So many good books added in the comments to my post last week! Make sure you bookmark it!
I am updating it to include Rosie’s caution over there about some Rosemary Sutcliff books.
That reminded me of times in the past when I have been disappointed in a favorite book’s author’s other offerings.
It happens. It also reminded me of when readers have objected to themes in classics or books I actually consider pretty good reading for children, as have generations before me. For instance, I had to go back and edit, probably kind of confusingly, the post about some Dumas books. Parents need to know, and need to consider whether the issue is enough to take a book off a list. Sometimes it is, sometimes it’s not.
One reader at the very start of the political movement now known as Woke — the view that racism lurks everywhere (and other identity issues too) and the past has to be wiped out (literally, as in banishing books and taking down statues, renaming streets, and so on; always destruction, never production) — passionately objected to my recommendation of Booth Tarkington’s Penrod for its depiction of the characters of the little black boys.
I really thought about it, and here’s the thing: I’m not going to stop recommending that book, not as a classic but as one of those sturdy old books that gives a lot of pleasure.
The character Penrod is not really a protagonist in the sense of being a role model. The mischief he gets involved in is actually put in perspective by those little kids, who, while treated by the author in an undeniably caricatured way that seems unsavory to us now, expose his ridiculous behavior. The book is hilarious and ironic, and it’s good material, especially for boys who are in need of civilizing. I don’t think it makes anyone into a racist to read it — in fact, without, among other things, a contemporaneous picture of life in a mid-century mid-western American town, what context would a young person have for understanding this social ill?
For all my life I have heard people dismiss whole eras because of their lack of conformity to current progressive standards. We aren’t allowed to appreciate the texture and splendor of the medieval period because “they treated women so badly” (an dismissal uttered to me when I was about 18 and converting to Christianity, by an Ivy League Episcopal chaplain who seemed quite oblivious to the intentionally gothic surroundings that provided him with his status and livelihood).
I do think we need to protect children from any explicit or even implicit sex scenes — this goes beyond ideas, directly to material that excites the lower appetites. The post Rosie directed us to points to one book in particular that is rightly just crossed off the list. What on earth. I wouldn’t want a book that glorifies sin, for sure.
There’s the obvious, like treating adultery lightly or homosexuality as normal, and the subtle, like the series of books on the shelves of my library when I was a kid, that depicted the young main characters being inducted into a secret society that ruled the world. It was a strange plot in which the children’s resistance to figures they intuitively found repellent and creepy was overcome by force, moral and physical; and once they were on the “inside,” they were made to drop their fears and basically submit to their gnostic overlords and become a part of an overtly political scheme. I cannot for the life of me remember the names of the books or the author.
However, at the time, though I was definitely absorbed in reading them because they seemed very like the sort of books I loved, I had the necessary criteria embedded in me to reject the premise.
I attribute this protection to two things: first, my parents were vocally opposed to Communism and any form of secretive power in which bad people do bad things in the name of the common good; and second, I had been so immersed in good literature, especially solid old fairy tales with their black-and-white, good vs. evil, immovable morality, that I knew that with the subversive books, I was in the presence of whatever the opposite of that is.
This experience confirms the importance of giving one’s children that vital formation in beauty from the earliest age. The best thing is to provide works of the past that have stood the test of generations, of moral parents reading aloud to their innocent children, of “old wives” who aren’t talked down by meddlers with bright ideas.
Those Bible stories, old nursery rhymes, folk stories, and fairy tales — and the wonderful works arising from that fertile ground, aimed at delight — really do provide protection. We talk a lot about “forming conscience”; I happen to think it’s less of a didactic process (though there is a place for that) than of trusting the collective memory, which has the poetic key to unlocking the mystery of how to do it.
Parents certainly have the right and duty to pass over anything they think isn’t good for their own children, even if it is a classic or on everyone’s list. I am not here to force anything on you, that’s for sure. We have to be careful about cancelling the old things, but you know your children best.
Even if you can’t vet every book beforehand, don’t be fearful. Having given your children a strong foundation, you can trust that a mistake here and there won’t be fatal. It’s like natural immunity. The sunshine, grass, and healthy diet of old-fashioned poetry and stories will see them through the occasional mind- or imagination-virus.
Housekeeping Corner
Taking pictures for the blog just makes me realize I need to clean my house.
Sigh.
Dear Alesha asked in the comments to this post if I have reviewed my vintage sink, specifically how to care for it.
If you are in the market for a vintage sink like this, the main thing to look for is that the enamel finish is in good condition. A little chip here or there isn’t too bad, but if the whole thing is pitted, you are going to be regretting it. And there’s no way to restore it, short of taking/sending it to the one place in the country that re-enamels.
This one was in super condition. I truly only have to wash it out with the scrubber back of my sponge and normal dish soap, or at the most, a tiny bit of Bar Keeper’s Friend gently applied.
Now, I don’t use this sink for my daily washing up. I wanted a stainless sink for the main area, and that’s what I got. This one often has little tea or coffee stains because that’s where it is, near the tea-making station. I rinse off garden produce or often wash out my Instant Pot there. But it’s all easily taken care of.
My friend Shyla has the exact same sink for her main use, and she has a big family! Maybe she can chime in on how she cares for it.
I can get back to my review of my kitchen after 2 plus years — any other questions?

The deck restoration project is almost done. It’s going to look so nice!
bits & pieces
I did a long post on articles I’ve been reading, over here. I don’t have anything cozy at the moment for you, sorry!
from the archives
Criteria for choosing books and movies
follow us everywhere!
Here is all the info:
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them (the old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts)
A weekly podcast, done by Phil and me: On the Home Front.
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
I keep this site ad-free, but you can support me these ways:
Using my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit.
Buying me a skein or two of yarn! (This will appear on your credit card as “LAWLER” — please remember!)
Thank you!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen: Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
My old podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things).
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest







I’m grateful for your book lists, which have guided our childrens’ home library. Recently I became grateful for a corollary thing: the dynamic wherein my kid picks up a new book and immediately gives it to me without looking at it to see if it’s appropriate. I rarely veer from your book lists but my10 year old was so excited to use a cereal box promotion to order a book called “Super Power Puppies” and I let my guard down, because, come on. What could be harmful in that? When it arrived she handed it to me without looking, and sure enough the main character has “two dads” and there’s quite a bit about the blissful pair including an illustration.
Booth Tarkington wrote my favorite book called “the Magnificent Ambersons” whose main character is another lovingly written Hoosier boy, a regular imp.
Wow, cereal boxes stooping so low. Man.
My second favorite Tarkington book is Seventeen. Very funny and you have to read right to the end for the kicker!
Everything is so lovely! 🥰 I love our sink! I always saw my mom clean out her sink with “bar keepers friends” and I keep mine clean and white using the same. Never have an issue! I bleach out my milking bucket in the same sink and I think that helps keep it bright white!
What do you suggest for preschoolers who seem to be overly fascinated by dark characters in picture books (witches, trolls, sorcerers?) We have a few fairytales with illustrations of these, and I didn’t think it was an issue, but my one preschooler really takes down ALL the picture books over the course of a few weeks. And sure enough, she gets stuck at these illustrations. I have explained that these characters are bad and want to harm others, but now I have hidden them because she seems too fascinated. Any suggestions?
And thank you for the information regarding Sutcliffe’s books. I had those two bad ones on my shelf but hadn’t read them yet myself. To the dustbin they go.
Elizabeth Goudge is similar – I threw out her The White Witch and I think two others. I read them and found them so disquieting that I didn’t want to keep them around for older children eventually.
And I have been wondering about John Buchan for teens. The Dancing Floor and Witch Wood by Buchan have some occult themes. I don’t know if it is bad enough to remove them from my shelves or not.
What do you suggest for preschoolers who seem to be overly fascinated by dark characters in picture books (witches, trolls, sorcerers?) We have a few fairytales with illustrations of these, and I didn’t think it was an issue, but my one preschooler really takes down ALL the picture books over the course of a few weeks. And sure enough, she gets stuck at these illustrations. I have explained that these characters are bad and want to harm others, but now I have hidden them because she seems too fascinated. Any suggestions?
And thank you for the information regarding Sutcliffe’s books. I had those two bad ones on my shelf but hadn’t read them yet myself. To the dustbin they go.
Elizabeth Goudge is similar – I threw out her The White Witch and I think two others. I read them and found them so disquieting that I didn’t want to keep them around for older children eventually.
And I have been wondering about John Buchan for teens. The Dancing Floor and Witch Wood by Buchan have some occult themes. I don’t know if it is bad enough to remove them from my shelves or not. But all Buchan’s adventure stories are so brilliant that he is a favorite over here.
Sounds like you need a good old fashioned book burning. As a mom.of an avid reader who read a lot of great younger books, I would suggest sitting down with a Grimm fairy tale book and reading it with your daughter. Pick out stories with bad guys. You want her to see that yes there are bad people, but that they are bad. No goodness in them. Even rumolestilskin is a great read. Beware of books that make the bad guys look good. As my oldest said… She did admire Casca in the play Julius Caesar. He was bad. “Bad to the bone.”. She admitted that because you had so many other flippant characters. Mark Antony for example. But they all left her seeing the state of the human condition. Justy thoughts.
My preschooler recently went through a phase of liking dark stories, although they weren’t super scary… one she kept requesting was the ghostly tale “The Dark Frog” in our Frog and Toad treasury, and the other was a rather creepy copy of Rumplestiltskin (a horrible story with a happy-ish ending and the good lesson: don’t make promises to demons who visit you and offer to help). It kind of concerned me that she wanted to hear these over and over, but now I really think she was overcoming fear and maturing in courage. She also spent some time studying a picture of the troll in the Three Billy Goats Gruff. The first time or two we read it she wanted to skip the page with a scary picture, but after she looked at him for a while she basically told me she could handle it. I think it was just an internal exercising of her courage organ (which would be the heart… I suppose). However, I do avoid “witchy” books in general, especially when they are the protagonist… you certainly should purge them if she shows signs of wanting to be like the bad characters.
That is interesting about the Rosemary Sutcliff books, we only have a few—from Bethlehem Books, I think—and they are the good ones. I have noticed in my own reading that some of my favorite authors’ later books handle things differently. For instance, a more friendly approach to divorce, or more frequent depiction of extra-marital affairs, or pre-marital situations without much judgment. I notice the drift in the post WWII era books (by time written not by subject). I haven’t really looked at our children’s authors in terms of when books were written, but I would be curious to see if Rosemary Sutcliffs books follow a “later is more morally permissive pattern”.
A Cookbook to add to your list…. I was lent your Summa and appreciate your through explanations of books ect. I have an avid oldest reader who read many wonderful books in her youth. She mentioned wanting The ReWall Cookbook. I was not expecting anything super grand. A Cookbook for a book, really. I am adding it to our Christmas list. It is not Joy of Cooking, however it does contain ingredient overview at times, lovely pictures and the recipes look actually real. Thanks to Archive, you can search up ingredients and see those corresponding pages. Abebooks.com has it available for a decent price as well. So… If there are any other moms who have redwall readers, check it out.
The book series you described from your childhood about the kids being brainwashed into a secret society – is it perhaps “The Mysterious Benedict Society by Trenton Lee Stewart”?
Actually, looks like that’s a no. They fit the plot line but we’re published more recently…