I am not sure we women consider the effect of words on our happiness. It’s almost a canard to complain about those older women who can’t help responding with “Wait until he’s two (or a teenager),” or “you will lose your mind now,” or other negative commentary.
But it’s a whole new level in the social media world. I’m not even talking about the entertainment so-called industry, dishing up dystopian images of women forced into the slavery of traditional roles (see the Barbie movie and of course, The Handmaid’s Tale).
I think because women who monetize their accounts are anxious when they have a baby, because, well, baby interferes with their work, they are more subtle, projecting those same thoughts but in an influencing way. When it comes to who we choose to imitate, the slow drip of being exposed to the point of view of a lady who seems very much like oneself, we are more apt to follow her train of thought. If the train is taking us to essential compartmentalization of motherhood, that’s where we might find ourselves going, unbeknownst to ourselves.
Since they’ve sort of put their own life into little squares, whether they are DIYing a renovation or baking or making knitting patterns (just to reveal what my algorithm looks like), a baby is indeed an interruption (even if they have glamorized the arrival somewhat). Then they project their ambivalence onto the audience, and a synergy of negativity develops. Of course a new mother, or mother with several small children, has trouble adjusting — the more so if she has also imposed obligations of meeting the public’s expectations of her product. But is this the whole of the process? It shouldn’t be, unless it confirms itself by means of the narrative it establishes.
There are exceptions, but here are some examples of the messaging I’m talking about that I came across just this past week, and realized that taken with everything else in the culture, they added up to a profound undercurrent of negativity. They were all little thoughts in the larger context of recovering from childbirth to go on to resume some other sort of optimal existence, “fulfilling themselves”:
“Now I’m postpartum and finding myself again”
“Breastfeeding depleted me”
“Pregnancy takes a toll”
Emphasis added.
(I always wish these ladies would say, “And now I’m not going to provide content anymore, because I’ve discovered a new world in taking care of my dear baby!”)
Such negative words have an effect, and it’s not a good one. They strongly imply a fundamental defect in the woman’s bodily design and ultimate realization. They create in the mother’s heart a sort of atmosphere of fear and constriction, especially when she is young and inexperienced.
Such words turn her mind from the miracle of new life, in which she participated in a unique and all-encompassing way: a miracle! The start of a whole new life!
They turn her mind towards herself and her doubt that this could be worth more than whatever the other thing was that she was doing. These words make sure she doesn’t dwell on the miracle, but instead on the change, on the loss, and on the anxiety to have the baby not matter so much to her identity. Isn’t it odd, though, that no one tells a woman who heads for a law office to mourn seeing the blue sky, or what could have been, had she made some other choice.
Do you have these words in your head? “I should get to the gym so I can recover my body.” “I am depleting myself; the baby is taking my life away in the form of milk.” “The time it took after the baby was born to get back to normal was wasted.”
I partly blame some of this, especially the after-pregnancy body shock, on the images women have been fed for generations now. Nothing prepares you for how your body looks right after the baby is born. Somehow it would be good to be told, I think! “You will not believe the change in your body, but you will also not believe that you will go back to reasonableness, and feeling good, and it will be okay, because now you have a baby — a little miracle.”
Our bodies were made to have babies and feed them. They weren’t made to stay virginal, smooth, and taut. Where there are real difficulties, they are not the norm! Just in the same way, if someone has trouble walking, it doesn’t make walking problematic or “take a toll” or cause depletion to the body. Imagine how you would feel about life every day if the voices in your head constantly dragged you down every time you used your two legs to get somewhere! “I need to recover my sofa-sitting self” is not conducive to one’s fruitful existence.
These doubtful, stressful words ultimately cast a shadow on God’s goodness in the making of His plan for woman, man, and marriage.
The things we hear and then make part of our interior dialogue matter! Pay attention to who you listen to if you want to be happy and flourish.
“For the rest, brethren, whatsoever things are true, whatsoever modest, whatsoever just, whatsoever holy, whatsoever lovely, whatsoever of good fame, if there be any virtue, if any praise of discipline, think on these things.” Philippians 4:8
Knitting Corner
I am finishing up some little projects and moving on to others!
Are you doing any crafting these days? You know, sitting at practices, waiting in the pickup line, and listening to children’s narrations are all great times to do a little knitting or such!
I finished that pair of socks — they turned out big! But I’m happy to have used up a bunch of leftovers in a nice way. I’ll find someone to give them to! Just not the young girl who was the intended recipient, so back to that task!
I went to Michaels, where it is a wasteland for knitters and sewists, to pick up some interfacing and take a look at sock yarn. It desolates me to see racks upon racks of acrylic and polyester yarn. They only have three types of wool, I think. I got the pink superwash merino (above, in the basket), for making a cover for a hot water bottle — this project, which is a free pattern, seemed very cute to me!
Never would it have occurred to me to do this, but a friend in our knitting group made covers for her kids’ hot water bottles, a gift they loved. She says they have a little night-time ritual of taking them to bed with them, and they were all thrilled with their covers. It seems like a pretty quick knit, so I’m in.
I think, for this particular project, something soft and above all, washable, is in order, even though I don’t love superwash, so I was happy to have found this pink Loops & Threads yarn.
And I did find sock yarn, two, count ’em, two, balls of the only slightly girlie color:
I forgot that this Kroy yarn knits up in stripes! So that was a fun surprise. I will get past the toe increases and then put them all on one Magic Loop to knit two-at-a-time, which I think is easier on my hands.
I have a pretty big stash of yarn from scooping up what was heavily discounted when the yarn store nearest me went out of business. But none of it is at all for little girls! It’s all blue, gray, and green! A little mustard yellow… So I had to go shopping!
Here you have the bag full of the cashmere I reclaimed.
I put each piece (back, front, sleeves, and neck) into its own plastic bag. What I should have done was ascertain the gauge of the original, because it was a nice fabric (not only the yarn, but the way it was knit up, which is called the fabric). But you see my swatch as well there. I am hoping to make this cardigan for myself (or something similar, which I will explain when I get started — it’s to level up from the rather ratty but well beloved thrifted cashmere cardigan I tend to turn to all winter).
It’s over 500g. of yarn, more than enough to make the cardigan (I hope, famous last words). For $9.10! This warms my thrifty heart I must say. I should keep my eyes open for some pink and light-colored sweaters to unravel for girls’ projects.
NB: I won’t be posting next week, as I will be in Idaho!
Maybe I will see you there?
bits & pieces
- Remembering Russell Kirk
- Every Family Has Its Own Private Language. What Does That Tell Us About Ourselves? (archived here if you’re not a subscriber).
- Do you have an interest in the doings of the Supreme Court? Do you have a student who has interest? A vital resource is SCOTUSblog!
from the archives
- Cranky two-year-olds
- Bad morning sickness? HG? Be sure to read this post!
liturgical living
follow us everywhere!
Here is all the info:
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them (the old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts)
AÂ weekly podcast, done by Phil and me: On the Home Front.Â
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
I keep this site ad-free, but you can support me these ways:
Using my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit.
Buying me a skein or two of yarn! (This will appear on your credit card as “LAWLER” — please remember!)
Thank you!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen:Â Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
My old podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things).
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest









Love the “familect” article (not even sure I spelled it right—maybe starting a new version of the word!).
Also, about women and their bodies, I have long wondered what would happen if the majority of women just let their hair grey naturally—would we be more comfortable about aging; would we see it as a sign of wisdom, a badge of honor, instead of staring fearfully at it. My mother is 89 and I am so proud of that number for her—but many in her generation and the one before were so reticent to reveal their age as if it was some sort of embarrassing fact, rather than a great blessing!
I was reading an astonishing online debate about what it means to age gracefully the other day, none of which seemed to involve looking old or admitting that you’re not in your twenties any more!
To me, ageing gracefully means:
1. Looking old
2. Looking happy with your life choices
Full stop, the end.
Just have to comment on the hot water bottles!! They were the favorite gift of my 6 children last Christmas; you can get them from Amazon in all different colors. I used a sewing pattern to make quilted covers for each child. Don’t forget to make one for yourself!!
Good to know! I did order one from Amazon for the project. I’m excited!
I think this leads to a much broader issue, which is–social media itself. It’s worth considering deeply and praying about what it brings to your life, the positive vs the negative, and if the latter is stronger, cut it out. Social media platforms are designed to make money for the creators, not designed to help us flourish. I’ve been on a 6 year journey of getting off social media, dumbing down my smart phone, and getting my brain back! Yes, I might miss a few good ideas now and then, but the overwhelming effect is positive; it’s so worth it. Plus, I work to sub in real-life experiences. So, instead of being in Facebook groups about fresh milled flour, I started a local group with everyone I know who uses it, and we learn from each other.
Social media platforms are all designed to be addictive. I’m not advocating leaving the world or not using technology (haha, clearly I’m using it now!) but being very thoughtful about how we use it and its influence on us.
These companies wouldn’t be worth millions of dollars if they weren’t affecting all of us. If you believe in capitalism and price mechanisms, you have to accept that social media influences all who use it. Otherwise it just wouldn’t be worth much, if anything.
Amen. I have done a detox from each platform in turn- I am of the age where Facebook was everything, socially, in college- I weaned myself off around the 2016 election. Then I got on instagram and weaned myself off when I had young toddlers- now, when I log on just to check something it is instantly overwhelming and I have to leave. Now I’m in that process on Substack because being off of it for long stretches makes me NOTICE how depleting it is to scroll and take in so many thoughts that aren’t mine.
OOF Annie and Catherine, I SO relate!!!!!!!!! Emphatically. I don’t regret one bit getting off Insta about 2.5 years ago, but now Substack, which initially seemed so golden, is just another landmine for doom-scrolling. And I am also convinced the “algorithm” is just actually demonic, in how it purposefully preys on your greatest weakness, finds the easiest ways to make you doubt everything you’ve believed in, and feeds you just the trash you least need to consume. Ugh.
I’m bummed about Substack, TBH, in a way I never was about IG and FB. I knew with those platforms that my excuses for keeping it were thin and superficial” — like, really, I’d be “missing out” on seeing things, mainly from people I don’t even know IRL? So silly. But I have genuinely found some stellar writers and thinkers on Substack, which makes it much harder to give up. But I think, like you said, the tell is in what I’m like when I’m NOT on Substack for days at a time. My time, my thoughts, like you said, are more ME and MINE. It’s this thought-stealing, thought-cancelling sort of business that I find most frightening about the Notes feature in Substack (and I guess X is like that too, but thank God I’ve never had the desire to go there). I wish it was like it was format-wise about 4 years ago with no feed. ugh. I really, really miss old school blogs that you could visit and just be on that one, discrete site which was naturally extremely limiting (like this one! LMLD is literally the only blog feed that I have at all anymore. EVERYONE ELSE has “gone over” to paid accounts on Substack, and it makes it all the harder not to be playing along).
Much to ponder.
Substack is good because when you are subscribed to someone, you get an email with their actual long-form posts and you can read them that way. It’s the Notes that are on an infinite scroll and function like social media. For me it’s way too tempting to be logged in, and to read what everyone’s saying, and to chime in myself (which I all too often am doing) and then all the responses to my chiming in, with their dopamine hits when people agree and rage responses when someone disagrees… if I could stop myself from logging in to see Notes and commenting, all of that would be the key! Maybe a good resolution…
Yes, exactly. I have definitely done the “log myself out” approach, a couple times. I also can’t figure out how to get the emails to show the WHOLE article, rather than a preview!!! They REALLY want to make you click through to the site. I need to see how to fix that in settings, maybe!
I have been thinking about what is the draw towards wanting to on Notes, and I do think (beyond the dopamine hit issue, which is definitely true), that there is a strong sense that it feels like we’re “talking” or connecting to other people during the day, particularly for a SAHM, who is otherwise really isolated from fellow adults and other moms in our shoes. I felt like at least with old-school blogs, it was really possible for a discussion of sorts (just like what we’re doing here, with commenting) to occur, and it stayed within the confines of that blog post, and that was it. There is a veritable limitless flood of possible “people” and their posts, snippets, responses, re-stacks, etc etc. That becomes overstimulating and I think a lot of what leads to the feeling of overwhelm, emptiness and lassitude after being on the site for any amount of time.
You can set the home page to your subscriptions by clicking on the sort of “inbox tray” icon on the left-hand side.
I don’t have the substack app, but I do web search a few of my favorites writers, or subscribe so I can read it in my inbox. That works pretty well for me to keep the distractions down. I liken it to checking out a reasonable number of library books. Speaking of library books, I notice that getting into one of those helps cut down the scrolling too, but it’s definitely more work to get started on a book now than in the days before I had a darn smartphone.
I agree that it would be better to embrace the changes that come with motherhood. It is good and healthy and right to be fully honest about these things with other women. I do think that it’s better to have these conversations in real life vs online in an attempt to sell Plexus or whatever. A typical real life new mom conversation swings easily from breathtaking wonder about the new baby and complaints about plugged ducts and the postpartum bleeding and hair falling out, etc. But many people, especially new moms, are so isolated, so it makes sense that they are trying to have these conversations online. We all need to do what we can to build real life community.
I think this is true of aging as well. Our society has a very narrow ideal of beauty for women. As for our ideal of what women ought to be doing, forget it. I’ve been a stay at home mom and I’ve been a working mom (in a law office, actually!) and I can tell you that neither of these choices ensured universal approval. Don’t worry, plenty of folks have plenty to say to working women about everything they missed out on by pursuing demanding careers.
I think that’s very fair about the reflections on negative words about being a mother, though it’s also true that the internet is a selective source of information– there are many reasons it isn’t where you’re going to find an abundance of more balanced, positive views. However, I qas hust refreshed by Elsie of Tea and Ink society announcing in her newsletter that her project she has been working on is… a new baby! Yes it takes a lot of energy, so a lot of other things have to wait, but she just framed it so nicely as THE thing she was focusing on– and I think that is the difference? The embracing of it, the choosing? Because as unexpected as expecting can sometimes be, we still have the choice to then treat it like a project we are committing to; we did sign up for this as wives to become mothers, and this is the work we alone can do. I mean, to carry and raise this child– God gives that full role of mother to only one woman in the universe for each child.
Perfect timing on this — I’m taking a philosophy class on Motherhood. It’s a mixed undergrad / grad class — so me, a few other grad students, and about 20 undergraduate women. In 10 days I’ll be presenting on an assigned chapter of a book on maternal ambivalence. While I have plenty to say, I was thinking how much I’d love to talk to Auntie Leila about this topic!
I am not a knitter (and probably will never be — arthritis) but your posts make me wish I were!
This is one of my favorite things you’ve ever written. The power of suggestion is huge and words truly can give us such consolation or desolation. Thank you for being so reasonable and encouraging; it makes such a difference.
I’m so glad you’re talking about this Auntie Leila….social media has so many problems when it comes to women and motherhood! Having said that, I do think a lot of the “pregnancy took a TOLL/breastfeeding DEPLETED me” stuff is coming from a genuine place (I’m sure you agree) and I can’t help
but wonder if it’s due to the lack of any common wisdom about nourishing your body before and after having a baby. Part of it isn’t any new mom’s fault: our food supply is so depleted of nutrients not to mention grown with poisons (pesticides) that something that’s totally normal is now causing issues. On the other hand, so many new moms think the idea of resting in bed is a foreign concept, it’s no wonder they get depleted! Traditional cultures made a new mom stay in bed for SIX WEEKS! Nowadays we expect her to “just bring the baby!” and resume her normal social/work calender. If we all made an effort to actually replenish our nutrients after each pregnancy/breastfeeding “cycle” (for lack of a better term), and did things like taking supplements and special foods for a temporary time with the intention of building ourselves back up, we wouldn’t all be so “depleted”. I also think this is why people (ie like medical professionals) view pregnancy as a sort of harbinger of medical doom: women are walking around essentially malnourished so it’s no wonder something as nutrient-intensive as growing and feeding a whole new human is going to cause issues. I also think this is why women start really having problems by the time they get to the 4th or 5th kid. We really need to recover the collective memory about nourishment and rest. Our bodies run a biological marathon every time we have a child. It seems to me we should start recognizing that and “training” for it.
I should clarify: not every woman will have problems by the 4th or 5th kid…it depends on your general health. Some women do, others have 7, 8, or more kids with no problems! It just depends-don’t want to scare anyone 🙂
Yes! I was thinking exactly this. I really do think that the initial reactions (and I actually hear this more in real life with close friends and family rather than SM) of feeling depleted physically or burnt out mentally and physically (usually from moms of large families with a wide spread of ages), is hugely due to the complete loss of what Leila calls the collective memory around pregnancy, childbirth and recovery!
It’s actually crazy how our society, very much including fellow Catholics and fellow moms-of-many/homeschoolers, etc, makes it seem like the norm ought to be moms trotting out to Mass at 3-4 days postpartum, getting back at homeschooling at 2 weeks, ferrying older kids to activities/school/sports at the same timeframe, etc. It really makes it hard for all of us to internalize that we should be completely resting for at least one full week in bed, focusing on nursing and resting and healing/getting our organs back to their original positions lol, and doing very, very little outside (or inside!) the home for that 6 weeks. The community does do a good job with meal trains, but less so with the larger idea of postpartum rest and recovery and nutritional repletion with healing foods and lots of it.
There are similar problems I’ve witnessed among the husbands/dads even (especially?!) in Catholic work places. My husband has been very vocal about this at work, because many of the Catholic men he works with in a Catholic school have a weird and frankly, extremely distasteful attitude towards fellow husbands/dads and their primary vocation, when their wives have another baby. It’s all, “woahhhh took 4 days off, huh?! Weak Sauce,” style “razzing” each other. It is really, really not pro-life, pro-baby, pro-taking-care-of the most vulnerable members of their immediate society. It’s the rare man there who says, “Take off all the time your wife and baby need. We’ve got your back here at school!” It then makes it really feel, well, awful, as the wife and mom who is just begging for the bare minimum of another adult presence in the home for two weeks, to then feel like she has to field the criticism implicit in these “gentlemen’s” comments towards her husband at work. I find my friends whose husbands are in totally secular workplaces get far, far more generous leave but more importantly, their bosses/co-workers just don’t give them crap about it. I cannot figure this one out, but like I said, my husband is trying hard to push back against this yucky culture there, by reminding younger co-workers to take at minimum two weeks after their wives gives birth, and push back hard against the ridiculous jabs by mentioning they’re supposed to be a pro-life Catholic institution. I know that not every workplace can necessarily facilitate generous paternal leave, and I’m not saying we need the 3 full months that many people I know get. But a Catholic institution would do well, I think, to make paternal leave for fathers of many a big priority as a pro-life witness, putting their money where their mouth is.
Man, that is nuts and would make me feel awful! Good for your husband for pushing back and helping bring these guys to their senses. I hope the culture at his job can shift.
Right?! At my parish it’s almost like a competition to see who can get back to Mass the soonest after having a baby! Ay yi yiii….
That is so sad about your husband’s workplace-it reminds me of the latin maxim which translated is “the corruption of the best, is the worst”. Good for your husband for working to change that! I really think a lot of those kinds of comments and subtle pressure (whether from coworkers, family, husbands or whoever ) is coming because a lot of people don’t want to help the new parents. (Because it’s almost always coming from someone who will be directly inconvenienced somehow by the parents having this new baby.) I think in order to recover the collective memory on this, we all need to move beyond our selfishness as a society. Everyone wants to “live their best life” but a lot of elderly don’t want to give up their Mahjong to go stay with and help the new postpartum mom or younger men/women help pick up the slack at work when a coworker has paternity leave. I also think this is why everyone subtly pressures new moms to get back into the normal swing of things asap: think how much the average Catholic, large-family homeschooling mom does, alone, for her family. There’s a strong temptation for husbands (and the grandparents) to get her back doing that just so everyone else can keep getting their needs met/enjoying life with minimal interruption. I think being open to life means you have to start taking peoples comments with a grain of salt and realize they are probably just being selfish and are struggling with the idea of you (ie the new parent) probably going to need something from them at some point in the near future. We are a society that prizes its independence and new babies really mess that up.
Yes, yes, YES!! This is so true – that we are all walking around mostly malnourished, due to our food supply and food choices (like the modern elimination of organ meats from the diet, etc.) – so that pregnancy wears us down far more than it should. After my first baby – and I started severely malnourished, though not knowing it, and also having hyperemesis – it took me a full 15 months after the birth to feel better. Now I am appalled at how we are, as a society, putting women into marriage and pregnancy with bodies so malnourished that they can’t handle pregnancy and breastfeeding. We really need to improve our food and food-processing choices.
Do you have a good resource for learning how to darn – book or website/videos? Since I invested in high-quality wool socks, I now want to invest in repairing them!
I have finally resolved to start sewing, knitting, and ironing in front of my children, instead of “saving” those activities for quiet, alone time. With the arrival of baby 3, I finally realize I need to learn to do this work with them around, or I won’t get to do it all. Lo and behold, it’s good for them to see me doing these things, and they’re not quite as troublesome as I anticipated… most of the time!
I purchased the book Mending Life, and I really appreciated their simple darning instructions. I’m sure there are more complex ways, but it was a great place to start, with good results!
Thank you, I will look that one up!
I recommend, as well, going to the library and browsing the section that has this topic. It’s fun to take the books home and see what you can get out of each one.
Old housekeeping books often have mending sections.
I will keep my eye out for something helpful!
I love this, thank you. I had my 6th at 38 and I’m almost 40 now and recovery is just taking a long time (I did NOT rest postpartum and I am Paying For It), and add to that that part of me that wants to kick and fuss at realizing that youth is behind and six babies has altered my figure and I’m just not ever going to be that slim again! But I’m slowly learning to not only accept but enjoy those middle-aged changes. I get to be “matronly” now!
For wool yarn I’ve come to get it mostly from KnitPicks. It’s a nice midrange: you can still get good quality yarn without breaking the bank with boutique prices (same reason I get most of my bulk tea from Adagio. I can’t afford the very best but I’ll settle for a couple orders of magnitude better than the grocery store). All we have in our area is a Hobby Lobby and they’re no better than Michael’s for stocking natural fibers. I do confess I’ve been knitting socks in super wash but I do kind of need to be able to launder them without them shrinking into a sad little wad.
I’m (re)reading Kristin Lavransdatter right now and whoa–it really hit me last night how much this attitude runs throughout various characters in the book. Feeling sorry for a woman who has 8 children; fostering the baby out to a wet nurse so the mother can regain her health, or because pregnancy took enough of a toll on one so young (Ramborg) so lets give her a break; being glad about a long separation between husband and wife because it means no more babies for a while. Women who still look young and beautiful “despite” having a number of children. Etc. Of course there were also factors like a high rate of mortality in childbirth, and that the more children you had the more financial worries you had for them as adults. So interesting–I’ll be looking for this elsewhere in literature now too, I think.
It also spurred me to look at some other “historical views” on the topic and I found these lines in A Call to a Deeper Love, the letters of Sts. Louis and Zelie, and thought I would share:
Speaking of a woman she knows who has been advised to go to Lourdes to ask for the grace of having children “but she declares she doesn’t want to because she’d be afraid of having too many. As she loves her pleasure immensely, she prefers not to have any at all rather than be a slave” St. Zelie–CF 51
but in the same letter she says of herself “I’m not afraid of the effort” of nursing her baby if she is able to.
“As for me, I’m crazy about children. I was born to have them”- St. Zelie, CF 83 🙂
Leila, this couldn’t be more timely. I had my 11th baby the day you published this post. I agree with everything you said.
Wading in delicately here. Grandma of 11. Youngest is 6 weeks old. Beautiful post, Leila. I have a small sharing. Words. We serve each other well when we don’t lean into “memory amplification“, to the point of using words that describe catastrophe when telling our birth stories. I can’t spill the beans on how I know this information, just to say that I’m not a doctor but I raised one. When babies have to come out fast for safety reasons, it’s not necessarily an emergency or a traumatic birth. When it’s a traumatic birth, there is very effective help for resolving the effects of that, from the information I have, it is one of the most eminently treatable conditions (single trauma in an otherwise healthy individual). And kudos to every one who makes that treatment possible or seeks it out.
No one is asking anyone not to share their own version of the most intimate participation in a miracle. No one should have carry a burden that they didn’t need to carry, and it can shape the conversation in the community for the better.
I see posts online of a woman being afraid to share that they are pregnant with a fourth child with their mother. who thinks their daughter’s health will be (fill in the blank, destroyed, forever altered, etc.) That shouldn’t be.