Kitchen Renovation: Soapstone Countertop Review
As promised, a little revisit of my kitchen renovation, which was more or less completed in early 2024. It still feels like “my new kitchen” and I really love it.
Of course, I’m the kind of person who thought of my old one as “newly painted” years and years afterwards, always appreciating the “updated” color of it (BM eternally cheerful Hawthorne Yellow, one of their historical paint colors and in my opinion, the only true yellow with no unpleasant personality traits). Here’s a post with some befores and afters, by the way. Let the record show that I would have just carried on with my old kitchen, but there were some structural and practical issues from a previous renovation (before our time) that had to be addressed, going beyond simply repainting and so on.
Personally, I love considering all the factors and elements of what goes into a kitchen (and all aspects of the home), so I don’t get tired of thinking and talking about it. I still read articles about the best this or that choice (countertops being a good example), even though I have obviously crossed that bridge!
Okay, let’s talk about countertops.
If you read all those articles, they will usually steer you through the main kinds: quartz, quartzite, marble, granite. Here’s my take on those:
Quartz is the man-made “stone” on the list. There are different qualities of this substance and some are not at all going to perform the way people present it. The look of it can start to get to you if you go with the veining, because it’s computer-generated and your eye will always seek out the pattern — it’s like being in the re-education room in That Hideous Strength.
Quartz that is made without veining is nicer, in my opinion, because it’s not pretending to be something else (marble) and doesn’t have that tiring aspect to it of making you interpret it. It reminds me of Corian, which I actually have in a bathroom here, and I don’t hate (don’t love the beige, but that’s another story). It is what it is. I don’t think quartz is that heat-resistant and Suki has it in her rental house and says it has chipped quite a bit (it was new when they moved in a few years ago).
Most of all, my objection to it is that it’s manufactured, and the process is extremely toxic, making workers sick and even killing them.
Quartzite and marble are beautiful and natural. They are expensive and require sealing. They are going to etch and chip. You can put hot pots down on them. I love marble so much. I would totally go with honed marble and not even really worry about sealing it. However, the color of marble was just not going to play well with my yellow/cream preference for my color palette; the gray that was available in all the slabs I saw cries out for gray or green paint choices, or a white that pulls from the slab.
When I observe myself every single day going around dripping lemon juice all over, I know that marble is not for me in the kitchen (love my marble fireplaces and hearths). But I love and admire it in others’. My daughter-in-law Natasha has marble in her kitchen and it’s just beautiful. She also is fairly okay with patina and aging.
Granite is also a good, solid stone. It can be extremely busy, color- and variegation-wise, and I don’t go for that. Also, the trend has been for a long time to polish it to a high shine. Sometimes it’s part of a dated renovation. When you see another stone in a kitchen with an aesthetic you like more, you might feel you need to get rid of it.*
*I have a thought for you: consider hiring professionals to remove the shiny finish. Matte stone of any kind looks amazing. If you are longing to transition to a more unfitted, true old-world look, it can take some time and thought, and it’s always worth working with what you have and taking things little by little. Honing the counters you have could be the answer, though my search revealed that some kinds of granite would not stand up to the treatment at all. A local fabricator could tell you what is possible. Fabricators are a helpful lot, I have found! Here is an article about the process: Outdated Granite Countertops? Here’s How to Fix it.
I certainly could have gone for granite. There are dark ones that would have been just as dramatic. In the end, I wanted the soapstone: the way it feels, the very New England quality of it…
NB: Please know we are talking about choices from a blank slate. If you already have something you’ve agonized over, bought, and paid for — and love! — I’m not trying to make you second-guess it or feel bad about it. Obviously these are personal preferences — mine!
Here are the counters the articles usually don’t discuss:
Wood/butcher block/reclaimed bowling alley or such; and soapstone (also slate but I know very little about that other than that some old timers here swear by it).
Wood can be a great choice and is much cheaper in general than stone as long as you aren’t needing a long run of it. If you treat it properly, it can even be good around the sink, though I think eventually you would need to replace it. However, even that expense would not add up to the expense of stone.
It adds a homey, warm feeling to the room. Scratches can be sanded out and if you finish it the right way, it’s not hard at all to refinish it as needed. I found this post super informative and encouraging.
In the end, I chose soapstone. You can read about it here.
In the pictures in that link, things are new and newly oiled. In these here in this post, you’re getting my everyday version after 18 months. I didn’t spruce things up for you at all.
Soapstone is awesome. It’s antibacterial and anti-fungal. It’s easy to maintain. The kind I have is not the very rustic version that is authentic to antique kitchens in my area and is a very light gray; mine is black soapstone and while it is honed, it does have a more polished look. But you can’t put a gloss shine on soapstone! Just can’t be done. Mine reminds me very much of the high school science lab counters of my youth, but a bit nicer with the veining.
I love the drama of the black and how it plays with the yellow of the cabinets. I love how durable it is and that it doesn’t etch or stain at all.
It feels amazing.
One thing you might not really think about is that substances have their own thermal conductivity. There is a name for it but I can never remember and it’s one of those things that’s impossible to look up because you always get results for something else. Maybe you remember and I might have already posted about this. But anyway, it has to do with how things feel different even when they are all in the same 68° room. Steel feels cold. Wood feels warm (and I do miss that about my old island butcher block). Stone has a wonderful, cool feeling under your hand. You expect quartz to feel colder than it does, because it looks like stone but has a lot of synthetic resin in it.
Anyway, I enjoy the feeling of my soapstone.
I oiled it at first (using mineral oil and then my own homemade beeswax and oil paste). It’s really true, as soapstone owners say, that after a while, you don’t need to do much in that way; I don’t know why, really — and some never bother at all. Very high-traffic areas like right next to the sink do end up needing a touchup once every few months, but it is a matter of wiping the dry stone down with an oily cloth and then giving it a quick buff.
I found this bit of crockery at the thrift store and I keep an oily rag in it.
Once in a long while I do a proper job but it’s more like a concerted clean, like anyone would do, followed by a pass with the wax paste and then some buffing, than “sealing.”
Every one of the kinds of countertops I mention here has its drawbacks because nothing in life is perfect! So it’s a cost/benefit analysis.
For instance, you might not think it, but one benefit of my old white Formica, than which there is hardly anything less desirable, was that I never had to dry it to prevent water marks. When I wiped my counters, that was that! They were clean! It never occurred to me to get out a clean towel to wipe them dry so that there wouldn’t be little droplets. I never even noticed if they were actually wet! I never gave it a thought.
The soapstone does need to be dried off at the end of cleanup; a lighter color would not need that. I use a clean dish towel that I then hang on the oven door to dry.
And it does chip. Here are two rare chips on the highly used edge of my sink:
The are smaller than the head of a pin. I am careful with how I whack a pot on the edge of the counter; I don’t slam my cast iron around or throw things towards the sink. The other advantage of the white Formica was that I didn’t care! Ah well.
Soapstone can scratch. But it can also be sanded.
So that’s it, I think! When I consider the negatives of other stones, I am okay with these negatives. The positives are so very positive! Feel free to ask me anything!
Knitting Corner
I am still working on some projects we’ve looked at before, so I will just show you the quick leg warmers I finished up on April 19th and then promptly put on because it was just that cold, yes, even with my woolen dress, tights, etc. The suffering, I’m telling you!
I had two skeins of Woolstock Bluesky worsted. It’s a beautiful yarn. I probably could have used a bit more, to be honest, but I was desperate to cast on something very simple for my car knitting, and I only had the two.
So one skein per warmer. They are very simple indeed: I cast on 48 stitches, 2 x 2 ribbing at the bottom, stockinette up the legs, 3 x 1 ribbing for a good length up to the knees, one row of 1 x 1 ribbing, Italian bindoff.
Next time I might cast on 54 and yes, maybe use up 3 skeins all together.
I came across this adorable little chick pattern and decided it would be a perfect little project to jump-start my 7 yo granddaughter’s knitting energy, which has been waning, for lack of inspiration I think.
There is only so much practicing a little girl can do! We need to knit something adorable and fast, so I will show her this on Monday. This is one little square which you fold, sew, and stuff. It almost shapes itself, and then you add the comb and beak with some red yarn scraps and a needle. You can find more detailed tutorials anywhere online. I would just say, cut the yarn long so you have enough to sew it up with, and use any weight yarn and whatever size needle works to get the fabric you like. For this size chicken, you’re aiming at about a 2″ square.
I’m working on another one, in a finer yarn (just a leftover in my stash):
Here’s another little project to knit from a square: a bunny!
bits & pieces
- I always get the question about what to give young people for a news resource. By high school, they should be very familiar with journalism and how to read a newspaper, but handing over a newspaper is an exercise in parental irresponsibility! It was bad enough in my day when everything was traumatic Vietnam War accounts and images. Now it’s unfiltered, biased sewage.
I don’t know the answer. I was talking to Rosie about it and she mentioned that she gets the 1440 Daily Digest but wouldn’t just turn it over to her kids (the older two are 15 and 12). And anyway, something actually in print would be desirable. She also does get Oyla, a science magazine, for her kids. She does look it over first, and has removed two articles from it. She told her older kids that she’d be happy to tell them what the articles were about but didn’t want to leave them in there for the younger ones. She pointed out that when she was a kid, we got three newspapers a day at our house! In a way, having so much meant that whatever was buried just didn’t attract her attention. Sigh.
I posted the question on Substack, and there are some helpful answers if you’d like to take a look. Full disclosure, the editors of Dad News Network are good friends of ours; I can totally vouch for their respect for the innocence of the young.
from the archives
When you try to live differently, do you feel a bit misunderstood by those closest to you?
Two Rules You Need Now (substitute “turning on a device” for “TV” if you need to)
liturgical living
follow us everywhere!
Here is all the info:
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them (the old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts)
A weekly podcast, done by Phil and me: On the Home Front.
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
I keep this site ad-free, but you can support me these ways:
Using my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit.
Buying me a skein or two of yarn! (This will appear on your credit card as “LAWLER” — please remember!)
Thank you!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen: Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
My old podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things).
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest















My guys read the Epoch Times often, for what it’s worth.
I appreciate this discussion and will look into the suggestions! I am curious about World Watch News as a video source, suggested by someone on your Substack. I have seen a few Christian (not Catholic) homeschoolers praise it recently, and I am considering it for next year, but I don’t know enough. I suppose my best bet would be to prewatch it everyday, since it is only 10 minutes. I wonder if there are other similar, trustworthy video resources out there, especially from a Catholic perspective.
Couldn’t see your beautiful soapstone counters without mentioning another possibility: concrete! My husband poured our countertops out of fine concrete tinted a dark gray, like yours but without veining. I thought it would be a disaster, but it was a surprisingly simple one day job, plus install the next day (requires several very strong men!) I was scared they’d be rough or weird, but he applied an oil based (foodgrade) sealant and they’re a buttery soft matte- so nice to the touch! No chipping or discoloration yet, and I’ve been able to buff out some light knife scoring (kids and their resistance to cutting boards…) An economical option to check out.
M, how long have you had it? We are definitley going w/ concrete in the 2nd kitchen, but i am unsure of the main kitchen.
I am highly wanting to hear from folks who have had it for a few years. What is the upkeep (let’s be honest here y’all, i am not gonna reseal it, like ever, and if the tomato sauce stains it i am unlikely to care much, except maybe to spill more on purpose and swirl it around all over. Does it chip? I have every intention of putting whatever out of the oven right down on it.
I will chime in and say that later, when I talk about the area behind my main sink, I will mention that water collects there. It’s just part of the way the window is. But I was talking about it with my contractor and how I hadn’t thought that I’d have this problem of the water there. He said, “well, it’s better than at my house [he has a similar bump-out behind his sink] — I put in concrete counters and it gets wet like that and then doesn’t dry for 6 hours! It just soaks into the concrete and stays wet. At least you can wipe yours up.”
Going on two years. No staining yet. Not problems putting a hot iron skillet right down on it. No chipping, but some light scoring. I do reapply the sealant once a year. So far so good. Interesting about water retention- haven’t experienced that…. Maybe a different sealant?
Good to know your experience!
My mom has wood and they are beautiful 🙂
I used to get the 1440 Digest and it was good, but I eventually got tired of the blatant liberal bias and unsubscribed. Now if I want to know the news, I usually check out Breitbart news. It’s got a lot of clickbaity fluff but there are some good articles sometimes. I also check out LifeSite news if I want a specifically Catholic news source.
This is also gonna sound really weird, but I also visit the meme boards if I want to know what’s going on or big news. You can actually find out a lot of news, especially the buried/suppressed news the MSM doesn’t want to talk about, from what people make Memes and jokes about. If there’s a breaking hot topic you can bet some Internet troll is making a meme about it.
We just can’t send our kids to these sites, alas…
Sorry, I forgot we were sharing recommendations for kids 😅
I was just saying what I use-It would definitely be extremely irresponsible to send a child to a meme board.
I just wanted to add to the discussion about countertops: if you think you want soapstone, but you’re worried about scratching or price, take a look at leathered granite. To my great surprise we ended up with a slab of black granite with white veining. The leathered top is matte so it doesnt look shiny or dated. It also turns out that as the popularity of granite has fallen, so has the price. We ended up paying less than half the price we were quoted for quartz. I love it so much. It looks like a LOT like soapstone, it doesn’t scratch, I can put my hot pans straight on it, upkeep is super easy, etc. etc. I never thought I wanted granite, but I’m a happy camper.
Yes, granite is a very durable and good surface. I think getting it honed or leathered is the way to go. It’s the extreme shininess that is making it look dated. Also, paying attention to the colors in it. If the countertop is too busy, it’s going to be very “bossy” and hard to deal with from a decorating point of view. That goes for marble too! Some of the trending slabs are so loud and demanding with their high-contrast veining. It would be one thing in the lobby of a bank or something, but in one’s kitchen, I think it would get tiring!
Thank you for mentioning this! I am liking the sound of it for when I get around to replacing my builder grade fake granite!
(I am a different Annie with a green symbol haha how funny!)
I have granite tiles for a countertop. I’m looking into a new one because the grout gets filled with stuff and then when I scrape it out, some of the grout comes out too. Yuck! I want a solid surface, but I’m at a loss because we have a real kitchen with real children and real messes. I’m seriously considering wood or perhaps something else around the sink. I expected real granite to be expensive so I haven’t given it a lot of thought. Concrete was an option until I realized I had to seal it, then I dispensed with that thought – I don’t want to have to seal something.
Make sure you go to the blog post I linked, about the wood counters.
If possible, try to find some reclaimed butcher block or even bowling alley or other flooring. Old wood is much harder and more durable than new. The old butcher block counters are made of wider boards than the new, as well.
It depends on how long a run you are looking at, too. The fabricator might have a length that would suit you.
You can also use different materials if you have different work areas. For instance, let’s say the area around your sink is 14″ in one direction and 18″ in the other, and the sink itself is 30″. That’s a total of 60″. Maybe the fabricator has 5′ of a nice honed granite leftover from a big job. If you give him the job of installation, he might give you a real deal on it. For instance, my fabricator had a 5′ length of marble and was going to sell it to me for $400 for my island, and that is actually really not much at all! In the end, I just didn’t love the veining in it and went with my same soapstone. But if I had loved it, wow. I would have had a deal.
If you go in that direction, you could use butcher block for the other areas, the non-wet areas.
Go back to my post about unfitted kitchens. And look at this post, in which the whole topic is discussed and you can see how the very most cozy kitchens end up using different materials in different areas: https://ladybutterbug.blogspot.com/2014/07/unfitted-kitchen.html
I love your kitchen and never get tired of hearing about the details! Does Rosie get the junior science magazine or 12+ versions? Thanks!
We got the older version (my 10+ kids got the most out of it, though everyone at least dipped in). To be fair, we don’t get it anymore, but did get a year or two’s worth, two years ago. My oldest is pretty science-minded, and they had enough meat in them to spark some curiosity and hold his interest, which is what I was hoping for! I’m pretty dismayed at how content-free most such things geared towards kids are.
Rosie- I’d love a post about the homeschool resources you have found worthwhile!
Any direction (from you or your commenters!) on bathroom materials (floor, shower, countertops, etc.) ? We are getting two bathrooms completely new this summer, and I don’t know at all what to look for!
We just built out the first bathroom, and went with limestone tile, large, for the floor. We will seal that tile in the bathroom, but we may not in the other parts. We’re still in talks over that. We’ll seal it ourselves, as the tile guy is done. The shower pan (aka, the floor of the shower) has specific requirements, the tile can be stone, but only a certain kind. We had a harder time finding and agreeing on that, than the other materials. It also has to be a smaller tile, so that the floor will drain down properly, so even if you want large tile on the wall, you will have to have small on the floor. Make sure you have enough grout space between the tiles, so pick something intended for that purpose. Take advice there. The shower has the subway tile in a ivory, oversized. I originally wanted a herringbone pattern, but changed my mind due to the smallness of the wall, and just went horizontal. We did use the same color grout on everything. It is a very small mud-room style bathroom- the sink is a utility sink, but the toliet matches all the others, and has a straight bottom- not the formed pipe looking sides, to make cleaning easier. We end up with dust, and in this bathroom, i suspect mud, all over the sides of the bottom plumbing of the toliet.
For all the tile we went to the big floor big box style, dedicated to flooring. they were much easier to deal with than the small tile place that had all the samples.
I meant to put this in the post: if you are doing a small area, be SURE to check with local fabricators. Often they have part of a slab left over from a job and will sell it to you for a good price. You can pick up beautiful marble this way!
It really depends on what the bathroom is used for, the style of your house, etc… make a Pinterest board and pin pictures of bathrooms you find in houses with a similar style to yours that you love. Sometimes simple marble tile is great (and big box stores like Floor & Decor have lots), sometimes simple black-and-white porcelain tile from Home Depot works perfectly because it’s timeless and has been used for more than a century. There’s a lot to think about with grout color etc so you really have to make that Pinterest board so you can see all the possibilities and successful projects and not be unduly swayed by what’s trending with contractors! If you have hardwood already, that can be awesome too.
I have two boards you can look at, though I was focusing more on fixtures than floors. Remember, when you pin one thing, it will pull up similar things under it when you click on it. Pinterest is super helpful this way! https://www.pinterest.com/_leila/bathrooms-of-smallness/
https://www.pinterest.com/_leila/bathroom-shower-inspiration/
One of my favorite things about hearing about your house is how you use pretty little things (found at a resale shop) to house the practical, not pretty things to keep them handy. That pretty blue dish with the oil towel in it is the perfect example. It inspires me to find things around the house that are pretty and make them practical too.
Thank you! I had seen some soapstone owners saying they kept an oily rag under the sink and I was like um… that does not sound like a nice or even practical way to store such a thing! I was brainstorming what I could do and thought, I just need a dish with a lid! And there is a nice consignment store near me where I found this one. Perfect!
From here in South Africa, we can’t find soapstone at all. I suppose one can privately import (LOL!) We have been sooo lucky with the quartz (manufactured stone) that we found for our kitchen last year. There are so many options that just look totally fake! We used Bianco Cloud. It has been popular, as a surprisingly good marble ‘impersonator’, for at least a decade. You buy them per slab and even if I try, I can’t spot the pattern, that is how large one pattern (slab) is. It is not an overwhelming pattern either. We love it so much!
I have loved your kitchen make over process and used so many tips. The cabinet handles in bronze and different ones here and there was a big one. My soft white kitchen does not look like a laboratory at all! Thanks to aunty Leila. Another thing, was incorporating old wooden cabinets (hosiers?) into the kitchen, instead of more built ins. Those cabinets are beautiful (one for our good crockery, table linen and serviettes, the other for drinks and glasses) and even though they date from late 19th century (!), they were still cheaper than building in some more cabinetry. I love the loose standing look they give.
Hi auntie Leila,
I was wondering about the thickness of your stone. We’re deciding between 2 cm or 3 cm. Any input would help! Thank you.
My counters are 3 cm. thick. Perfect!