Even homeschooled children will ultimately make their way into a classroom, probably in college or maybe in high school.
When they do, they will need to be able to participate in a good discussion: listening, speaking, venturing their hypotheses, not dominating, not being so reticent that no one notices them. (Not to mention just speaking in groups generally!)
On the other hand, I recently saw a post somewhere where the author, in response to what sounded to me like a valid criticism, stated that she observed her loud, unruly, and (in her own account of the feedback!) overbearing children in some group setting, and decided they were casting off the shackles of convention, and that is a good thing, she thought, proving how free they are and so on.
No, not really!
How do you prepare your child for the experience of sharing ideas with others, which, after all, is truly the joy of education and the delight of learning? How do we help fit a child for interacting with others, especially under tutelage, and then later with others they respect and can benefit from and help in their turn?
It’s a problem for teachers and professors that students have few skills for speaking up and being productive in class. Even children who have gone to school lack, demographically speaking, the practice offered by the rough and tumble of sibling competition overseen by prudent parents.
I firmly believe that the dinner table is where the child learns good habits. It’s where his personality and ideas grow, receiving the checks and balances needed in the context of a loving circle.
Advent, as a new beginning, is the perfect time to address things in the family that need to be worked on or rectified and in general to make dinnertime enjoyable.
Family dinners can get a big boost in this season if we give a little thought and make a conscious effort to instill new habits — and don’t worry! The children are up for it. Far from judging you or thinking less of you for making a change, they are remarkably open to your efforts. Try it.
I have already written it all out for you! It’s a chapter in my book (with many surrounding chapters to flesh out the problems, challenges, and details of family life) and there are lots of posts here.
The main points here are seven, and I hope they pique your interest enough for you to read the whole thing:
1. Your children don’t have to sit with you for very long. Manage expectations, including your own. Don’t look for instant results: prioritize your conversation with your spouse.
2. Everyone has to be polite. Manners are important. Don’t allow rudeness — this is a matter of gentle correction for the very young, who have no context, and swift handling for the older ones. Spouses, be courteous to each other.
3. One conversation. <—- This point is the most important, long-term, for giving even your shyest, most reticent child the confidence to speak up, even in a classroom situation that he feels is intimidating. If you follow this one rule that my husband instituted at the start, you will give your child the gift of being able to speak up in a group. I go into great detail about it. In retrospect, I see how crucial this habit was in making our children pleasant to be around.
4. Children can be asked to stop talking. There is often that one person (hopefully it is a child who can be corrected, and not an adult!) who feels that everything said must pass through him for a reaction. This attitude must be reined in. Learning to listen means that one must, occasionally, stop talking! Say, “It’s time now for you to think your own thoughts inside. Stop talking, dear.”
5. “Not of general interest.” Take a tip from a father of twelve! Parents absolutely can and should guide the conversation! With a sense of humor, of course.
6. Be understanding of the younger ones. These things take time. Let your children develop — let them be quite imperfect. Gradually you will see results; be patient.
7. Younger ones are low on the totem pole. Hierarchy in the family is a good thing! Don’t let it be overthrown.
If you are interested in many more aspects of each of these points (and if you comment, especially, because chances are I have addressed your concern in the post or its comments — or in my chapter!), do read it all!
Kitchen Corner
I have been musing on how many decisions go into choosing one’s aesthetic. There is pressure to get it right. As I ponder my inspiration photos, I realize how many of the details in them are things I would never choose, yet overall I like what’s going on.
That gives me hope! It helps me see that “open shelves” and “color” and “mixing it up” and “natural materials” are more important to me than any one particular thing, like stove or even which natural material… I would love a stone floor (though I would break everything on it, so I didn’t choose it) but I love a wooden one as well. I actually just love lots of things, though I am also extremely picky! Not sure what my point is… maybe it’s that I love lots of things and so the choices seem hard to make, but really, lots of things will work very well for my goal.
Here are some examples of overall delight without necessarily loving every detail or even general clutter (sometimes purposely thrown in for the photo, so you have to ignore those things):
What these pictures have in common, I think, is that each thing in them was chosen because it fit the situation or the person loved it. There seems to be no overall plan.
I can do that!
Knitting Corner
Still plugging along on my color work sweater, Altheda. I had to rip out a lot in figuring out the fit of the body. Several times.
Made some mittens.
Working on some thrummed mittens, which go slowly but are O So Warm and Soft!
Book Corner
A reader sent me this recently published book, The Star of Bethlehem, (affiliate link) and it’s really fascinating. The author is a priest who is also an astronomer. I don’t know how it jibes with the Star of Bethlehem movie I watched and enjoyed a few years ago. Maybe one of your high school students can compare and contrast! For more on the issue of ancient astrology and contemporary astronomy, I recommend the much longer book, Planet Narnia, by Michael Ward (affiliate link) (who converted from the Anglican Church and is also a priest now!).
On to our links!
bits & pieces
- If you have been doing the Advent wreath over the years and you are looking for prayers with a bit more, also using the Collects of the Sundays, go here.
- Speaking of Michael Ward, here is an article, C. S. Lewis, Jupiter and Christmas, that gives a taste for his scholarship and insight (on my favorite topics).
- We really do need to learn to say no to the busyness, even if the things are good.
- Go here for the free download of our favorite little Advent calendar from Fig & Thimble! (This is the Roman one — they also have an Eastern calendar one).
- A good reflection on the liturgical year, which is a great mystery, actually: Sanctifying Time as the World Ends
- Here is that site that our dear reader Anitra runs, The Family Gamers, all about family board games and tips for playing them! See this post, regarding sore losers. Also do see the comments on this post for helpful thoughts on making board games more pleasurable for all. I particularly appreciated the advice to institute the rule that the winner cleans up.
from the archives
- Don’t miss this post, on how to set the family table. Sometimes we don’t even realize the practical details that make our dreams come true.
liturgical living
Of course, tomorrow is the First Sunday of Advent. Many feasts are headed our way. Keep calm and remember, a little nod to them, a reading, a small little extra treat to commemorate, this is all we need.
Do remember St. Nicholas, December 6th, if you want to have the children put out their shoes or stockings — maybe pick up some gold coins (they usually have them at Aldi and at the drug store candy counter) and other little chocolates? Some parents have the lovely tradition of giving the children warm socks, slippers, or holiday pajamas on this day. Wish I had thought of it, but I guess I am here to say, you will survive even if you don’t do all the things!
follow us everywhere! share us with your friends!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing!
My podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) — be sure to check out the other offerings there!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen:
Consider subscribing to this blog by email.
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest











I have one teen who loves to put out her arguments very strongly, and another one who can’t bear to see his points criticized and taken apart – family conversations double as training in charity, even if it doesn’t always look pretty…
I like your observation that sometimes we’ll get great “decorating” results by not having any precise plan in place, but by simply surrounding ourselves with what we like. It’s not quite possible with a huge renovation like your kitchen, though, because when a space is (re)built from scratch there are by necessity loads of decisions to be made all at once, rather than layered in time, adding one detail now, another in a couple of years. To get everything “right” in one fell swoop feels very intimidating…
We were in your corner of the world for a few days, visiting TMC (again!) and starting off Advent with their very beautiful concert in Manchester, NH. Something tells me those places will become very familiar, let’s see what happens 😉
It’s true — so many virtues learned around the dinner table, including parental ones. That is the beauty of God’s plan for the family.
Yes, the kitchen coming up from scratch really has to have some things that are intentional from the start. And in a tricky space like mine, every inch counts, so I can’t just waste areas but need to use it all well. It is indeed quite intimidating! I am much more a make-do sort of person!
I am not sure if this comment will even reach you, given that this post was over a year ago… but I have a question regarding your table manners/conversations on this post. I may even cut and paste this into a more recent post, to see if you might actually respond. My question is this: I have raised (and am raising still) children to have good table manners. This has always been important to me. I have also recently ‘given away’ our eldest daughter to marry a man who was not raised with the table manners that we strive to teach our own children. Elbows on the table, multiple conversations going on at once, talking over one another, and sparking conversations that are divisive and ‘controversial’. For the past few years, to honor and help my husbands’ elderly parents, we have invited them over for supper on Thursday evenings. It has been a wonderful time. My daughter and her new husband, understanding the value of family and spending time with the grandparents, try to come to these dinners often. But now they are not quite as pleasant ordeals as they once were! In fact, I find it quite stressful and I can tell my in-laws do not have as nice a time. (They are liberals and do not agree with many of my husband and I (as well as our daughter-in-law/son-in-law beliefs). My husband and I know what controversial topics to avoid in order to respect his parents and still maintain a good relationship with them but my new son-in-law does not AT ALL. My question then is… how does one invite a new person into the fold who is an adult and love them and make them feel welcome and at home- but also encourage them to be more polite/considerate? I want my son-in-law to want to come to family dinners and not feel downgraded by our expectations but I also want our family dinners to be enjoyable and recently they have been LESS SO for all involved. How would you approach this?
Any advice would be appreciated!
I understand your dilemma and I would just say, be patient and maybe do a few things…
1. Maybe your husband can drop a hint or two, little by little, to this son-in-law on the various issues or whatever strikes him as wise. He can certainly play “Mr. Gilbreth” — doing his best imitation and hollering out ONE CONVERSATION or NOT OF GENERAL INTEREST– at least for the sake of the younger kids, to whom he still does have a responsibility. Sometimes disciplining the younger kids can rub off on the older ones.
2. Maybe your daughter can talk to him about having a bit of awareness about her grandparents. You don’t want to introduce discord, but if you put it as “maybe he isn’t aware… ” it might be helpful.
3. Be patient. Eventually he will notice and reform a bit. But it will take time.
4. Don’t take on more of the burden than is really yours. People are who they are. It’s not up to you to control everything. Let the chips fall where they may to a certain extent. If you detach yourself a bit, you might find others step in or he himself notices more. I think this is one effect, and it’s not a bad one, of our children marrying: we are shaken out of our world where we really are the arbiters of everything that happens, as the parents of good, obedient children.
5. Relatedly, consider that it might ultimately be good for everyone to adjust to things that are not exactly as we would want them to be. No one should be rude, but it’s not the worst thing to have a serious conversation. If your SIL is really making everyone uncomfortable, I think the awkward silences will correct him, but if it’s really just that there could be more to talk about, maybe everyone else will live up to the challenge.
In any case, pray about it and don’t be afraid of an adjustment period. It’s really pretty normal! Things are settling into a different mode… life changes when our kids start to marry!
God bless!