixture in this + refrigerate covered for several hrs or overnight.
Slice thin + bake at 400 degrees F on middle shelf until golden brown
Store in tightly covered tin container.
Many thanks. Perfect. Coming up at our house.
My girls brought to me the other night 4 “programs” for the 12 days of Christmas–a piano recital of Christmas songs, a Nativity skit, a Nutcracker performance, and… I forget, poetry recitation, maybe? They were illustrated in the style of our 12 Days of Christmas calendar and the girls told me I could fit them in with whatever else I have planned for the 12 days. Already starting to run things and only ages 2-11!
Our one and only attempt at Midnight Mass scarred us, lol. Our parish changed the Christmas morning schedule this year (to earlier) and we are still trying to figure out how to make it work without the morning being a stressful rush. We are praying and praying for another baby but I guess if it doesn’t happen that means we are closer to Midnight Mass being an option…
I married into an Italian family, so we do seven fishes (some are easy–like smoked salmon, tuna dip with crackers) and then on Christmas, wedding soup and homemade ravioli and meatballs. Both at my in-laws’ house, because they are two very distinct events/celebrations and we have to go to both!
Daughters really do take over! At such a tender age LOL!
Love it.
My Italian husband didn’t grow up with the seven fishes but we liked the idea of a cultural tradition so we do it in our family. For a few years, I tried to do elaborate dishes… I burned out on that pretty quickly. Now, we keep it all very simple and we like it so much better that way. Shrimp cocktail, various seafood dips, bisque, steamed mussels… There are seven of us, and we all have our “must-haves” for this meal. This year, my kids were chatting about how they would all bring their one dish when they come over on Christmas Eve as adults with their hypothetical future families. I know it may not look that way in real life, but it made me very teary to have them talking about carrying on traditions when they are grown. It was very sweet.
My eldest is only seven and it has taken us several years to fumble our way to traditions which are fun for everyone and which don’t have an overwhelming work:fun ratio for me.
It was so worth doing the figuring out! I feel so relaxed about Christmas this year, with four children seven and under, because I just know what to do.
How?
I took notes.
Last year, for the first time, I systematically wrote down everything that we did, all the supplies I need, all the recipes, etc etc. All in one big Advent and Christmas spreadsheet. Even our meal plan from Christmas to Epiphany is there.
Not to say that I can’t change things up next year and be flexible, but this year I didn’t have to do all the brain-work as well as the physical work. I have started doing this for all sorts of annual events and it’s been wonderful. Anything I think next-year-me might want to know, I just write it down. It saves me reinventing the wheel every year!
And one day, maybe I can just hand the spreadsheet (or part thereof) to a child……….
I read a tip on Substack about making a “Thanksgiving binder” where you keep all this info (recipes, details about what you do and when) for all your holidays and family traditions! I started it this year at Thanksgiving and thanks for the reminder to add to it about Christmas! Our town has a Christmas parade that we host a party for because it goes past our front lawn and every year I forget what time the parade actually starts, so I need to add that to the binder, for instance.
This! Taking notes was a game-changer for me as well, some years ago. “What was the stuffing recipe we tried last year and everyone loved?” “What did we do for breakfast on Christmas morning??” No one would remember and we had to brainstorm all over again and comb through cookbooks and cooking bookmarks online. I mean, in a way it can be fun… But as you say, taking notes just took all the stress away! Now it’s easy to decide when to do things exactly the same, and when to change – and the changes get recorded too, so you soon build an abundance of options. Every year you’re free to start from scratch, if you feel like it – or not!
Thank you so much for the link about Br. John, Auntie Leila! I especially liked the reminder that God can, when we let Him, make something precious out of our “failures”.
Merry Christmas!
Thought I would share another fun idea for one of the Twelve Days—Treasure Hunt Day! Make a simple treasure hunt through the house, ending with the treat or small gift that you would have enjoyed anyway. I was inspired by a book we got from the library, Max and Ruby’s Treasure Hunt. The clues are nursery rhymes with one of the words missing (ex: Hickory Dickory Dock, the mouse ran up the ____). Then go to the clock to find the next clue. I know I always wanted to do treasure hunts as a child.
I knew about the Italian feast of the 7 fishes, but I was just talking with the Polish cello teacher– the traditional meal there involves 12 dishes, including a carp you buy live from the market and stick it in the bathtub for the duration!
In my tradition, Cuban, they go to midnight mass and then have a huge pork-laden feast at 2 a.m.! The roast pork is the center, plus black beans (made with bacon of course), rice, two kinds of plantains, rolls, and possibly empanadas. We have always had this Christmas Eve, after the earlier mass when we were little, then before the late mass when we were older, and now again after the earlier mass now that my siblings and I have small children. I feel slightly conflicted about mass as I prefer both midnight and Christmas morning to the early Christmas Eve service, but I feel much better about eating meat after going to mass. Translating traditions to a different culture is not always easy.
I wish we were midnight mass people but we are just not at this point. Children aside, it takes me over a week to recover staying up until midnight, not too mention past it.