How can you teach your toddler to obey?
Children need to learn obedience. Obedience is really self control, because it means not giving into one’s passions but instead following authority; the authority in turn follows the truth and what is good for the child and for everyone. (In other words, the authority doesn’t act arbitrarily.)
So a big part of learning to obey is learning self control.
To learn self control, the little child needs patterns.
To the child, there is no inkling, not a hint, that the day will take a turn and we will find ourselves eating supper.
The toddler has no clue that the playground can be found, quite reliably, down the street.
Certainly a big baby can’t even imagine what you could be doing when you are out of his sight, or that you even exist at all.
So before a child can obey, there is so much he has to learn about, well, everything!
The wise mother doesn’t see these things as separate: the daily patterns and the learning of obedience. She sees them as one. She doesn’t just move her child from one place, one thing he has to do, to another. She sees getting him out of his crib in the morning as a chance to awaken him to how this day is like the others, what we will do next, and how their bond will create trust in him eventually to obey her.
“Let’s get your diaper changed and some nice clothes on so we can go have breakfast! One, Two, Buckle my SHOE!”
Divide your day into “units” so you’re not both just wandering aimlessly through it. Have a purpose for each unit, including rest.
The pattern of the day with its quieter times and its more active ones offers many opportunities for cooperation, trust, and learning self control, that lead to the habit of obedience. Here are some examples (and I’m thinking of an 18-24-month-old):
“Run and put this dirty diaper into the trash for me, please!”
“Please hand me the baby’s blanket.”
“Dash over there and get me some diapers and the wipes.”
(The new baby is a great way to establish the idea that your toddler exists to run and do things for you.)
“It’s nap time now; up the stairs we go, [singing] Go to sleep, little baby, Go to sleep, little baby, Your mama’s gonna sway, And your daddy’s gonna pray, Won’t you close your eyes, little baby?”*
“You want to read a book? Yes, let’s! First put this truck back on the shelf.”
“Soon it will be time to get things ready for Daddy! Want to play outside while you’re waiting?”
Remember to say, long before you are barking out a command and expecting compliance, “You know, it’s good to obey Mama! When I say to do something, you say, ‘Yes, Mama'” and do it — such a good boy.” The best time to say this, lovingly, is occasionally as he is actually doing what you asked.
*Nursery rhymes are crucial for so many things, establishing patterns being one of them!
It’s better for you to ask for something even if you can do it yourself, if you see it as a moment where an aimless little kid can gain a sense of purpose.
As you go through the day, he starts to interpret your warning voice and connect it with something he shouldn’t do. Of course he wants to do it anyway! That’s the passionate toddler in action!
If it’s something merely naughty, mother doesn’t panic. She remembers he needs a pattern, takes into account his age and development by standing above and separate from him, not letting him get under her skin, and keeps correcting, over and over.
Firmly. Explain a bit but then just rely on calm firmness. She realizes that most of the time he literally has no idea what’s going to happen. A mess is to be expected. “That’s naughty!” is the proper response if it really was naughty. If it’s just something inconvenient, well, do your best!
If it’s something legitimately dangerous, she acts swiftly. No, you don’t have to explain as he reaches for the electrical outlet or is about to pull something heavy on himself! You can yell and even deliver a spank if the circumstance warrants it (i.e. he has been told before). And because of the trust built in the other little interactions, the germ of an idea grows in his mind: that he must obey.
Anyway, I’ve been getting a lot of comments and mail from moms of littles on this topic. Teaching obedience takes a long time in a lot of cases (especially with boys): obedience doesn’t come from a vacuum. It comes out of the relationship you build on the foundation of the little things you do all day long.
Grocery-Store Herbs Corner
I think the rosemary is dying, but I got some basil at the grocery store and divided up — there are like 12 or more little plants in that one container, for $3!
I have had this little terracotta pot for ages (mug for scale) — it’s so little, and has no drainage (not that I would know what to put under it), so whatever I plant in it dies immediately. But it’s darling and my hopes refuse to be dashed.
I never could figure it out until I had the idea to cut one of those plastic six-pack seedling cells in half lengthwise. I divided the basil plants up in it, smushing it in the planter. It fits right inside and I think this will work! I also cut the basil way back.
I have repeatedly affirmed that I am not an indoor plant person but this is making me happy. Even if it doesn’t make it. It’s only $3! You can’t even buy three eggs for $3.
Thrifting Corner
I put this on Instagram but I thought I would show you here too.
Here is one of the items I told you about last week: a beautifully made, high quality 100% merino cardigan:

But I didn’t like the buttons.
They are metal and really quite ugly!
So I replaced them with pretty shell ones from my stash, that however do not photograph well as they are so shiny!
Maybe this helps you see how just changing the buttons can really change something from a bit frumpy to really special! Or maybe you have to see it in person to get it!
More on Small Kitchens
Except the high chair ones.
I detest those IKEA/triptrap chairs. I think in a small or very cluttered space (like my big kitchen with all its chairs and pathways) they are just a menace. But they would be a menace in an open field. Isn’t it enough that we are tripping over the dishwasher door? And the dog?
Auntie Therese and I were discussing them as we were appreciating the old wooden high chair she obtained for her grandchildren in her little cottage. We were sharing our detestation of those awful new ones, ranting away as only two grandmas can.
She pointed out that they are made with those splaying legs because it’s supposedly safer, but of course everyone other than the baby is over there breaking their ankles and toes every day! She thinks the old-fashioned kind are fine. “We’re always there. We aren’t going to leave our baby alone to stand up and tip it over.”
So anyway, if you are going insane with those ridiculous (yet appropriately named) TRAPS of death, may I suggest a sturdy vintage wooden high chair. (I do endorse the other ideas of the clip-on kind or the ones that sit on regular chairs.)
This one has gone through 5 of my own children (I threw away the stupid plastic-and-metal one I had for the first two) and all the grandchildren when they are here (though it was unjustly sidelined in favor of the triptrap one when Deirdre was living here). It is 42 years old. The tray is annoying, I’ll grant you. But it only trips you sometimes.
bits & pieces
- I forgot to say, in my Lenten pep talk, to just… leave your phone out of your bedroom when you go to bed. Try it. Here’s a good article about phone use: Do you remember how life used to feel?
- Looking for incandescent bulbs (say yes): I always have to do a search all over again, but these are an amazing price compared with the ones I’m seeing on Amazon right now. I don’t know about these particular bulbs, but they have good reviews. I have ordered from this company before. Always check the bulbs right away to be sure they aren’t broken. A broken filament has a very high-pitched ringing rattle to it.
- The role of bitters in your nutrition. I tend to think the American diet doesn’t have enough bitter things in it, and could be one reason why we are always catching all the colds etc.
- I know the trending thing is to think “just buy organic” and sometimes it’s a good thought, but sometimes it’s not. We have to be savvy! Hidden dangers in organic food.
from the archives
- Say this instead of “because I said so” — you’ll be amazed
- Toddler Life
- What Can Children Do? A Guide
liturgical living
follow us everywhere!
Here is all the info:
Visit me at The School for Housewives and recommend it to your young friends!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them has moved over to Substack! — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing! The old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts.
There you will find the weekly podcast done by Phil and me, called On the Home Front. Do let us know what you think!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
I keep this site ad-free, but you can support me these ways:
Using my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit.
Buying me a skein or two of yarn! (This will appear on your credit card as “Domus Enterprises” — please remember!)
Thank you!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen: Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
My old podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) if you haven’t heard them.
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest









Yes, it is hard to photograph anything shiny! But I can see your sweater is transformed – what a nice thing for you, to have this at such low cost.
Great post, as always. I will warn people, though: There are older vintage high chairs that don’t have enough of an angle on the legs and can be knocked over. A friend of mine lost a sibling in a high chair accident, so these things do happen, especially if you have a lot of kids and/or pets coming in and out.
Oh, that’s so awful!! I’m so sorry.
Yes, I think Therese and I were acknowledging the safety issue. Basically, the ways people can hurt themselves are myriad — for babies it’s usually stairs and bathtubs, so sadly. We were just agreeing that we didn’t leave our kids unattended at all in the chair. (That said my kids definitely fell out of them… )
The vintage wooden high chairs are darling, but my issue is that they have no buckles! I used one at an acquaintance’s house once and my 9-month-old took every opportunity to attempt to stand up in it! I would rather eliminate that particular safety-and-also-power-struggle issue by just having buckles on the high chair!
I know… but you can get a harness.
I am enjoying your very informative links. Please tell Auntie Therese, that from your blog, have admired her beautiful cottage for many years.
What beautiful new buttons! And thrifting always seems extra special because one never knows! Maybe a dead loss, maybe lots of wishes granted. In any case, it always feels like a special gift from God when I find just the thing by thrifting.
We manage high chairs by buckling one to a regular chair. Buying an extra harness is excellent! So nice to have one to swap in while the old goes in the wash. They’re only about $10 on Amazon.
Congrats on the live rosemary! They’re tricky. A dear gardener friend always quipped, “A dry rosemary is a dead rosemary!” Your clay pot is darling. We’ve had several hardware stores and nurseries closing, so I’ve been restocking my clay pot hoard. Just about any stray plant looks better in a clay pot, I think. Have you tried the lowly but faithful Pothos plant? I wish I could pass you a cutting. Our modern (but lovingly thought out) sanctuary has vines on either side of the altar, Pothos vines. I’ve inherited watering duties and am making firm friends with them. They’re like the best kind of church lady – always shows up, not too picky, functional, and reliably graceful and cheerful.
Ha, no, the rosemary is, I am almost positive, quite dead.
It’s the other ones that are doing well!
Sigh…
Perfect timing! I’ve been wondering and asking friends how I teach my 21 month old daughter to obey. She knows the word “obey” right now, but is still lost in her little world much of the time. I feel reassured that I’m heading down the right path with a rhythm to our day and giving her little tasks and that this will just take time!
One thing I observed a friend do that I could see wouldn’t work—her toddler threw a heavy water bottle which landed inches away from the baby. My friend corrects her toddler in a very soothing, pleasant tone, “No, no honey. We can’t throw the bottle.” I realized, if I was the toddler, based on the mom’s tone of voice, I wouldn’t take it seriously at all!
Now….about the toddler whining? Anything we can do to “fix” that?
Also, we’ve had good luck with the Abiie high chair (although maybe this is the design you don’t like?). Of course, it’s pricy but we got ours as a hand-me-down from a friend. The chair’s footprint is completely underneath itself, so less likely to cause tripping. And I really like the adjustable seat and footrest. I agree that the Ikea chair is a nightmare for small kitchens! It feels like it’s deigned to trip you!
It really is a matter of grasping that the child has so much to learn!
You are right about the toddler throwing the heavy bottle. He needs to hear concern and disapproval in mom’s voice, and a sense of urgency. He needs to hear “Be careful around the baby!” and “Do not throw that bottle”
And then mom needs to insist throughout the day that he start on the path of learning cause and effect of heavy things being thrown.
Little children have a need to throw things! Are we giving them scope for that? It’s all about awareness, a growing awareness of when it’s okay and when it’s not.
As to whining… yes, yes I do: https://likemotherlikedaughter.org/2013/09/whining-whiners-and-how-to-cure-them/
By the way, all these things are covered in my book, The Summa Domestica!
We have had a different high chair for every child so frustrating thank goodness they are all second hand. I think this time I’m going to look out for a nice Eddie Bauer one. The ones I have seen are wooden look nice and solid have straps but also have a plastic tray which is easy to clean and put on and off. My mother-in-law has her beautiful old wooden high chair from her childhood in the 1950s at her house available for our children. Being resourceful she sold a cover for the seat back that has a buckle attached to it. And my father-in-law fixed the tray so it easily slides out and off.
Also a word about plants and clay pots. The clay itself absorbs moisture this is a little time consuming and messy but since you have that extra sink you can actually fill the sink and soak your clay pots In about 2 inches of water for an hour. This keeps the pot moisturized and the plant roots can take up the water better.
This is so funny to me! I have that exact Kirkland sweater, in a different color, and also replaced the buttons because I detested the clanking metal buttons. Mine are plastic now, because I haven’t built up the beautiful stash of buttons you have, but it’s so much more pleasant to look at, wear, hear!
That is so funny! Ha! There was another one at the thrift store. It was gray and so I didn’t get it, but I should have. It is so well made and I like how it looks and feels!
Mine has help up for a decade with fairly frequent wear! The elbows are starting to get thin, though. I’ve darned thicker sweaters but aren’t sure how to make it look nice on the thinner merino, so I’m just wearing it less 🙁
The Catherine Shannon article (Do you remember how life used to feel?) is excellent! She offers a lengthy portion for free, but some of it is only for paid Substack subscribers. The last line I could read asked, “What’s it like to live without a smartphone, week by week?”
Did you subscribe and read the whole thing? I’m wondering if it’s worth at least a one-month subscription just to read it in its entirety.
I don’t subscribe to that one. I think I just got the idea from what she shared, which was a lot and very helpful, I thought. But sure, $5 doesn’t seem like a lot for a month’s worth of her ideas if they are up your alley!
I loved the obedience subject . I have had an interesting experience with my oldest son. He was a very serious little boy. He was learning piano but I didn’t want it t feel like ‘hard work’ so I used to say to him after his lessons ” You’ve worked hard so now go and relax at the piano”. I always used to say that and to this day, now he is 18, he still ‘relaxes’ at the piano after studying or coming home from his part time job. Yes, it does seem routine and lots of time with mum is the key to discipline?
The piece about bitters was so interesting! I want to try! Have you incorporated bitters into your diet yet? Let me know if you have any tips!
Just got my copies of The Summa Domestica! What a gorgeous set. Now to the most challenging task of doing my domestic work and not spending the whole day reading!!!