I am back in business now! Sorry to go dark here. We had server issues but now they’re fixed, I am hoping!
So now we have lots to talk about.
Let’s start with something on my mind — teaching a child to write.
Let’s avoid a syndrome that’s quite pervasive across our society; it involves identifying a problem, marshaling experts to address it, seeing that things are getting worse, and then layering on another system requiring more experts.
I’m thinking of the decline in our population as a whole and our students in particular of literacy, religious education, math and science skills, and so on. There’s always another credentialed entity weighing in… meanwhile, colleges everywhere have pretty much given up on the idea of requiring students to write capably (and they know students don’t read).
Add to that the incentive to monetize the system — that is, the evident demand eliciting purveyors with shaky credentials who offer ever more complicated systems — and you have what amounts to a trap for innocent consumers.
These sellers assure the rather panicky homeschooling parent that the purchase of this new curriculum or hire of a tutor will do the trick.
But actually, all that can’t really be true.
How is it that in the colonial and 1800s eras of our country, those with a third-grade education had more literacy than we, and in the last century, even a rather poor so-called “disadvantaged” high school student’s vocabulary, syntax, and diction were better than ours?
It’s precisely because we are making things so complicated that we are failing.
In one way (thanks to those monetizing experts), we expect way too much from young children. It’s a truly rare child who can write an essay, for the great majority simply have nothing to say yet — they are still absorbing. It’s a kind of malpractice to ignore and even thwart this normal development.
In another way, we don’t expect enough. We allow them to be passive in their oral and written expression and we don’t help them with the years of reading and handwriting needed before a good sentence, much less magnificent treatise, can emerge on paper.
That “good sentence” should be your first goal.
Remember how I said, before school started, to set your goals for the year?
Your goal for your seventh grader should be to write a good sentence — if he doesn’t already. But does he?
The experts want that child to write a five-paragraph essay comparing two works of literature. I want him to emerge in the spring able to write sentences with subject-verb that agrees-object, sentences with dependent clauses, sentences free of dangling participles, and sentences in which the normal word order is inverted.
In eighth grade, the goal should be to write a good paragraph.
The paragraph should express and develop one thought and the sentences in it should, in general, have the same subject and not jump around. The paragraph should not begin “I think” or “There is” or “There are.”
If in elementary school your child develops good handwriting, makes lists, copies dictation, writes notes, jots down funny things his sibling says in a family log book, and copies poems into his journal, he will be ready to tackle his seventh- and eighth- grade goals.
In ninth grade he will be able to make a quick list of three things he wants to say about a thesis he has stated; he will write a five-paragraph essay developing it. The truth is, if he masters the paragraph and counting to three, he will absolutely be able to write an essay. My husband, an excellent writer and college professor, says so!
In the upper level of high school, the student should write an essay of two or three pages every week in this manner — using his good sentences, paragraphs and thesis statement. I promise you he will then graduate as a literate person who can either successfully start a business or learn a trade or perform well at an institution of higher learning.
I have chapters and chapters on the details of all this in my book (volume 2). There are lots of posts here on the blog.
It’s a process that takes confidence on your part — the confidence of sticking to the simple but not flashy process of setting the goals without trying to micromanage or overwhelm your child with managerial procedures; he’s not a machine! He has to figure it out for himself, by means of tested methods with far better results than what we have now.
You need the confidence of not feeling inadequate when others wave around their new shiny expensive packages. Look at me — I have a whole blog about homeschooling and I keep posting about tattered old texts from the 20s — the 1920s. But my (grown) children can write! It’s not easy to have confidence in the face of all those experts, but you can do it.
Do search out the old primers and writing texts. Much less expensive, much better.
Sourdough Corner
I hope you are practicing your sandwich bread! The reason to make this bread as you are learning is its ingredients: the milk and sweetener give you a lot of wiggle room for achieving a satisfying loaf. Success breeds success. You start to understand the bread developing under your hands. So keep at it — soon we will be tackling crusty loaves.
To develop your intuitiveness and emphasize how I do not discard, ever, I want to show you what I have in my jar before the feeding:
And in the bowl:
I have tinkered with the KA recipe to increase the volume. It could even be more. Try making it, if you would, and let me know how it compares. (The recipe is typed out below, and I’ve included a printable PDF file!)
Meanwhile —
Notice how full your bowl is when you put in the flour! Try after a while to just put in that amount without measuring.
Put the amount of salt called for in the recipe in your hand. Feel how it feels, look at it. Try just pouring it into your hand without the measuring spoon. See how the bread turns out.
Sourdough Sandwich Bread Like Mother, Like Daughter
Printable PDF: Updated Sourdough Sandwich Bread
(If you are looking at my notebook there, you will see I didn’t include any butter or oil, but I did add it to this recipe.)
For the levain:
65 g. starter (1/3 cup)
85 ml. water (1/3 cup)
11 g. rye flour (1T) (if you have it)
80 g. bread flour (about 2/3 cup – a little more if you didn’t use rye)
Let that rise for about an hour, up to three hours or so. You want it to look lighter than when you mixed it, but you won’t be able to see it doubling or even really rising, because it’s a small amount in the bottom of your big bowl.
Once it’s looking active (bubbly, airy, lighter), add the following:
750 g. bread flour (if you have found that your loaves from the KA recipe seem small, you could go to 800 g. or even a bit more and add a bit more liquid) (6 cups)
350 ml. water (1 1/2 c.)
50 g. dry milk powder (1/3-1/2 cup)
2 T to 1/4 c. softened or melted and cooled butter or oil
25 g. salt (1 T)
60 g. honey (~3 T) or sugar
Mix up your dough, adding the liquid slowly if you are using a stand mixer or all at once if you are mixing by hand.
Allow it to rest for about 25 minutes.
Turn out onto a clean counter and knead for 1-2 minutes until it’s smooth and cohesive.
Rinse out your bowl — no need to wash it! Bits of dough are fine. You just want the interior to be wet so the dough doesn’t stick after it rises.
Put your dough back in the bowl and cover with a warm, wet, wrung-out towel. Place the bowl in a warm spot (my oven’s light warms things up sufficiently that I actually set a timer to turn it off after about 1/2 an hour — watch this because you do want the dough warm, about 75°F, but not warmer than about 90° for very long).
When the dough has risen 60-100% (stopping short of losing its integrity on the surface, which indicates over-proofing), gently turn it out onto your very lightly floured counter.
Using a bench knife, divide it in half. Gently form your loaves by patting each piece into a flattened rectangle the width of your pan and rolling it up rather tightly, tucking in the sides, or by dividing each piece into three, forming strands, and braiding.
Try not to use much if any extra flour. It’s better to wet your hands than to add more flour, which will not have fermented and so will add a flat taste to your bread if you use too much.
Place each piece in a greased bread pan (8.5″ x 4.5″). Let rise for about an hour or until each loaf has filled in the pan about halfway; you can also let them rise for about 40 minutes and then put them in the fridge to bake the next day. In that case, take them out of the fridge and let them come up to room temperature for about 30 minutes while the oven preheats.
Bake at 375° for about 40 minutes, until the tops are golden and a thermometer reads 200°.
Let them cool for at least an hour! To freeze, let them cool for at least 6 hours before putting them in plastic bags.
Again, here’s how much I started with for the levain:
I detest the idea of using plastic wrap to cover my dough and never do it. And I don’t understand using a dry towel.
Instead, I use old, very clean kitchen towels and old, very clean cloth napkins in the case of individual loaveSourdough Sandwich Bread Like Mothers and wring them out with hot water — the dough does not stick:
It is helpful to slash the tops of the loaves, but a bit easier to do if they’ve rested in the fridge:
Before or after you’ve mixed the levain, feed your starter.
This is how much I end up with in my jar, after removing what I need for the dough I’m making:
Just add the same volume of water and enough flour to make a stiff dough.
Can you see how thick it is?
When it’s risen like this, stick it back in the fridge unless you’re making more dough at the moment!
On, at last, to our links!
bits & pieces
- I will add these two book lists to my LMLD Library Project (I usually hesitate to add lists as most compilers feel obligated to include edgy books of no or worse than no consequence): The Regina Coeli one and Good books for Catholic Kids.
- Lots of marijuana bills on ballots around the country. It should be obvious that we don’t want our parks and sidewalks (and roads!) filled with people who are high, and that it’s not good for people to use this drug.
- Let’s just sigh over Cotswold houses.
from the archives
- Keeping your child warm this winter
- Keeping your house warm this winter
- You’re doing your dishes wrong (and doing them right is a good opportunity for conversation with your child)
- A Royal, Holy Marriage
- Mob rule
liturgical living
follow us everywhere!
Here is all the info:
Visit me at The School for Housewives and recommend it to your young friends!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them has moved over to Substack! — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing! The old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts. It will take me a while to get things organized, but you’ll be patient, I know!
There you will find the weekly podcast done by Phil and me, called On the Home Front. Do let us know what you think!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
My podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) — be sure to check out the other offerings there!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen:
Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest
Here is my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit!
















“… those with a third-grade education had more literacy than we,”
My heart (and mind) leapt for joy when I read that phrase! Do you realize how refreshing- and rare- is subject agreement with comparisons? For those scratching their heads, the ubiquitous usage would be, “had more literacy than us.”
Phew, dodged one there!
😉
I think this is good advice for teaching writing. Many people who hate writing hate it because they don’t know the basics of constructing and sentence, then a paragraph, then an essay — so it feels like something they ought to be able to do but somehow can’t do easily or well (in other words, it feels like a personal failure). Some kids will zoom ahead, taking to writing like a duck to water, but for those who don’t (and even those who do), they need to be given the tools they need rather than simply expected to write!
Yes, but I want to say here that the goals I am mentioning are for those zooming ahead too. In fact, I learned about setting these goals from the curriculum used by the Trinity School (where three of our daughters have taught — at the Meadow View school).
The children who go to that school are pretty well on track to excel. The standards are high and the student body is impressive.
I had the opportunity to read through the book given to teachers at the time Rosie taught there (it’s about 400 pages long!) and was astonished to see that these simple goals I mention were the ones listed at those exact stages.
I thought, hmmm… this is how an admirable college prep school handles things… perhaps it really works!
The interesting thing is that Warriner’s, the grammar and usage text I prefer, tracks along with this approach as well.
The wonderful thing about homeschooling is the ability to tailor the curriculum to the child. If one’s fifth grader has a good grasp of, say, sentence structure and proper usage, then one can go ahead to the next goal, the one that suits his abilities.
Even an intuitive writer needs the discipline of attending to the particulars, as you point out.
Yes, absolutely. Even those who are “naturals” benefit from developing discipline through learning the structures. It’s foundational. Otherwise you will find that the natural talent does not become refined into skill, and the wild, frenetic gallop never comes under control.
I’ve never heard of Warriner’s. We’ve used Primary Language Lessons and Secondary Language Lessons, and then year 4 of Voyages of English. My oldest is an advanced 5th grader who has been writing stories, letters, poems, etc for years– is the first year of Warriner’s appropriate for her? I haven’t really been that happy with the texts we have used, they are all a weird combination of writing activities and grammar activities, in my opinion. Truth be told, everyone’s writing is great for their level so I haven’t spent a lot of time researching alternates, but I would like something that is JUST grammar. My oldest does plenty of short, written narration of her school reading (in addition to all her fun writing), my second is not as prolific but is still competent in her 1-2 written narrations a day, my third is only in first grade so only does informal writing but is quite prolific, and my fourth, though a partially literate five-year-old boy, is following in her example… All that is to say, would Warriner’s sixth grade fit the bill for my oldest? Thanks.
Also I am finally back to bread baking after years of hiatus and I am so happy! I’ve made the King Arthur sandwich bread quite a few times and look forward to the crusty bread! Having two kids old enough to help is such a game-changer. The cost increase of the local bakery bread was a game-changer too, in the other direction.
I have a strong memory of writing about Voyages and Warriner’s… but now I can’t find it.
Let me just say that teaching grammar before fifth grade is rather futile. Yes, some children can sort of get it, but I think the effort is taking the joy out of things and taking the place of other things they could be studying.
A fourth grader is at the ideal stage to learn to spell, for instance. Sure, they can play Mad Libs and so on but there are so many things to learn and I think studying parts of speech and so on intensively is a waste of time.
In fifth and sixth grade, they can start learning the mechanics of grammar and it’s a good time to diagram sentences. They can memorize parts of speech.
I find Voyages tedious. I don’t like the clip-art aesthetic. I have used it and my heart sort of dies a little dragging a 4th or 5th grader through it.
I think we should be careful not to make school a grind.
Warriner’s comes in different levels, from 6th grade, I think, all through high school. It’s a little tricky to figure out which book is for which level without it being in your hands, and I don’t think they are in print, so you have to find them in used book shops.
You could start in 6th grade.
It’s very straightforward. It’s a dry textbook but in a more honest way, I don’t know how to explain it… you feel like you are getting somewhere with it! As a student, I had the sense that doing Warriner’s while doing algebra just patterned my brain to be very systematic (some may disagree LOL).
I love that your 5th grader is writing stories and so on. Perfect! Just don’t worry — grammar particulars can be taught in one year, preferably in middle or high school when they are ready, developmentally.
I wrote about it here: https://likemotherlikedaughter.org/2020/06/bits-pieces-198/
Thank you for the reply! I ordered Warriner’s for 6th grade. I may start it in January with my 5th grader. I had planned to do one year of elementary grammar, one year of middle school grammar, and one year of high school grammar, but I haven’t been very happy with any elementary grammar options. My second child, “third grade,” is an almost perfect speller and confidently answered the grammar question at the end of the new Latin through stories (from University of Dallas) year 2, differentiating easily between the subject and direct object… so I was hoping to combine her and my oldest in the elementary grammar, at least learning basic parts of speech.
I certainly felt like grammar was introduced waaay to slowly when I went to Catholic school and then just all but dropped in public school. But my parents are both writers in some form so I did fine.
I definitely feel the tension between making learning a delight (at least most of the time!) and keeping things disciplined. My husband’s biggest hesitation about homeschoolers is that they can do all these brilliant things– but only when and if they want to do them!
I also re-read most of your writing posts. It’s been a few years since I read them. Thanks.
Really looking forward to the “crusty bread” tutorial! I’m having a lot of success with sandwich bread but I need some help with hearth breads. Right now I’m making the King Arthur Vermont Sourdough and it’s really good but denser than I’d like.
how do you like Latin through Stories?? I have a kinder that I want to introduce latin to and have been looking at that curriculum.
As always, spot on with the writing/homeschooling advice! I’ve been following your sourdough posts with interest too, because despite being a veteran bread maker I feel I can always learn MORE. One perhaps helpful suggestion that I did want to offer (having discovered it myself) is instead of using tea towels to cover rising dough, use beeswax cloth. Like you, I don’t use paper towels (except for the rare very icky situation), and I find that I am perpetually inundated with damp kitchen towels. I have a rack for letting them dry that hangs over our washer, but I still try to eliminate any unecessaries in the system! I made my own beeswax wraps with a DIY kit that was reasonably easy and inexpensive (they are a bit pricey if you buy them and making your own lets you customize the size). I made one that I use to cover my rising dough and several smaller ones that I use in lieue of plastic wrap in the fridge!
Thank you for the advice about writing expectations for children. I plan to refer back to the guidelines for my 1st grader as he grows.
I have a question I never thought I would need to ask anyone about marijuana. What do you think about medical marijuana? Completely unexpectedly, our doctor recommended it for pain for a dear older relative of mine who suffers constantly and is afraid to take strong medicines like hydrocodone. The doctor said it would not make her high, but the home health nurse said she has never had a patient who didn’t get high from it. I just wonder about not only the efficacy and safety of it, but also is it morally right?
Just weighing in. We use CBD cream for muscle aches (My husband has a very physical job.) It is derived from Marijuana but without what would get you high, at least that’s my understanding. Also since it’s a cream it is used on the skin in the place it’s needed. Maybe that would work?
I don’t know that “getting high” is in itself immoral. Certainly, morphine has that effect. But it’s a reason for prudence, right? I remember taking codeine for a migraine (prescribed the the doctor) and feeling like it was making me high but not taking away the pain. So I didn’t take it again.
My bigger concern is the lack of transparency in studies of medical marijuana. If I find the article that exposed it, I will share.
Auntie Leila! I’ve been a LMLD blog follower for a number of years now. Thank you for putting so much energy, heart and soul into this wonderful resource! I’ve gained so much over the years from this space of yours! I recently have been listening to your new podcast via your sub stack page. Thank you for this, too! The podcast has prompted me to consider some things I hadn’t before. I have been wondering over the past weeks if you (and/or your husband) have read anything by Heather Cox Richardson? Or if you have read her Facebook posts/ Letters to an American? I am sincerely interested in your take on her and her writing!
I was curious based off of your review of this Richardson–never heard of her. I’m still not sure who she is, but her writing is sensationalistic (in the most yawning sense) and inflammatory; I was immediately put off by her takes on interviews that I had listened to and she replayed with sinister tones that didn’t exist.
The ones who talk most of gaslighting often seem to have mastered the fine art of it!
Jennifer, I don’t know anything about her, but the Lincoln Republicans are basically wholly committed to gender ideology and abortion. They will do and say anything to further those goals.
Here’s a tweet from the Lincoln Project — truly ironic, terrible, ghastly, and disgusting:
https://x.com/projectlincoln/status/1850507743326876105
“There is nothing a father won’t do to protect his daughter. This November, all you have to do is vote for Kamala Harris.” With a video showing a father and a baby and then a young girl — who needs an abortion, we’re meant to conclude. So fathers need to make sure their daughters can abort their babies — those fathers’ grandchildren??
Anyone associated with this group has a lot to answer for.
Yes. Thank you so much for your response; I hadn’t seen this ad nor had I known anything about the Lincoln Project or Lincoln Republicans. After viewing this advertisement, my takeaway was not that a father ought to support his daughter’s choice to get an abortion, but that a father ought to support her right to choose what she does with her own body, which is something I hope all fathers would indeed support. That’s the issue as I see it, anyway. A father who loves the Lord would certainly be talking with his daughter about chastity, first and foremost, and the sacred nature of her being! At any rate, I am thankful for your response, for this space of discussion and learning. May God bless our country, and have mercy on us all in these tumultuous times!
“a father ought to support her right to choose what she does with her own body” you say, but anyone with kids know that kids will do the darnedest things with their bodies.
Would you support a daughter’s choice to harm herself, or harm an innocent person, or steal a car, or shoot up heroin, or punch her little brother, etc.?
To borrow from an oft-used line about the civil war: “support her right to choose?” well, her right to choose WHAT?
I agree of course — I didn’t say I support her right to choose!
And of course, the father in the video is saying he’d do anything to protect his daughter… but apparently, not if his daughter is in the womb 😣
Hi Edward, thank you for adding this to the conversation. I agree with you: no, I would not support my daughter’s choice to harm herself or another person. Most definitely not. Though, if she is an adult with a fully-formed conscience, this decision is hers to make, and ultimately, she alone will have to bear the most unthinkable wound (in the case of abortion) of having killed another human being. This is primarily between her and God, yes? No different than any other form of murder. Are other people harmed in the process? My belief is, 100% yes. Everyone surrounded by this heinous act is harmed, including what I would call “innocent bystanders.” Which I guess leads me to think we are all innocent bystanders if we aren’t the ones out on the ground, day in and day out, speaking out against how abortion/the actions of one person harms every person in our society. I think I am answering my own dilemma here.
Thank you for the writing advice! You make it sound doable and straightforward. Do you have any suggestions for things to write about? Did you have a textbook that gave suggestions for sentences or paragraphs or does each child write about something that interests them? I have one child who most likely would not have any ideas of what to write about and I think I would have trouble coming up with ideas.
Thank you!
Please do peruse my posts! Here are some: https://likemotherlikedaughter.org/category/teaching-children-to-write/
I have so many suggestions…
In my book, The Summa Domestica, all the posts, and more, are organized for you!
Here is the main post where I talk about ideas for copying and writing things out: https://likemotherlikedaughter.org/2012/12/the-mechanics-of-writing-advent-style/
You can apply the organizing principle to any season you find yourself in.
And a good old-fashioned primer will have many entries with interesting prose and poetry for copy work. Just make sure it IS interesting and even beautiful.
Thank you! I had forgotten about the writing blogs you wrote several years ago. Very helpful!
I love your Holy Family relief outside! Could you please recommend a good place to buy sacred art for the outdoors? I was very inspired by a podcast of yours from a bit ago about saving the neighborhood through beauty, but other than statuary, I have been unable to find outdoor art!
Thank you!
Racehl
Thank you — that one is something from my parents-in-law’s house, and it is ceramic that had a glaze making it look like it was wooden. So I did a hacky job painting it…
This post has some thoughts in the comments: https://likemotherlikedaughter.org/2021/06/beauty-will-save-the-neighborhood/
It’s hard to find things!
Thanks, Auntie Leila for talking about my favorite subject! 🙂 Just wanted to share the name of a very good Catholic creative writing organization that has great programs and classes for kids. They even have a curriculum for creative writing that they just released. They are called Catholic Literary Arts, and I love them. I am a young adult who graduated from a homeschool classical education. Creative writing is my passion because of my mother’s dedication, God’s grace, and Catholic Literary Arts. Not to mention the greats of literature! Honestly, it would be super hard to be a good writer without proper knowledge of good literature.
Oh yes, this is the foundation of everything I say about curriculum! Read read read — and it has to be good, old literature.
I don’t know that organization; I think there are good ones and I’m sure that one is. I just say, be sure to set the goals and don’t move on until they are reached, generally speaking. It’s easy to get fancy! It’s harder to keep the real goals, simple as they are, in mind.
I’m in my 14th year of homeschooling and your writing advice is almost to a T what I have figured out works the best to teach writing in a non-stressful way. I have confidence in this method because I now have a college freshman who has written a few short papers already during his first semester and has gotten good grades on them. No writing assignments before middle school, besides basic story summaries of books. Elementary students read whole books, do penmanship, write answers in workbooks, and study grammar, but they don’t write any compositions. Seventh graders work on good sentences – and read whole books. Eight graders work on complete paragraphs – and read whole books. Ninth graders do five paragraph essays…whole books. Tenth through twelfth graders write various expository, persuasive, and research papers (Lantern English is amazing for providing instruction and grading for upper-level high school papers, though a bit rigorous at times. I highly recommend them. They have 8 week writing classes, they communicate purely through email – no app! – and they are pretty affordable). I had many moments of doubt, as I do use a big box homeschool company for many subjects, but I saw early on that young writers were frustrated, so I always skipped composition until they were much older. This is the way.
Ah, thank you for sharing your experience! Wonderful!
This is very enouraging advice re: writing. I find the many programs and writing curricula so overwhelming and overwrought. Like your advice on sourdough, it’s better not to overcomplicate this! 🙂 I’ve been really pleased with the approach in the Charlotte Mason education we use. It’s not one of those things where you’ll “see results” quickly (something our culture, particularly in education, with all its benchmarks, testing, measuring, grinding, etc, seems to value highly), as it takes years to get the students from orally narrating/re-telling all their school readings, to written narrations (usually these would begin with one written narration per day in 4th grade, ramping up to two written narrations in 5th, and going up–slowly and steadily– from there). There is a natural, slow, incremental process in orally narrating for the child to listen to a reading quite attentively, recall, organize their thoughts, then retell. This process really does help prepare them for the later act of writing out these narrations, and paired with studied dictation to improve spelling/usage/mechanics, their writing does mature with them at developmentally appropriate pace. Later in high school, studies in composition are in the students’ timetable, and of course, all this is built on the backbone of absolutely wonderful literature and books across the disciplines. When I compare this approach with what I was tasked to do as a 6th grade teacher back in the day… wow. No wonder the students all saw “writing” as tantamount to torture!
On the sourdough recipe– a silly question, maybe, but is step one (making the levain) actually also the step of feeding the starter out of the fridge?? Or does it need to already be fed and active beforehand? I wasn’t quite sure! 😀
Love CM! And have written all about the things you mention — there are so many wonderful, inspiring ways to get to the goal.
I just want to emphasize the importance of setting a goal and making it one that absolutely must be met or the next goal will not be achievable!
As to sourdough — yes, the levain making and starter feeding are the same and happen at the same time, though the levain has a higher hydration (in my method, because I prefer a stiffer starter) and I do it separately anyway so I don’t mistakenly use up everything in the jar in my dough!
It has happened… yikes.
In other words, your levain uses starter right out of the fridge. And you feed your starter at that point.
If you were to feed your starter, and then make the levain, you’d have basically fed it twice. Which some people do. But in my opinion, a good healthy starter from the fridge is ready to go.
In fact, in a pinch, you could use the starter out of the fridge to make the dough, without the intermediate step of building the levain. However, with the smaller amount I’m storing, it would take a while to leaven the whole mass (because you need some in your jar to feed for another time!).
The less volume of starter/levain you use, the longer the first bulk rise will take. We make the levain to have more volume, as well as to be sure it’s strong.
Yes!! Ok! That definitely helps me wrap my head around it. I’m a big fan of your method of the “separate feedings” done together— both to not accidentally use up all the starter (which I have done several times too!!) and to have no waste. So simple.
I’ve moved into experimenting with making a quadruple batch of regular sourdough and baking one as a boule and 3 in loaf pans for easier slicing. It’s coming out so well, I almost can’t believe it!! Leaving the bulk rise overnight or at least 10 hours makes the dough rise beautifully and it’s the most stretchy, pillowy dough. Easy and pleasant to work with!
That’s the way!! Brava!
Leila, I finally got my starter going and have made discard pancakes a couple of times! I’m trying to make sure I have all my ducks in a row to try the sandwich recipe. I have been reading all your posts, and I read somewhere that you can substitute oil for butter… I don’t see any oil or butter in your tweaked recipe. Should it be there, or was that just for the KA recipe? Thank you!!
Oh man, you are right. In my recipe, I just went with the milk. You can add fat to the recipe with no problem! From 2 T to 1/4 cup, it will just make the crumb softer. If you went with more — like 1/2 cup — and more milk, it would be more like brioche. I will edit the recipe… sigh… I’m truly hopeless. But maybe this is how I will eventually get recipes that actually make sense!
Good work getting your starter going! I look forward to an update!