Homeschoolers know what their critics are going to ask:
“What about socialization?”
And we’ve developed a lot of defense mechanisms to cope.
I actually happen to think there’s a grain of truth in this question.
First, two parameters for the discussion:
- I have little bits of evidence to support socialization as a valid goal, though we may not all mean the same thing by that word! This is my “rough draft” so to speak!
- Public schools certainly do not do any of the things I’m going to mention. They have lost the way. The older people who make the “socialization” comment have a very distant memory of what they are talking about. It doesn’t exist anymore. I think it should, but it doesn’t, so don’t worry, I still totally hold the position that in our time, homeschooling is best, with a very, very few exceptions where there is a good, old-fashioned-style school to send them to.
Those who are going to school their children or who are involved in education should be sure to read Pius XI’s encyclical Divini Illius Magistri, On Christian Education.
It is a master class on the relationship between the “three societies” — family, state, and Church — and on the importance of schools and of sound education generally. You might be surprised to be challenged on subjects like same-sex education and the sound reasons given for it, and on the natural-law arguments for the primacy of the parents, who, he says, “are under a grave obligation to see to the religious and moral education of their children, as well as to their physical and civic training, as far as they can, and moreover to provide for their temporal well-being.”
He sees the danger we do (quite a while ago for him, and even worse now):
The declining influence of domestic environment is further weakened by another tendency, prevalent almost everywhere today, which, under one pretext or another, for economic reasons, or for reasons of industry, trade or politics, causes children to be more and more frequently sent away from home even in their tenderest years. And there is a country* where the children are actually being torn from the bosom of the family, to be formed (or, to speak more accurately, to be deformed and depraved) in godless schools and associations, to irreligion and hatred, according to the theories of advanced socialism; and thus is renewed in a real and more terrible manner the slaughter of the Innocents.
Anyway, Pius says this about education:
11. Education is essentially a social and not a mere individual activity. Now there are three necessary societies, distinct from one another and yet harmoniously combined by God, into which man is born: two, namely the family and civil society, belong to the natural order; the third, the Church, to the supernatural order.
He then goes on to explain all that in glorious detail.
A good school, where the teachers see themselves as assistants to the parents, not usurpers, and where the mission of the school is kept to its boundaries, not infringing on family life, will not only teach the curriculum, but will provide an environment where children can expand their knowledge of others and learn to interact with those who have different habits and proclivities.
Where everyone basically adheres to the 10 Commandments and wants the good of the child, the school can be a place where correction and supplementation can be administered to the inevitable insufficiencies of the “imperfect society” (as Pius calls the family — imperfect simply because it stands in need of others).
But one thing that’s so important that in many ways we had achieved in more peaceful times is hard to pin down. It has to do with the impossibility of adults to pass along all cultural wisdom directly to children in a way they can assimilate it. There’s only so much instruction you can give a child. Some of what he needs to know comes from experience, but in an emotionally and spiritually safe place, as far as possible.
That experience needs to come from older children who themselves are wisely monitored and observed. Let me give you some examples.
I once saw someone lament “kids today” not knowing how to play stoop ball. He said “their parents didn’t teach them.” But this is incorrect! Children of the past didn’t learn to play stoop ball from their parents! They learned from older children.
There are so many schoolyard games we played, and we learned them all from the big kids. Not only did we learn kickball, touch football, hopscotch, and many other games from them, we learned fairness and meticulous observance of rules and the bending of them when a player was smaller, unfamiliar, etc.
We spent a lot of time on the playground. Schools today do not have this important aspect of education. There were playground monitors and I honestly don’t recall any bullying because these ladies were pretty sharp-sighted and my elementary school was small. But we had two long recesses plus time after lunch and before school, and those times were full of games of all sorts.
Socialization — learning to play with everyone, taking your turn, responding to your name being called, dealing with annoying people without running to an adult — happened mostly in school, though we had the neighborhood to roam around in as well.
Here’s another good thing: children in America had a lot of chants we pulled out in various situations. There were the silly songs we sang while doing clapping games— and these were actually important for 7-12 year-olds to get the brain cells and nerves working at high speed (we played them lightning-fast), with arms crossing the midline, so important for becoming proficient at reading. I think the girls did this while the boys played catch.
Friendly competition, day after day, drives the acquisition of these actually complex skills. This is not a once-in-a-week thing, nor can adults really implement them.
I was reminded the other day about how, if we second-graders noticed a boy and a girl having a crush, we’d chant at them (and I got this chanted at me too!): “First comes love, then comes marriage, then comes baby in the baby carriage!” You know, there’s a warning and a life lesson about the proper order of things, all wrapped up in a few words, right there. If everyone’s on their devices, this message will not be delivered. But it also won’t be delivered with quite as much situational directness if one’s social group is basically one’s family, with a few friends encountered on random or sporadic occasions, as in the home school.
Finally, there’s nothing wrong with giving different adults and other, unrelated children the opportunity to smooth the rough edges that indulgent parents don’t attend to; nor is it a bad thing to have them appreciate the child whose parents might be exacting and strict. Where society is more or less aimed at the same goal, of cooperation and good will, socialization is actually a good thing. It should not usurp the role of the family, but it also should not be eliminated.
I honestly lament the disappearance of the neighborhood school in stable communities. As a child with a troubled home life, it provided me with at least some guardrails. Sadly, the troubled homes began to outweigh the stability.
It’s a somber thought to know that my parents, with their divorce, contributed to that loss of stability, because I think most of us tend to think personal choices don’t matter much. But they do. With the sudden shift to individualistic, pleasure-oriented pursuits, that society was overthrown.
Notice by the way how much of what I think of as socialization in the sense our critics mean (though they might not realize it) is not about what goes on in the classroom. It was mostly about the school yard and recess and the walk to and from school, though learning to hear others out and to listen respectfully to the teacher were good things as well.
So it’s worth thinking about how we can offer our homeschooling children (or the schools we organize) this sort of socialization — not what we hear and react to, when we are confronted with the charge, which makes us think about mindless conformity and the stifling of creativity, if not worse.
Instead, let’s acknowledge that we can’t go it alone. We need, for our children’s development and within the circumstances we’re dealing with, the interaction of other families, of outside activities (within reason), and of the community.
*I don’t think he meant America, but it could now be said of America, sadly.
bits & pieces
- Recess at school is vanishing. I think I read somewhere, but don’t have a link, that more and more, recess includes doing things on one’s devices. When you consider a school for your child, recess should be an important criterion.
- The Brilliance of Metaphor and Why the Left Can’t Meme — Emily Finley with some good insights on metaphor and nature: “… the Christian relationship with nature is one that is ordered toward God the Creator. It allows us glimpses of eternal truth, of the manifold beauty of existence. In so doing, it inspires the poetical mode of thought.”
- When Emily says, “In my estimation, the most effective (and funniest) writers are those who have command over the use of metaphor,” I thought of P. G. Wodehouse, whose creativity in that subset of metaphor, the simile, is unparalleled. Wodehouse alone is a good reason to make sure your young ‘uns read Shakespeare and Dickens, for they will miss half the fun if they are unfamiliar with those inspirations for Wodehouse’s flights of wit!
- Amelia McKee writes about the liturgical, historical, and poetical background of Mary, Gardens, and May. This Mother’s Day, Deirdre and I did some companionably puttering in my Mary garden, pulling out invading vines and pruning rose bushes. I will try to move some Mary flowers in there shortly. Here is a picture from two years ago:
- A review, by John Byron Kuhner, of The Lives of the Caesars, by Suetonius, translated by Tom Holland. “It is easy to feel that our era loves the Roman Empire too much, and the frugal, law-abiding, freedom-loving Roman Republic too little. I would rather see a new Hollywood movie about Scipio Africanus than another Gladiator retread. Yet the basic reason for having a republic at all is found on every page of the Lives.”
- For more “bits & pieces” from me, be sure to go to my Substack, Happy Despite Them, where I have “my open tabs” with other reads.
from the archives
- Decorating books — and beauty (and Pinterest). How do you find your own style? Some thoughts from moi.
- May is such a good time for beginning a simple prayer life with children.
follow us everywhere!
Here is all the info:
Visit me at The School for Housewives and recommend it to your young friends!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them has moved over to Substack! — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing! The old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts.
There you will find the weekly podcast done by Phil and me, called On the Home Front. Do let us know what you think!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
I keep this site ad-free, but you can support me these ways:
Using my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit.
Buying me a skein or two of yarn! (This will appear on your credit card as “Domus Enterprises” — please remember!)
Thank you!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen: Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
My old podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) if you haven’t heard them.
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest






Thank you so much for this reflection! As a homeschool graduate who is about to start officially homeschooling my own children, this both articulates an unease that I have felt about homeschooling, and offers some points for me to discuss with my husband this summer, as we set our course for the coming year.
The problem though is, what is going on at school? I don’t know that there are the games and songs that came about over the years when kids were just allowed to play together, in school and out.
My friend is a 4th grade teacher at a catholic school. A few years ago she found an old old book of games and began teaching her students some of the jump rope rhymes and games. 3 years later she was out on the playground and saw some younger girls playing a Clapping game with a totally different rhyme. Success! A little push on her part has brought about a small revival!
Yeah, that was what I was thinking as I read– I actually did have this playground experience at my Catholic grade school (whatever the tone and academics of the school, which were a mixed bag), but I really, really wonder if almost any schools, be they private, Classical, Catholic, or public have this environment available anymore.
My kids went to a very small Christian school until it closed when my oldest was 8.
Since it served PK-8th but was TINY, all the kids had lunch and recess at the same time – and many parents would let their kids play together for a few minutes after pickup, too.
It’s the only place in my adult life that I’ve seen those kinds of multi-age playground games happen without an adult to initiate them.
My daughter goes to a pretty humble neighborhood Catholic school and she came home and taught her little sister all these hand clap games and jump rope rhymes! It’s still out there!
This is one big reason we moved back to the city. We live on a street with children, and while we’ve had to lay some guidelines (no screens with neighbors, EVER, like don’t even go on their porch if they’re there with a tablet), they have played so many games of tag, mafia, kickball, etc in the street. They’ve also learned to deal with some obnoxious personalities, some very different family backgrounds, and my daughter had a habit of crying loudly at friends when she didn’t get her way nipped quite early thanks to the little girl who would simply go home in response to it!
(Also … the neighbor kids don’t sit outside with tablets any more. Turns out it’s more fun to play outdoor games with actual kids. 🙂 )
A good balanced article. Your comment: “….I still totally hold the position that in our time, homeschooling is best, with a very, very few exceptions where there is a good, old-fashioned-style school to send them to.” The school may be very good, but in my experience, the problem is the socialization that takes place between other students and your child. Kids on smart phones sharing stuff, poorly behaved kids who are sent to good schools in order to be “reformed” that end up “reforming” your children, etc. There are other issues with schools, as I see it. One is that there is so much wasted time spent in school, which could be used more wisely at home, teaching the basics. And not to mention time to pursue other interests like piano, reading, crafts, gardening, animals; which is excellent education all by itself, for children), etc. I think if children that are homeschooled go to church, attend homeschool groups, have play days with like minded families, are apart of a big family of many siblings, etc. they get some “controlled” socialization which children under 16 should have, in my opinion. Once they turn 16, it is time to begin to commence, to start, to release … 🙂 letting them go slowly until they are 18 and able to begin to make their own decisions, or their own mistakes, as the case may be. Always enjoy your writing! Keep up the good work.
It’s not just about being together, though. It’s about those little games and songs passed down. I have a fear they will be lost, and it’s easier to lose something than to find it.
I appreciate your perspective on socialization-as you define it. As a former classroom teacher, and a former homeschool mom (kids young adults now), I struggled with getting my kids the right sort of socialization (the kind that didn’t require lots of damage control). We moved a lot–problem #1–and the few homeschool groups we connected to were difficult to be involved in. Playground days were great for my son, but my daughters (one with special needs) never connected to the girls. We had similar problems later with youth groups–very nice Catholic group but difficult for newcomers to get connected with such a strong inner circle. We probably could have done a better job–tried harder to connect them, but friends were few from elementary through high school years. In retrospect, and with many old fashioned school/playground stories from great literature we have read, I can see the advantages of the right sort of school experience.
Hi there: I am not trying to. be provocative or negative but I feel called to say you are really off base in your characterization of public schools. I just retired as a public school teacher, having worked in this capacity for 32 years in several different elementary schools. Now I have not been in every school in this country and I am sure there are some bad ones that do not do a very good job of socialization. But let me tell you that not one of the elementary schools I have worked in could I recognize in your description. May I ask what your description is based upon? When is the last time you spent significant time in a few (more than one) public schools? Are you repeating what you have heard or read with stories that from others that lack context and may or may not be true? I can only tell you that I have never meat such loving, conscientious and professional folks as the teachers I have worked with over the years. Teachers are leaving in droves partly because they are demoralized by folks who constantly put down public education (which is the same as putting down the teachers who work there). We are dedicated and love what we do. We are offended by implications such as we are trying to “take over the parent role” “groom or indoctrinate children” and “do not teach respect. ” This is completely untrue and frankly slander. The vast majority of teachers and most schools are communities of support and caring and parents are looked upon as the most important members of the team cheering on the kids. We teachers work with the parents and support families throughout the year. We impose nothing on children except the notion of respecting each other and making a healthy community. My schools had 3 recesses a day where kids engaged in health competition, played soccer, taught the younger kids 4 square. One of the schools I worked in had the older 5th graders mentor the kindergartens and read to them daily. Have you spoken with any parents (who represent the majority) who love their kids neighborhood schools (and yes there are many) and love their kids teachers. Or have you only spoken with members of the minority who do no not. The schools I worked in had tons of parent volunteers and family nights. The school was a bastion of light and fun in the community. Parents input was welcomed and respected. Most of the kids thrived. Of course nothing is perfect but on the whole they were pretty good. How can it be good for the vast majority of kids who do attend public school (and by the way that is the majority of kids in this country and unlikely to change) to demoralize the teachers and the schools they create constantly by saying how bad they are and spreading inaccurate information? I am not saying there aren’t some “bad” teachers like every profession but most are wonderful, hard working folks who try and do their best everyday. And when you demonize or tear down public schools you are demonizing, insulting the teachers who work there because they have pride in what they do, and take ownership for the “vibe” of the school. Especially when the information presented is inaccurate and not based on personal witness, but what is said on the grape vine or rumor mill.. Please volunteer at a school near you and tell me if you still feel this way. Teacher’s jobs are hard enough and getting harder; they do not need this lack of support and appreciation. The best thing to do to make out public schools even better, that won’t cost a dime. Love our teachers!
Not sure where I said teachers groom anyone… anyway here’s the link, if you missed it, about recess in public schools: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10319329/
Look, I don’t agree with Leila on everything all the time (don’t do that with anyone else either – not even my husband ^_^ ) but I think anyone who has to pay property taxes (and even those who rent do – albeit indirectly through their rent) which pay for teacher pensions, school bond repayment, school building maintenance, etc… should be allowed to care, have an opinion and proclaim it without being accused of “demonizing” or being told to go volunteer too. : D I’m sure you pay property taxes too whether or not you’re a former public school teacher. I would expect you and Leila both vote at school board elections and do what you can civic duty wise. It’s good to discuss concerns – especially because they impact us all and our kids, grandkids, neighbor kids, etc… whether or not we homeschool. That study was concerning and I’m glad you shared it, Leila. I’m glad you care. As someone who happily homeschools and was happily homeschooled, you’re spot on about how the mix of ages and just being around different kids from different families helping prepare us for grown up life.
I live in Massachusetts like Leila does, and I DO send my three kids to public school. I think the teachers are doing the best they can, but the culture of multi-age-kid-play that I desire does not exist here. Why?
(a) each school only serves 3 grades (K-2, 3-5, 6-8, highschool). Kids get very little exposure to anyone more than a year away from their own age.
(b) at the elementary schools, each GRADE has recess separately, so even in that narrow span, there’s no opportunity for different ages to play together.
(c) starting in 6th grade, the kids don’t get recess and aren’t even allowed to go outside at lunch.
(d) everything is highly mediated by well-meaning teachers who want to keep kids safe. So kids don’t get any opportunity to be bored, or uncomfortable, or come up with their own games that would be slightly dangerous or simply annoying.
(e) kids under 8 basically aren’t allowed to be alone, ever. A parent MUST be present at drop off and pick up, even if the kid lives close enough to walk to the school, even if their bus stop is in front of their house.
My family has accepted that if we’re going to use the public schools, this is (sadly) part of the culture, along with cell phones creeping younger and younger (few elementary kids had them just 5 years ago… now most of the 4th-5th graders do). I think these trends were creeping in already when my oldest started public school, but then our district’s response to COVID made it so that kids were not allowed to play with each other for a full year – except online. So, now that’s what many kids think of as “normal” play – going online instead of playing outside together.
The problem though is that while you’re correct-that there are good public schools here and there, it’s now become too much of a Russian roulette problem to find one. And no one wants to risk their children’s formation on the hope that “well maybe THIS one is ok”.
If these teachers care so much, fine-but just because you guys work hard, it doesn’t mean you’re above criticism. And a lot of you are working in a bad system and you know it.
You live in a rich, safe, white bubble that the vast majority of America do not live in.
After homeschooling for 19 years, we have been privileged to place our younger four children in one of these very rare old-fashioned schools that you mention. I have seen benefits in this school setting that we did not have in our homeschool. I have felt the need for my children to have other trustworthy adults helping shape and mold them, and for my children to learn to navigate a setting where they must cooperate with the group to some extent and keep their emotions appropriately in check. I have observed other homeschooled children who are nothing but cry-babies because of the mother who means well, but hovers! No option is ideal or perfect, and as parents we must always be trying to balance out the weaknesses of whatever situation we are in. Thank you for these thoughts Leila, they encouraged me today!
Where did you get the statue of our lady that is in your Mary garden? It is my favorite statue of her that we have in the adoration chapel at my parish and I would like to have the same one in our yard.
I got it here (but the price has gone way up, sadly): https://inhisname.com/products/25-inch-mary-queen-of-victory-outdoor-statue-13308
Thank you Leila. This is a really important discussion. I homeschooled for 10 years and now my youngest two are in a really lovely Catholic School. Morning recess before school, lunch recess and now that the weather is warm they are outside again at the end of the day. They have learned all sorts of new games. Daily gym class is another highlight along with Mass three times a week. Many of the school girls have started veiling. Father comes to teach and offer confession to the kids regularly and there is an adoration chapel in the school where I attend adoration weekly. We have been very pleasantly surprised by the healthy environment at school. No phones or smart watches are allowed. It’s not perfect of course but neither was home school. I thankful for school at this time.
I enjoyed this post! Our lovely co-op has about forty kids who do a great deal towards softening each others’rough edges, but the games that I played as a kid seem to have to be introduced by me or by dad. We do see clapping games still.
We’re blessed to have good neighbor kids, tons of kids at church, and the co-op, so we have more socialization of the less organized kind than we can fit in. Games though – that’s something to ponder. Thanks!
I so agree with all of these thoughts! “Socialization” was always my husband’s concern when we began homeschooling, which we did for two years and it was crushingly isolating when we lived in an area where there were very few other homeschoolers. My children would look longingly out the window in the morning at their friends being driven to school and would wait 8 hours for them to return! In the three years we have had them in Catholic school, we’ve seen that the socialization is not the type we had hoped for. It’s not even a given in Catholic schools anymore that the families are there for the morals and values. Many of them are broken homes. And the school certainly usurps the parents with things like those awful “stranger danger” and “good touch bad touch” lessons even for preschoolers, although they do give the option to opt out. We’re moving to a new state next month and our children will be part of a “tutorial.” Classified by the state as homeschoolers, they’ll attend a full school day with other homeschoolers twice a week with paid tutors, and then do assigned (classical, Catholic) work at home under my supervision three days a week. Recess is an hour long with all the grades together. We’re seeing this model crop up more and more and it seems like a wonderful balance.
Thank you for making this observation, Leila. It is something I think but often do not say because it seems to trigger people on both sides (public schoolers and homeschoolers). I am pro-homeschooling and agree it is often the best available option to families, but I do think God made us to live in community and homeschooling by nature is often a withdrawal from community rather than an attempt to create a new and better kind of community.
I know quite a few very excellent homeschoolers, truly upstanding and wonderful people, who really do have the sort of “go it alone” ethos in their families. They are so used to taking care of it that they just withdraw into their own little world and only come out to get what they want from others. Again, they’ve often had to do that to survive and to raise their kids as best they can, but what I’m saying is along with the positive goods they’ve provided to their families there are some negatives, which I think others can sometimes see more easily with the “socialization” topic. For example, their kids can be withdrawn, poor at communication, and stunted in social skills — not always in super obvious ways, but in ways that naturally accrue from dedicating your days mostly to your own concerns and not having quick and frequent social feedback from people outside your family.
Partly this is because it really is a large task to ask a mother to a) not use birth control b) feed her family healthy and frugal (i.g. largely homecooked) meals c) educate all her children while often still tending to babies and toddlers and d) then “in her spare time” try to host community-building activities! Of course it’s POSSIBLE, but it definitely increases the likelihood of mother burnout and related health problems. And if mother goes down, the whole family is at risk.
Cultural breakdown places such a huge burden on families to fill in all the gaps that used to be filled by functional kinship and friendship networks. This is why I think a good school that stems from a healthy and thriving church is such a blessing if one can get it. And yes, good does include attracting families whose kids don’t have their own cell phones, share prosocial (i.e. Christian) norms, etc.
I also think that in this environment people perhaps should move INTO town to be closer to and more able to connect with and mutually serve their church families, rather than isolating themselves out in the country. Especially if you are having one baby every other year for a decade plus without any nearby family. It’s just ridiculous to ask the average woman to do that with zero community support.
I couldn’t agree with this more. I taught for a while at a very solid classical school. The school wasn’t perfect but the community of families was amazing. Money cannot mend a school deficient in community.
Where I live now this isn’t an option and very likely won’t be while I am schooling my children. I do love homeschooling but I don’t think it is a superior option to a good school. However, we must make do with the times we live in, and the places.
Your thought about moving into town reminds me of Caroline Ingalls’ request to Charles to give the girls an education, keeping them near a town. I think being in community with other families makes a great deal of difference.
I agree with you, Joy. It’s something I muse on often. Mothers can’t be all things to our children, and we need so much more trust-worthy support in our world. I can’t help but feel like the Church is letting us down on this front.
As someone who grew up homeschooled until 5th grade and begged my mom to put me in normal school so I’d have friends, I really appreciate that you’re tackling this delicate subject. Socialization IS crucial, but unfortunately the public schools aren’t providing it either. Even when I did go to regular school (various privates and then later public) I still felt isolated but in a new way: the other kids didn’t share my Catholic values and the older I got, the more that bothered me.
So there really aren’t any perfect solutions anymore. My daughter is 2, but when she’s old enough, I’m resigned to the fact that we’ll probably have to homeschool. A Catholic school is my first choice for the socialization, but I’m realistic enough to know even that might not be a possibility if there’s none nearby or even a good option if the school isn’t run well.
We’re all just going to have to do the best we can-God writes straight with crooked lines.
My children attend a classical hybrid school. The mom who ran our field day yesterday said that her favorite part of the day was seeing kids of all ages (kinder to 11th grade) working together naturally. She said she felt like that natural, cooperative interaction was the result of the parenting our students receive and then bring into our school. Do we have some students who aren’t being raised that way? Sure, but the general tenor of the community is set by the big (formerly homeschool) families.