Food is really expensive. It seems overwhelming to try to live on one income and feed the family, especially if large. I keep seeing people saying, “It’s not feasible; it can’t be done anymore.” They are wrong!
The thing is, the household needs a manager of all its resources. If both husband and wife work, the household will always be at the mercy of high prices, because things spiral: the more you work, the more you need to alleviate your scarce time (and exhaustion) with conveniences. The more you spend on food “because you don’t have time to cook” the greater the need to make more money. Very quickly, the children are viewed as the problem and we are urged to have ever fewer. The messaging is all futility, all the time.
Escape from this syndrome lies in the wife accepting the responsibility for being the household manager, manager of time and money and resources. While there is no paycheck for this role, there is considerable savings (I mean if we look at it financially — there are so many other non-monetary advantages of course, and those I have written about as well).
This is the homemaker’s province. The wise and frugal wife can help her family thrive on very little and ultimately oversee its flourishing. But it requires work and thought, especially at first. The thought is so necessary — no one but she can figure it out! There is no other person who can take into account the needs and circumstances of the family but she.
It can be done and I want to tell you — especially anyone new here — that my methods will help. They are here on the blog (look up at the menu bar under Dinner Every Day for all the posts). They comprise a whole volume, the third, in my Summa Domestica (currently on sale, 35% off!)
The food expense challenge has two parts.
The first is to plan what the family would and could eat. Planning implies knowing. The facts evolve — children grow, tastes change, needs emerge, your own skills improve. What are all these facts for your family?
The second is to know where the food can be obtained and what the prices are. Grocery store? Costco? Food co-op? Your own garden/homestead? There is no one place where everything is cheaper and better. The good housewife “is like the merchants’ ships; she bringeth her food from afar.”
This coming week, can you devote yourself to that first part?
Read these posts from the bottom up.
I suggest a notebook (but it can be done on the computer) in which you write down the breakfasts, lunches, and suppers your family will and can eat. I explain making your own menus here (and why it needs to be menus, not just “pork chops”).
Some homemakers say they don’t meal-plan, but I think that might be a bit misleading.
They have likely internalized the template I’m talking about here and have arrived at a place where it’s all second nature. But the beginning homemaker who doesn’t want to be reliant on pre-made food and constant going out/ordering in needs to analyze the process and figure it out for herself.
In any case, as I explain, a busy household does require some planning for the different kinds of days — busy days during which we resort to buying food made elsewhere, because we didn’t plan. I show you my thought process but you can apply it to your own situation.
My way is, I believe, unique, in that it’s very detailed but also totally freeing for your own life, which is so different from everyone else’s.
The trick of frugal and good meal planning is to replace as many of the pre-packaged, prepared expensive foods with homemade inexpensive ones as you are able. For instance, I know that many mothers plan on buying cooked chickens on their big Costco run day, but consider instead putting a hearty bean soup in the slow cooker before you head out. Those chickens are not healthy, don’t go very far, don’t taste wonderful, and seem cheap but aren’t, as they are very small. You still need sides and so on, and might end up eating your savings all on that one day.
In fact, challenge yourself to do completely without any restaurant or takeout food until you master the thrifty way of meal planning. Eating out (or taking in) is a hidden and extreme tax on your budget, and I say this as someone who is at the mercy of it all during this kitchen renovation.
As I was buying our week’s bread the other day, I noticed that I bought was literally 10 times what I could make it for, maybe more, and goes without saying, nowhere near as tasty or nutritious. In fact, our imposed regime has led to me gaining about 10 lbs, sadly, even though I do make most of our meals, camp-style!
From our days of many kids and small budget, I can attest that it’s possible to schedule in another soup day (fortified with unlimited bread and butter), and to turn Sunday’s roast into many eagerly awaited meals in the coming weeks.
If making everything from scratch sounds exhausting, think about what I call Save-A-Step cooking to be more efficient but still homemade.
Figuring this out takes hours of work — at first. Later, it becomes second nature. “She riseth also while it is yet night, and giveth meat to her household, and a portion to her maidens.” Remember, if you get a job, it will take more hours of work to get up to speed there, and then, it’s all work from there on out.
For the second part of the challenge, really know your prices. You need to know the unit prices of everything you buy. Even the food co-op delivering things in giant sacks has some items that are more cheaply found elsewhere.
If you are buying a lot of salad greens in big plastic containers, think about how to grow greens yourself next year (or now if you live somewhere with a warm climate — salad greens grow beautifully in quite cool weather and can even be grown inside!). Kale and chard grow perfectly, cost virtually nothing, and can be frozen for soups in the winter. But if you’re buying, you need to know which stores carry the cheapest, best vegetables.
Cut-up fruits and vegetables are pricey– learn to prepare the whole ones at home. Buy a cabbage and a bag of carrots rather than “slaw mix,” for instance. I bet you have a food processor lurking somewhere… or a sharp knife!
You don’t have to cut up raw squash, much less buy it pre-cut — bake it whole and peel and cut it up after. Two-income households buy pre-sliced apples; housewives are good with slicing apples at home. Look at the unit price to confirm the savings.
Roast several chickens at once; bake four loaves of bread, minimum, at a time; get your ham with the bone in so you can easily make homemade soup another day.
my garden this past May
You will have to go to multiple stores for the best prices, and in order to maximize this effort, plan to buy in bulk when you are there. That means figuring out storage — again, only you can know what your circumstances are. Do you need more shelving or another fridge or deep freezer? Look on Facebook Marketplace and your local buy/sell/give for cheap or free — they will pay for themselves. “She perceiveth that her merchandise is good: her candle goeth not out by night.”
It goes without saying that we’ll have to tighten our belts and eliminate a lot of frills in the grocery expenditure, but in the end we’ll be healthier for it, and definitely happier to know that our food is homemade and of good quality, even if very simple.
I can’t put it all into one post, but I have gone into all the details for you here and in my book. You can do it! Change your mindset from “it’s impossible” to “there is a way! and I will find it”! Make your role model not the helpless women of today who don’t know how to cut up a potato, much less a whole chicken, but the thrifty mothers, past and present, who skillfully make the most of what their husbands provide.
We will survive this imposed dearth, and with good cheer! “Better is a dinner of herbs where love is, than a stalled ox and hatred therewith.” (Proverbs 15: 17)
Kitchen Reno Corner
The floor is in and finished!
That structure in front of the fireplace is the trim for the big window; it will be put in when the counter is installed. It has to be moved all the time!
The cabinets are due to arrive this coming week!
Art Corner
I love my son-in-law John Folley’s Our Lady of Victory print! I’m so happy he gave me one.
A while ago his Instagram account was hacked and deleted. He has a new one — follow him if you’re on there!
Reader Question Corner
In the Department of Auntie Leila Sure Doesn’t Know, a reader asks “how do you get your children to play board games without sulking, whining, anger, pride, bad temper, etc?”
I had so little tolerance for it that I’m sure I don’t know, but they grew up to play board games a lot, including with their own young children! They seem to just somehow move on from meltdowns and power through. What do you do at your house? Do your kids play board games with each other? Do you assume their friends will provide the necessary feedback to render them good sports? Do you wait for your husband to teach them?
bits & pieces
- A fun post from Peter Kwasniewski about coffee, and I say that as a tea-drinker who has never had even one cup of coffee! Tea is the true “cup of the needful” if we are really reading P. G. Wodehouse, who apparently scorns java as not worthy of mention, if I recall correctly!
- He also helpfully points us to this resource for chanting the Rosary in Latin. I think learning these chants is not hard, and singing the Rosary is a wonderful idea for processions, pilgrimages, etc.
- It’s coming — all the hot takes about Our Lady, the Blessed Mother, being an unwed teen. I will never stop reminding you that this is false. Were Mary and Joseph really married?
from the archives
If you are not going to click on all my food management posts (or if you want even more), how about these:
liturgical living
Listen to Michael Ward’s speech at Hillsdale if you have some time. His speech begins at the 36 minute mark. Did you know that the word “chapel” comes from St. Martin’s “cape”?
follow us everywhere! share us with your friends!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing!
My podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) — be sure to check out the other offerings there!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen:
Consider subscribing to this blog by email.
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest








The kitchen floor is stunning! I love that cabin-y pine color.
Your frugality talk reminded me of the Pasta Grannies. Did I mention the Pasta Grannies to you before? It’s one lady’s project to collect and preserve the dying pasta traditions from all over Italy, and she makes beautiful little videos on Youtube of clever, wrinkled women, some over 100 years old, making their family pasta recipes. I have the cookbook now, and I’ve been struck by the little notes and biographies I see in here. Many of these ladies were children during the second World War, were raised with their many siblings on nothing more than beans, vegetables, occasional eggs, and homemade pasta with the occasional feast-day meat dish if the family was blessed with it, and often had to make the food themselves from a young age when parents died or were forced to work, or lost health or limbs. When I see their cheerful faces and some of their houses plastered with pictures of the Sacred Heart or the Blessed Mother, I am just awed and humbled and think, “maybe I can do this frugality thing after all, even in these ‘trying’ times.”
Thank you, Auntie Leila!! I have really been struggling internally with this lately. Not that I am really thinking I should run out and get a job, but just being DONE thinking about food, the cost of food etc. It really stems from the fact that I am still early enough in forming most of the good habits you suggest that they aren’t real habits yet, and so I am easily discouraged. Thank you! This was just the encouragement and the firm talking to I needed all in one.
I agree that it is still possible to live on one income despite the price of food, but I also think that this excellent advice is still sometimes not enough. I have always cooked this way. I never even throw out the carcass of a chicken without making soup from it. We get most of our clothes and other necessary non-food items from the thrift store, too. Yet even this is not enough now. To my great shame, we ended up going on SNAP. I hate this. We chose to have a large family and I dislike needing to rely on the government to feed them. I can’t imagine working with as many children as I have, though. Even if I sent them all to school the child care alone would cancel out anything I earn. I am not sure what the solution is for us and others like us who are already living extremely frugal lives.
I’ve been there and sometimes you’ve cut all the corners and ends still don’t meet and then it is time for you and your husband to have a heart to heart. Leila isn’t talking to you personally, of course, and her reminders are very helpful for those who don’t know how they are wasting money! But a few years ago, my family was in a similar situation as you, and the solution for my family was my husband had to start making more money. It required quite a sacrifice for a few years for him to train in a new field but I think it was very important for our family and helped us mature and grow and take seriously our responsibility to care for our family. My husband was not on board with the change at first and it took a couple years of prayer and discernment to even get to the point of his seeing the problem but we had to start talking about these things. I kept looking on the Internet for somebody to tell me the answer for what I needed to do but nobody could tell me what I needed to do, only my husband and I knew ourselves and our needs for our family. I’m not saying you need to change jobs, but sometimes, the answer that you’re looking for to the problem of your life that you’re facing isn’t something that you’re going to find in a blog post! I’ll pray for you, I know it was so hard for me to know what to do but prayer and good friends to turn these matters over with can be such a help!
Being on SNAP isn’t shameful I’d like to add, I am happy as a tax payer to support families since that’s the system we’ve got, whether it should be that way or not!
My husband changed careers early on when we looked to the future and saw that it would be tough to live on that income, and raises in his industry were slow- even in the relatively inexpensive part of the country where we live. That was early on, when I still had time for a side-hustle, so I ended up paying for a lot of his classes, but it would have been worth it a different way. He’s tripled his income in the last 5 years. I’m very grateful.
Prayers that you can figure something out!
I’ll be praying too. No shame needed. Have you ever seen theprudenthomemaker.com? Brandy there has a lovely section about how to trim even when you think there’s nothing more to cut. She and her family had to go without income for a couple of years. And once a week, folks comment with thrift ideas that often surprise and help me. And my folks are from West Virginia, where the Depression never left:). I’m sure you’ve already seen many things like this. I just wanted to pass it along in case it’s helpful. God bless!
Thanks for the great blog suggestion, I visited theprudenthomemaker.com and got stuck there for a while the other day. 🙂 I loved her post about eating beans every day. Beans are so good for the body, and serve as both starch and protein–and dry beans are still cheap (even if they aren’t as cheap as they used to be).
I make about 3lbs of beans every Friday and we eat that as our main Friday dish and then have leftovers as sides for the next few days.
And Leila, I love how your kitchen remodel is going! It looks absolutely beautiful so far!
So glad you liked the blog, Victoria!
Dear Erin,
I am totally in sympathy with you. In my book I have some other thoughts — this post is just about food costs.
Besides what the other readers have said above, what I outline in the book is looking at your major budget items. For most people, it’s their home — mortgage or rent. Another lockdown pressure. I also outline how to get out of credit card debt. Email me if you want the details.
One way the dear Lord tells us what His will is has to do with what we can afford. If housing and utility costs are too high — and truly, you can’t make up the difference by saving 20 cents on your cans of beans — then, if the income can’t go up, the family must move.
There are parts of the country where the cost of living is so high, adding in taxes, keeping warm in winter, gas prices. It could be that God is nudging you to find a place that is not so high. Of course, a lot depends on where your husband can earn a living. But, as Cirelo says, doors will open. The only recourse is prayer! I can say from experience that putting it all at His feet and simply asking for a very specific answer can be the way forward. A novena to St. Joseph and keeping a sharp eye on real estate and job opportunities is the ticket.
I am sure you are praying, but be encouraged! Many reading your comment will pray for your family! I will too!
Your husband’s taxes and the taxes of the people benefiting from his labour go toward SNAP. Your children will be supporting their retirement by keeping the economy going. I’ll say a prayer that you can be free from any shame.
Ladies,
Thank you for your prayers and encouragement. I pray for all of you as well.
This is so encouraging! I find I need to make myself rethink all of my kitchen habits about every quarter or so. It’s easy to get into a bit of a rut, especially after a season of survival mode.
One thing I’m doing now (in very much a season of survival with a 6 week old who needs special care) is thinking of meals that are super easy to double as I prep. So things like pot roast, pork shoulder recipes, seasoned Pork chops, soups, taco meats etc. I put the uncooked, prepped meal in the freezer and write down what I made on a list I keep at the command center— then when I make my weekly meal plan, I can consult what I have available to me in the freezer. Then the other prepped meal gets cooked for that day’s dinner. I find this approach a lot easier than the all -day freezer meal prep (I did do some of that in the summer before the baby was born, and it really helped me get through the last couple weeks of pregnancy and the postpartum days when we didn’t have a meal being brought to us).
We have never been big pork eaters, but now I read that the mRNA injections were approved for pig farmers and it’s up to the farmer if they decide to use it. I wonder if I want to be eating this meat! So, we haven’t bought pork for a while now.
I am convinced that we need to seek out small farms in our area and buy meat from them!
If there is a Weston A. Price Foundation chapter in your area, they can be a good place to source clean meat (Find Food/Local Chapters tab – https://www.westonaprice.org/). Many farms allow you to purchase whole, half, or quarter animals, and we have found this to be a great way to save money on grass-fed and organic meats. When you buy a whole animal, you work directly with the meat processor, and you should be able to get bones, fat, and offal along with your roasts and ground meat. The cost of a whole animal (and a large chest freezer to store it in) up front can be a lot, but it also means fewer trips to the grocery stores if you have a freezer full of meat and a pantry full of staples.
Yes, you describe my Save-A-Step method, and I encourage anyone interested to check out those posts!
It’s exactly how you do it!
Yes, it is entirely possible. My husband and I (eventually with six children) have been doing this since 1990, in southern Ontario, Canada, mostly on a Christian school teacher salary and 20 years of that near the Toronto metro area. It takes thoughtfulness, ingenuity, willingness to do with less than your spend-y neighbors, home cooking and much more, but it can be done!
Hi, Auntie Leila – Awesome thoughts. You always have such good things to say. I appreciate the good reminders.
As another reader noted above, costs are insane. Our food bill has easily doubled since pre-Covid, possibly more. Right now we are living paycheck-to-paycheck while spending no extras, and we can’t afford health insurance.
My two challenges with food bills are:
(1) My time and energy, especially while trying to homeschool,
(2) My husband’s money habits, which until we hit rock-bottom financially, included his eating out multiple times a week for himself and the children (so, $50 each time, multiple times per week).
However, I am doing my best, and have made modest inroads. One of the best things has been just making sure that there are meals planned all of the time – no downtime in which I have to say “I don’t know what there is to eat at home.”
I’m looking forward to seeing what your thrifty readers have to say, too! Love the comment section.
Happy Martinmas!
Auntie Leila, what beautiful paint and light and pine! I’m so excited for you. Thanks for sharing this with us.
Thank you for the reminder to keep meal planning. It’s so easy to just forget to thaw things in time! Right now we’re eating up the second freezer for a while so I can remember better what we have. A great way to save a bit before Christmas. Another thing that we love is cold frames or greenhouse plastic to keep salad greens growing just a bit longer. Greenhouse thick plastic sheeting is so cheap at home repair box stores, and spinach and arugula keep so well under it. We really loved this. Lots of things can be cold frames, including milk jugs.
Board games aren’t a big thing at our house, except for the ones with tons of small choking hazards! Ticket to ride, Carcasonnr, Twisty all get pulled out pretty frequently. It took a while to get any sportsmanship. We didn’t figure it out as parents, the boys just wore each other down. Now they can manage most of the time.
Thank you for the lovely post! I always look forward to them. Happy Martinmas!
The Our Lady of Victory is quite art nouveau looking, isn’t it? An interesting take on it, and beautiful work. Your kitchen will be sublime when it’s done, and I’m so sorry you gained ten pounds – awful! It’s hard to lose weight! I wish you well!
The way you interspersed the verses with your words about saving money is nice and makes it more encouraging. 🙂
We aren’t quite at board game age with my young family yet, but both my husband and I are big into board games so we look forward to playing with our kids!
Here’s something my parents did that was a great way to get us playing games as a family when we were older (high school and college age)- every Christmas we would get one new board game as a family gift. Then we would spend the next couple weeks of our remaining Christmas break playing that game until we were all sick of it!
(This was after having been a somewhat board game playing family when we were younger, but with lots of yelling and screaming and kids being sore losers and my mom swearing she would never play games with us again! I guess we eventually learned. Although I admit that I stormed out of the room after losing a game to my husband YET AGAIN the first year we were married… so, maybe not…)
LOL to storming out… my husband and I played chess early on in our marriage and it ended with him being SO MEAN and me crying… haha
Maybe it’s just the process? (I will never play chess with him again and it’s been 44 years but maybe it’s a process with kids?) (We do enjoy playing bridge together, though!)
Yes there are still a few games I won’t play with him 😂 we are both competitive oldest children, there might be no escaping it
There was a card game that we used to play a lot when we were first married; I don’t remember the actual name of it but we called it “The Game That Makes Us Mad.” One of the first signs of us growing together as a married couple was that we eventually agreed to just stop playing it!!
And THIS is why I don’t let my husband teach me chess: he’s a very good player and I know it’s his way of plotting his revenge for regularly losing to me at our little tabletop foosball! But while I am a very gracious winner, he… is not! So we compromise with an Italian card game we both love to play and where wins and losses are evenly distributed.
I’m afraid Bertie Wooster often drinks coffee, not just tea – and he praises it too. I drink both, for different reasons and at different times of day: I like to start the day with coffee (more like a latte, I stay away from Dr. K’s beloved espresso!), but a meditative cup of tea with a simple shortbread is heavenly in the afternoon, especially on cold, cloudy days.
I’m struggling with cheap food versus higher quality food. It seems like food quality has really plummeted, at least here in Chicago. Buying organic or local tastes so much better and is, I’m sure, better for our health. But how do we afford it? A friend purchased a whole cow and pig from a wonderful farm and offered to sell us part of it. We did but some, but it was significantly per pound than what I would pay at Aldi, for instance. Is it worth it? Is it worth buying better flour, produce, eggs, milk?
We walk this line also. We ended up growing most greens as it worked out for us to start during COVID. And we planted lots of berries and eat them in season, and out of season, not. We do regular staples instead of organic – flour, butter, sugar, milk, meat. I figure that we win by having most things homemade. During the worst of winter, we get broccoli and frozen peas and canned green beans.
I find that a middle ground, between home made and some convenience food, is the perfect place for me.
I have no problem buying some unhealthy, convenience food items (canned soups, frozen meals) for the sake of less stress and convenience. Especially with forever hungry teenage boys! My husband was raised on convenience/restaurant food (single mother) so finding a middle ground to suit his tastes has been helpful. I’ve made many, many different bread recipes over the years…a cheap white sand which bread is still his favorite!
We’ve been financially situated in such a way at times that we could purchase local meats, raise our own chickens, purchase raw milk, have a small garden, etc. But sometimes it is impossible. I say, do the best with what you have and don’t stress! Figure what’s on sale, make your menus, and be thankful. Your skills will sharpen as time goes by, just as Auntie Leila says. Have faith in God’s providence.
I know something that has been very helpful for this past year, is having our groceries delivered. We are a one car household, and trying to figure out a grocery day that didn’t fall on a Sunday was stressful. Delivery is great!
Same for me with curbside pickup in a season of lots of little kids. Our local grocery store offers this at no cost now! It is worth it in the time savings for sure, and I can see the $$ total as I go and more easily take advantage of coupons and deals.
The one downside is not going aisle by aisle and having the chance to pick up the staples I know I always need, but weren’t on my list. Over time I hope I forget fewer things every week!
Thank you for this encouragement! I have not worked since my first born 21 years ago, but I have family members who do work with young children in school and I worry for them. I have to figure out if I have the guts to share this with them.
I also learned over the years of trying to manage our resources that, at least for us, variety is overrated. We are a routine and habit family and these days we have the same meal at least 4-5 days a week. And everyone is happy. This certainly makes planning easy and also stocking up (when our favorite meats are on sale I buy a bunch and freeze).
Another thing to keep in mind is that foods have certain times of year when they are cheapest. If you can stock up at those times you can have significant savings. The food industry has designated certain months for different things and then puts them on sale at those times. For example, October is seafood month, March is Frozen Food month, etc.. Other things go on sale because they all have to be harvested at one time of the year. Walnuts, for example, are usually $8-$10/lb. Right now they are $3/lb. I can get apples for $20 a bushel this time of year at my local farm stand to turn into a year’s worth of applesauce or dried apples. Baking supplies are almost always on sale between Thanksgiving and Christmas. Many grocery stores advertise these and run specials on these items the entire month. If you have a large freezer for things like chicken or nuts you can buy several months or even a year worth of a particular item. Canned or dry goods can be stored even if you don’t have a freezer (though you should absolutely familiarize yourself with how long things can be stored and how to safely do so). If you do choose to shop this way, you should write down how much you bought and when. When the time of year for the sale comes you will then know if you bought too much or too little for the needs of your family. After a while it becomes second nature and you don’t have to think so much about the quantities because you just know them. It may take a while (even a few years) to move toward this way of making purchases. Most of us don’t have a lot of money lying around to buy a few months of one item. Start with one or two items and add more when you get the money. Eventually you will find that the grocery budget remain even all year round because you are bulk buying different things at different times but not buying them at all on other months. The money you would be spending on that item in that month can then be spent on bulk buying a different item, which you won’t be buying when you are buying the first item again.
That was extremely lengthy and I hope it makes sense.
I never thought of freezing nuts. What and how? We eat them alot for protein snacks
They freeze extremely well. I just throw them in the freezer in the bags they come in. They taste just fine even after a year. I have actually discovered a bag down in the bottom of the freezer after 18 months that was also fine. I also sometimes grind the walnuts before putting them in the freezer since we mostly use those in holiday foods like cookies. They are fine stored that way as well. I just put them in big ziploc bags or back in the bag they came in if it is resealable.
It is a very good idea to freeze nuts if you buy them in large quantities. It keeps them from going rancid and it works very well! I always freeze my nuts and have never had a problem with them getting rancid.
Yes, the X factor of the husband. It’s so nice to have the mental space to balance our family’s wants and needs.
This is great advice, thank you!
I wanted to interject another thrifty suggestion that may be helpful to some readers – ask around to the thrifty folks that life brings your way, and find out if they have any kind of bulk food supplier. In lamenting about food prices years ago to one of my very thrifty friends, she shared that she got hers through a co-op group buy deal, and offered to connect me with them. As a result for years now I’ve gotten very quality King Arthur flour, 50 lb bags, for between $20-$25 each, which pretty consistently has been equivalent to the 25 lb bags at the grocery store. I buy two to three bags every three months for my family of six. Recently I’ve started getting other things as well – 50 lbs of oats (at $1/lb) that I then use to make granola ( have you SEEN the cost of boxed cereal these days? it’s unreal!), dried cranberries for half the store price, it goes on and on. You do have to invest in some bulk storage to keep these things good and pest free – we bought food safe plastic dogfood containers for the flour and oats – but it is SO worth it for the bottom line on the grocery budget. It’s very worth learning to bake all the bread products you can, as well… I make sourdough English muffins, for instance, that would be $3 for 6 in the store, my recipe makes 2 dozen (which would equal a whopping $12) all for 7 cups of flour. At $20/50 lbs (100 cups) that means the flour cost for the recipe is about $1.40, plus two cups of milk, so the english muffins literally cost 8-10 times more in the store. That pretty much goes for every kind of baked good out there! It might seem like saving very little in the moment (only $5 here, $10 there) but in the course of a year those amounts really add up.
Leila, I wanted to say a heartfeld thanks for ALL the helpful wisdom and advice. I have your book set (so excellent!) and while I thought I was pretty on top of things, I always find something that helps me tweak things just that bit more. The save a step cooking, of instance – advice to oven cook bacon (life changing!), and make sure to tuck away extra pieces, has been so helpful in being able to pull together a quick corn chowder in a pinch, or all sorts of other things as well. The passing down of collective wisdom may be less straightfoward (Wendell Berry would say, “wayward”) than it once was but so glad for every bit that trickles down just the same!
So exciting about your baking victories! I’ve never heard of this kind of co-op, though I’m fascinated. I’ll ask around.
One thing that’s been making a big difference in the cost of things around here is using powdered milk where it doesn’t matter. I make overnight yeast waffles, swapping in corn oil for butter because it doesn’t separate and actually works better, and swapping powdered milk for regular. I’m definitely not one to skimp on butter usually, but sometimes oil really is ok. And we make waffle batter about a gallon and a half at a time, so saving a bit counts. Marion Cunningham’s lovely recipe from her Breakfast Cookbook, a good read. It really is easier with the oil though.
Homemade jam/apple butter is a real money-saver in terms of getting healthy stuff for cheap. You can get fruit very cheap in the stores and at orchard in season; you only buy the jars once; so all you need is sugar (cheap) and lemons for most jams. Apple butter doesn’t even need the lemons, and you only need a little sugar for that!
Compared to nasty corn syrup store-brand jam it’s about the same price; but compared to Bonne Maman (i.e. real sugar, no bad ingredients) it saves a ton!
Also, a friend made the point to me that sometimes you have to have a season of maybe eating not the very highest-quality food, knowing that later you will go back to it. For example, we generally avoid pasta because it turns straight to sugar in the blood, but when my 20-year-old brother lives for us during his college breaks our grocery bills go way up — at least a couple of hundred dollars per month. He just eats so much! My friend said: what if when he’s home, you eat a lot of pasta? Pair it with cheese! It’s only temporary! That has been helpful to me.
In terms of board games, I think board games are a context in which kids figure out how to solve disagreements. It’s horrible at first with the fighting, but eventually they figure it out themselves. This used to happen in sandlots and things, too, but we’re so used to kids being supervised in their play these days that I think we’re kind of shocked when we see this happen with board games!
They just kind of…figure it out over time. Which is good for them.
Last thought: Leila, year and years ago I had a post on FB about trying to figure out whether to private school or homeschool the next year. I mentioned that we couldn’t afford tuition, and you commented with something that really helped us with the decision: that sometimes God speaks to us through what we can’t afford. That is, if you can’t afford tuition, then probably private school must not be a necessity for this particular year. You were right!
Oh, one more tip — you can get 50 lb bags of name-brand flour (all-purpose and whole-wheat) at restaurant supply stores for $25. Abby mentions this above in terms of co-ops, but check out the restaurant supply stores, too! They are usually open to the public.
Yes, I do this, too. There’s a few items, like flour, that I can pick up at our local restaurant supply store. Their 10 pound ground beef tubes and pork shoulders are cheaper per pound, too.
I had a child who would wail and cry whenever she lost a board game. She has since gotten over it and I think it’s mostly due to time and maturing. But we did try to help her cope (and now I have a new 4 yo who cries when he loses) by practicing saying “good game” to each other at the end with a handshake. If I happened to be the one who lost I would say to her “I had fun playing the game with you, even though I lost!” There are also so many “cooperative “ board games out there which are really fun when the kids are still little and learning how to play games. It’s helpful for my kids to mix those into the rotation from time to time!
Leila, I love your pine floors so much. I wonder if you would be willing to share what kind of flooring it is specifically, and where you got it? We need to redo our kitchen floor very badly (it’s currently 1980s linoleum filled with holes!) and I would love to have one that looks like yours!
It’s heart pine. I got it from a place that sources it from NC. I called/emailed lots of mills near me and priced out the heart pine — these guys were by far the cheapest. My contractor went and looked at it and was impressed — and so am I.
The mill is Fabrizio Lumber in Middleton MA.
The lumber has to be acclimated in your space for one day per inch of width (so 9 days for us). The floor guy used Bona finish on it (Classic sealer and Traffic HD, 2 coats). Far less toxic than oil-based poly! I do love it!
Food is SO expensive! We just moved back to the States this summer after 2 years in England and we couldn’t believe how expensive food has become since we left. The first few months back we really struggled to figure out how to have a reasonable grocery budget, even as a family who basically does not eat out, makes basically everything from scratch, and is used to cutting corners on food! Before we moved we could count on getting meat on sale weekly, but now we’ve had to start looking for deals on meat that is about to hit its sell-by date and is therefore significantly marked down. We just stick it in the freezer and allocate as needed.
I agree with many of those above–the struggle between finding things of good quality and also buying things cheaply is a constant debate. Sometimes it just depends on our expenses that month or week! In our area, buying locally is not an option at all–local options are sometimes 2x as expensive as the stores, even for produce. I feel that finding the balance of quality and affordability will be something we just have to constantly work on this year as we figure out the new food economy here.
We have the same problem in our area— local food is way more expensive. Farmers markets, local farms, etc are not affordable! We got a whole pig this year, and while it is tasty and we were happy to support our friends’ farm, we have already had to go back to getting shoulder roasts and chops and loins from the store! (We got the pig in mid-June). We have a lot of sausage left and that’s great, but we’re not sure it makes the most sense for a large family, considering how often we need the big roasts and chops. And while it is superior to store bought meat, it is significantly more expensive per pound! It’s a dilemma.
But I think the key is to group with friends — to use the communities you belong to for finding and encouraging those willing to raise meat birds or pigs and get in on that deal.
That’s what I’ve seen working here.
Leila your encouragement is wonderful and these thrifty comments are very helpful. People are always asking when I will go back to teaching. I have four children, the youngest two being two year old twins. I just laugh!
One thing I’ve found this year, though I admit this works because I live in the Midwest where gardens just grow well, is to check Facebook marketplace for fresh produce. U-pick blueberries for less a pound than you can find at the farms around, $1 per butternut squash, etc.
It takes driving a bit further than normal, but is often worth it to stock up. Can’t guarantee the places are organic, but it is absolutely fresh and local, and often just someone who enjoys growing more than they can consume.
Your kitchen floors are beautiful! Excellent post.
One thing that’s been helpful with playing games with my kids (7 of them, 12 and under) is saying before we start, “Now remember, by playing this game, you are entering into an agreement that you might lose. Actually, odds are that you will lose, because X number of other people are also playing. If you’re not willing to lose, you can back out now.” They rarely (never) back out, and then we can remind grouchy players of what we said at the start and that they need to have a good attitude. Also, “rejoicing with those who rejoice” means we congratulate the winner at the end of the game. (Mom and Dad need to set a good example of this!)
It’s a work in progress of course, but these things have helped all of us lately!
These are awesome ideas Dani! Thank you!
Leila, I used your “ask your family what they actually like to eat” method a long, long time ago, and it went a long way to helping me figure out meal planning that actually worked for our family. (We love your mac & cheese recipe, too.)
These days, I tend to forget that most families DON’T make meals from scratch all the time – it’s second nature for us now. I’ve been teaching my teens to do it, too, so they can lighten the load on my busiest days.
Board games! This is my specialty – I run a website devoted to family board games – and the answer for how to get kids to be good sports is LOTS of practice. It can be really hard, but it’s definitely worth it. Talking before, during, and after games will also help kids to identify appropriate behavior AND how to control their emotions. Cooperative games (where everyone wins together) are also a huge help, especially with young kids. More ways to prevent sore losers: https://www.thefamilygamers.com/4-ways-sore-loser/
Thanks, Anitra!
It’s great that you have a whole website about family games! I am bookmarking it and will share it next time. Good timing for the holidays!
Cool! Definitely bookmarking your site, Anitra!!
Thank you for featuring my question Leila! Lots of good stuff in the comments, as per usual. I’m very grateful for the community you’ve drawn together over here 🙂
You’re welcome!
“Winner cleans up” helps us keep the gloating in check.
That is such a good idea!