Ask Auntie Leila Corner
Dear Auntie Leila,
I’m curious/mad/disappointed that you use the King James Version in your book, The Summa Domestica. Why would you, when there is the Douay-Rheims?
Respectfully [but Nonetheless Irked],
Many Readers
Dear Readers!
We are the lucky, blessed, and favored heirs of the richest language and most profound treasury of literature, poetry, and song of any culture.
The source of this textured, subtle, and brilliant expression of man’s creativity comes for the most part (not completely of course, but in broad terms) from two springs: Shakespeare and the King James Version of the Bible. For centuries, many of our greatest writers and poets only had these two works at hand, or learned on them before encountering others, which in turn took nourishment from them.
This is a historical fact. If you want your children to have a chance at the eloquence of Abraham Lincoln, consider making them read Shakespeare and the KJV by firelight only. Living in a log cabin and having no shoes might also help!
But seriously, we are trying to educate our children, which means to pass along to them, in as intact form as we can manage, our faith and culture and this particular aspect of our culture, its poetic beauty. It’s ours. We actually have a duty to it, as well as to our children and making them able to apprehend it.
In my books, contrary to what my critics assert, I generally reference and use three translations: the Douay-Rheims (which is often identical to the King James Version, in which case that’s the one I mention), the King James Version, and the Revised Standard Version.
We need to understand that no translation achieves perfection. Some are better for studying, and that is why we would turn to the RSV. Some are better for prayer, e.g. the Douay-Rheims or RSV or perhaps Knox (with whom I have quibbles), and I would argue, the King James Version, for sheer beauty and forming a deep connection to our heritage on a visceral level. By the way, did you know there is a Catholic King James Version (affiliate link)? Because the main objection to it is just that it leaves out canonical books, which this edition restores. I address the other objection below.
But let me put it this way:
Surely we all know the beginning of Psalm 23 as “the Lord is my Shepherd, I shall not want” (KJV) and not “A psalm for David. The Lord ruleth me: and I shall want nothing.” (D-R).
We want our children to know it the first way too, I would think! And meet it with recognition and warm joy in hymn and poem.
The reasons might be subtle, but they are real.
First, the rhythm of the KJV fits its meaning. It is childlike and simple, easily memorized or rather, just slipping into the memory. Its poetry will cause it to come back easily when the soul needs it.
Second, the lack of a direct object in the second clause offers a deep meaning. “I shall want nothing” is a bit too negative — the word “nothing” isn’t helpful in this context — and although the meaning is that nothing will be lacking, that idea is conveyed better by simply leaving out the predicate. “I shall not want” emphasizes the existential fulfillment of the person, the child, the “I”, the subject, the sheep. I will not be in a state of having any needs, because I will be perfectly taken care of by the good Shepherd.
And of course, the image of Shepherd, so central to this Psalm, is left out of the D-R verse entirely.
So in my book, when I talk about, say, building writing skills by doing copy work from the Bible, I suggest usually using the KJV or at least weighing the different translations before choosing one. Personally, I usually find the KJV more satisfying.
And I often use a KJV quote in my writing precisely as a sort of object lesson or ready demonstration of how powerful it is in conjuring up all sorts of connections in your, the reader’s, own mind, in the hopes that you will wish to pass that intellectual (at a minimum) superpower on to your child.
Copying out, say, the KJV Psalm 23 imprints it on the child’s mind. He internalizes its meter and will recognize it, if only subliminally, in future readings of other works. He himself will become more familiar with expressing things this way. Those of us who are sure to pass along these venerable passages can attest to our children coming up with charming and funny expressions, like my four-year-old son’s “Oh, I am as tired as a gazelle falling down!”
Fr. Paul Mankowski, translator extraordinaire, expert in Semitic languages, and priest of sterling orthodoxy, referenced the KJV and other old translations easily, without self-consciousness let alone compunction, as all educated Catholics do. He once commented in an email to me,
Another issue, that also hinges on lexical distribution of reference distinctions, has to do with the Deus/homo antithesis, especially where it’s implicit. In the KJV, Isaiah 53:3 reads (cue the Händel): “He was despised, and rejected of men.” In our Lectionary that became, “He was spurned and avoided by persons.” Try Händeling that. The point is that a word can’t drop out of a language unless another word pushes it out by doing the same job better, and obviously no word can do the job of English “men,” no matter how many professorial fingers are wagged at us.
He’s making a point about inclusive language, but notice the embedded point that we would lose a major master-work of our patrimony, Handel’s Messiah, and our deep resonance with it, if we did not preserve its wording, or if we used a different translation in our literature and music classes.
If we insisted on “Despised, and the most abject of men, a man of sorrows, and acquainted with infirmity” (Douay-Rheims) we lose the punch of that un-Latinized word grief in the KJV: “He is despised and rejected of men; a man of sorrows, and acquainted with grief.” (Getting back to why the NAB is so bad, not really the subject here, the biblical connection of the movie and soundtrack of O Brother Where Art Thou would be lost on us entirely if we existed on a diet of technical scriptures. We might think it’s only a retelling of The Odyssey and wonder why “I Am a Man of Constant Sorrow” is a featured song.)
It’s very difficult to teach later on what should have become second-nature from the start. The child who hears the KJV from infancy in at least some contexts is far better positioned than the one who has to assimilate it later for the purpose, perhaps, of appreciating some work of art that depends on it.
If we, in some doctrinaire fashion, ban what we perceive as the “Protestant” essence of the KJV, and then later, when our mature children are reading some great work, try to explain the genesis of its allusions, diction, and especially cadences, we will find it hard going and I can tell you from experience, often unavailing. The explanations might fall on the barren ground of basic disconnect.
It works the other way too. If the child doesn’t know these favored passages (favored for good reason!) by heart in his own mother tongue, he won’t recognize them in worship. I’ve been struck so often how the current lectionary in the Novus Ordo effects the separation from the past quite efficiently, if tragically:
Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen~ KJV: Pithy, straight to the point in a matter not easily explained, namely, what is faith.
Now faith is the substance of things to be hoped for, the evidence of things that appear not ~ D-R: Good, not as pithy, and “things that appear not” is a tad ambiguous.
Faith is the realization of what is hoped for and evidence of things not seen ~ NABRE (the edition used at Mass in the US): More words, the most important of which is not a clear improvement (realization for substance).
Can a child take this to heart is my question. Will it come back to him in moments of trouble? Less crucially, but still importantly, will he catch the reference in the title of some novel?
If attending the Traditional Latin Mass, the faithful will hear the readings in Latin and then a translation may be offered. For the child to learn his Bible, extra effort needs to be made to offer good translations in our everyday speaking and reading that offer more than just information.
Fr. Mankowski writes, “Further, a biblical text is not so much read as heard, and not so much heard as re-heard, often hundreds of times in a single lifetime.” He is opposing Ronald Knox’s theory of translation as applied to Scripture. Traditional Catholics should read his argument in this article; the Campion Missal, for one, uses the Knox translation for Low Masses.
Tony Esolen skewers the issue of clunky translations (not that I’m saying the D-R is that) in his article What We’ve Lost in Translation:*
One of the thieves crucified at the side of Christ is mocking him, and the other thief feels a pang of conscience. “We are receiving the due reward of our deeds,” he says, “but this man has done nothing wrong” (RSV); “And we indeed justly, for we are receiving what our deeds deserved; but this man has done nothing wrong” (Douay-Rheims-Challoner). I suppose that if you are hanging on a cross, you will come straight to the point. Now the NAB: “And indeed, we have been condemned justly, for the sentence we received corresponds to our crimes, but this man has done nothing criminal.” Corresponds? Nothing criminal? Who talks this way? A lawyer arguing before an appellate court, maybe. A professor, probably. A thief on a cross? The translators cannot have considered the drama of the specific situation.
The KJV has “And we indeed justly; for we receive the due reward of our deeds: but this man hath done nothing amiss.” Even more direct, more dying-on-a-cross-like.
For the issue of translating from the Latin Vulgate and how decisive that is for the question of eliminating the KJV, I recommend this article by Jimmy Akin: Uncomfortable Facts about the Douay-Rheims. I appreciate that he points out Douay-Onlyism as a counterpart to KJV-Onlyism!
While translator bias is a fact to be contended with, Douay-Rheims Onlyists often accuse contemporary translations of being tainted by Protestant translations.
But there’s another side to that story. Just as the original Douay came to influence the KJV, the KJV itself came to influence the Douay. Ward notes: “In nearly every case Challoner’s changes took the form of approximating to the Authorized [i.e., King James] Version.”
The fact is that Bible versions on both sides of the confessional divide influence each other. This is because serious translators don’t read only works done by one side. Sometimes the other guys come up with a way of better capturing what’s written in the original language, and when that happens the serious translator wants to know about it, not to hide his head in the sand.
All of this is not to say that the Douay-Rheims is a bad translation, or that it is not to be read, or that individuals may not prefer using it to other translations. It is only to indicate that the Douay-Rheims ought not be put on a pedestal.
The truth is, I found after my conversion that unbeknownst to me, many Bible verses and patterns of diction were embedded in my mind and heart because they had been transmitted in the culture — in books I had read, poetry I had heard, and hymns I had sung (because my mother, as a former Methodist, sang them, or because they were Christmas carols we also learned at school) — all in the KJV. My experience has convinced me that we are charged to transmit such things to our children, that they not be cut off from the land — the land of knowledge and collective memory.
bits & pieces
- A podcast episode about the Library of Congress from Katie Marquette
- A Light for Our Times: Blessed Karl Conference in Washington, DC — Phil will be speaking at this conference, our good friend Paul Jernberg has composed the Mass, and I’ll be there too! Be sure to register!
- In the spirit of things you need to know before you can know other things, I loved this reading list for gearing up for the Lord of the Rings. It’s a list of wonderful childhood books and stories for children to read before they get to LOTR, very much in the Library Project mode. You know it bothers me that people just jump right into introducing their children to mature things they themselves love. Yes, you love Star Wars, but is it appropriate for a 6-year-old? You love Jane Austen, but should your 10-year-old be reading it? There are just things you need to read and know about before you can get the many levels of the other things, before you can get the most out of them! I have the Lindgren book on hold at the library!
- Knitters! Does the long-tail cast-on give you PTSD? Me too. Here’s a LTCO calculator!!
from the archives
- I wrote a little about translations in general here.
- I feel the burden of educating my children — how setting goals helps lift the burden (we talked about that this year here and here).
liturgical living
St. Wenceslaus and St. Lawrence Ruiz and his companions
Tomorrow is Michaelmas — tonight or tomorrow night would be good for a bonfire and/or procession!
follow us everywhere!
Here is my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the blog loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! It opens up an Amazon tab and anything you purchase using that tab for 24 hours sends a bit over my way without cost to you. Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them has moved over to Substack! — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing! The old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts. It will take me a while to get things organized, but you’ll be patient, I know!
There you will find the weekly podcast done by Phil and me, called On the Home Front. Do let us know what you think!
Visit me at The School for Housewives and recommend it to your young friends!
My podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) — be sure to check out the other offerings there!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen:
Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest




I couldn’t agree more. As you point out, our spoken language is full of allusions form Shakespeare and the Bible. What a loss to enriched conversation when we mess around with the Scriptures. A tiny example. Many years ago, I was standing at the back during Mass, probably with a fractious toddler. I could see my eldest son, around six years old, sitting by his father close to the front. During the Gospel, the words, “and I will make you fishers of people”, were proclaimed. My son’s head swivelled abruptly round to his father and he whispered to him. He had said, “I thought it was fishers of men.”
Yes! And your little boy understood what Fr. Mankowski was saying — you can’t substitute for the word “man”!
I come at this from a Protestant tradition – I’ve had to explain to my kids that some verses come out very mangled when I try to recite them because many I learned in KJV and then NIV and then NASB and then ESV.
As you said: Handel, and Shakespeare, and much classic literature uses KJV. I already see lots of people who don’t understand when the Bible is being quoted because they’re not familiar with it; I want my children to identify Biblical allusion easily because they’ve been so often exposed to it.
I find that the new translations just wash over — they don’t stick. They are so wordy, yet the words don’t have any pungency.
I hadn’t thought about this, Leila. As you said, the culture has put some of these phrases in our minds and when we hear them differently, it’s missing something. I especially feel it in: weeping may endure for a night, but joy cometh in the morning. It could not possibly be said better than that.
Good reference! I always think of Anne Shirley when I hear that. The Anne books are full to the brim with KJV references that I missed, until I read more KJV.
Yes! I was thinking of LMM as i read this. Scripture was a second language to her. It works in so easily in what she writes. Actually alot of what i know is from her books.
I heard a talk once about choosing a Bible translation for your children as they get older. At the time I didn’t have older kids so I’m afraid I didn’t pay good attention. But the speaker made the point that some translations actually are bad theology. And now I really wish I could remember which translation she recommended. I think Auntie Leila’s point is reallyWell made that we need a couple of translations for different things.
Any NAB or NAB-adjacent version is not good and yes, has bad theology and even sometimes omits references to the devil!
See the embedded articles and my post that I’ve linked.
Teens should have the RSVCE for study (the old St. Joseph Confraternity bible is good too, good notes, but the Ignatius Bible has awesome study notes) and the family should have the D-R and the KJV
Exactly!
Do you remember the part in Anne of Ingleside when she’s being twitted about having so many children and not writing as much as she used to?
“ “And you’ve quite given it up?”
“Not altogether . . . but I’m writing living epistles now,” said Anne, thinking of Jem and Co.
Christine stared, not recognizing the quotation. What did Anne Shirley mean? But then, of course, she had been noted at Redmond for her mysterious speeches. She had kept her looks astonishingly but probably she was one of those women who got married and stopped thinking.”
2 Ye are our epistle written in our hearts, known and read of all men:
3 Forasmuch as ye are manifestly declared to be the epistle of Christ ministered by us, written not with ink, but with the Spirit of the living God; not in tables of stone, but in fleshy tables of the heart. 2 Corinthians 3:2-4 KJV
Got married and stopped thinking! Ha! LMM made Anne brilliant.
I’m sure I’d catch other references if I knew the catechism she used better, but I don’t know that one. I do love Davy’s howler in Anne of Avonlea about how we’ll have plenty of jam in heaven. God makes preserves and redeems us! Davy says, “Preserves is just an holy way of saying jam.” Anne had to talk to him about the importance of a certain comma.
Wonderful references!
I think it was A Tree Grows in Brooklyn where the mother reads to her child(ren?) 1 page of Shakespeare and 1 page of the KJV every night of their lives, and by the time they are still pretty young children they had already read through the entire works of Shakespeare and the whole Bible more than once. Read that in high school and it always stuck with me…
That vignette has always stuck with me!
A friend on Twitter posted the quote — it’s a screenshot — you can see it here: https://x.com/muchtoocommon/status/1840084399557370008
I was coming to the comments to make this exact literary reference!
I love a good Leila rant where I am all in agreement! 🙂 I was talking about this very point recently that the KJV is so important for your children to know.
Your little aside about introducing your children to mature books too young is so important! I wish you’d elaborate, I think that people miss this. our sense of appropriate timing for kids is all askew in our culture.
Lastly, Knox, quibbles? I’ve only ever heard positive reviews I’d love to know what I should watch out for. I haven’t read him yet but have a couple of his books in my queue.
Well, I did do the podcast about it — it’s linked there.
And the link to the First Things article by Fr. M has his elaboration about Knox — I know you will be interested in it.
Recently, some (traditionalist) people on FB were quoting the Knox translation and I was really not a fan. I wish I could remember what it was. Whatever it was, it was not an improvement…
So fun! The first time around someone in my house must have beaten me to your link and it wasn’t highlighted for me! I totally missed there was anything beyond the booklist!
I like the Knox. I have a hard time zoning out from being overly familiar with Bible passages sometimes. The Knox will kind of catch me off guard with its phrasing and diction, so I slow down a little and think about what’s written. I think it’s nice if you’re using in cross reference with the other classical versions, and his writings and books are generally really wonderful. So it’s nice to get a glimpse into the man’s own mind and workings in this other way. It’s a Bible you have to contextualize, like many others. You don’t want it to be your only reference, but it’s a good addition. That’s my two cents, anyways.
Thank you for the idea of reading the KJV to our children. I never thought of that, but it is important that they recognize it.
Yes and having them do the verses for copywork and memorization. As I say, sometimes the D-R is the same. Sometimes it’s just slightly different and usually not really better.
My husband wasn’t sure about reading the KJV with our 6-year-old, so I shared this blog post with him, and he agreed. He reads the Bible to our son every night. Tonight hearing Matthew read the KJV and discuss it with his dad really blessed my heart.
I think the KJV is best for memorization and recitation (not always, but usually). For Bible study, I think the RSV is best. But a six-year-old is not studying — just listening to the beautiful words!
Mio, My Son (on the reading list you link) is beautiful. I read it aloud to my 2 youngest daughters this summer. How have I not heard of it before now?
Highly recommend it!
Good to know! Looking forward to it!
The RSV(CE) is the main version in our household, but you are right that the verses that one memorizes always seem to come from the KJV language or something similar. I’ll admit that whenever I need to quote a verse in published writing I will search Bible Gateway until I find the version that is closest to what I have memorized. This is a very disorganized approach, I realize, but when the language is not beautiful and does not stick the verse just does not make the same impression.
I think many of us develop familiarity with verses not just from reading the Bible itself or from hearing it at Mass but from cultural references. The flattened, colloquial translations are unuseable this way (nobody in a novel is going to quote, “I may walk through valleys as dark as death, but I won’t be afraid. You are with me, and your shepherd’s rod makes me feel safe”).
Yes, and the current D-R does not actually have thee’s and thou’s, nor does the RSV. Sorry, but to understand our literature written before the current era, we need to have familiarity with that diction.
Thank you for linking all of these articles, I found them so interesting!
I appreciated Fr. Mankowski including that quote from Alter about the earthiness of the old English translations and the Hebrew. I started noticing this when we began praying morning prayer once a week in our community from the 1662 Book of Common Prayer which has the beautiful Coverdale Psalter in it. I’d grown up on the NIV (most of childhood) and then the ESV. I suddenly realized how concrete and earthy the language in the Psalms really was, and how the newer translations make it abstract so that it is more intellectual and less physical–so that it feels less down-to-earth. I do still struggle with some of the wordings in the KJV and find them awkward, (though somehow I was familiar enough with the language that when I see a quotation I do recognize it) but I want my children to have this rich language at their disposal!
Thank you, I had no idea there was a Catholic KJV. As a Protestant I LOVED the King James version, though I came to the faith later in life. My kids all learnt their bible verses in the KJV and I still know Psalm 23 in that version. I have to say that it just rolls off the tongue and has a special beauty to it that unfortunately the Douay Rheims just does not have in that passage and others besides. Now as a Catholic I still like the DR the best of the Catholic versions and I kind of wince every time they read out the “inclusive” modern version that is so simplistic it has all the beauty taken out of it at our Mass. I think I will bring back the KJV into homeschooling the younger children who are not familiar with it. Off to Amazon to get a copy now 😉
It’s sort of funny to read about Bible translations on the feast of St. Jerome 🙂
Auntie Leila, last night I was reading a bit of Winters in the World, the book by Eleanor Parker aka The Clerk of Oxford. She was talking about the Anglo-Saxon festival of Lammas on August 1, of which we know very little, but we do know it means something like “Festival of Bread”, likely celebrating the wheat harvest just completed. In Old English the name was “hlafmaesse”, where hlaf means bread and maesse is the Latin “missa”, but more in the sense of a holy season or feast day (as in Christmas, Candlemas, Michaelmas) than in the strict sense of the liturgy.
But the interesting bit is about hlaf, bread. Parker says the root of the word evolved to become simply “la”, and it’s the same root of two well-known words, lord and lady! She writes, “[…] these words ultimately derive from the Old English compounds hlafweard and hlaefdige, which originally meant something like “bread-guardian” and “bread-kneader”, suggesting those who protect and provide for a household.”
I thought you’d enjoy this 🙂
I love that! I do enjoy it! I’m a bread-guardian/bread-kneader enjoyer!
I once asked Fr. Mankowski if there is a linguistic reason you can’t say you have a husband if you’re a man or a wife if you’re a woman. He said no but he understood what I was getting at.
There is a complementarity and a connection to HOME and HEARTH that is embedded in the words!!
Would be interested in why you don’t like knox version. He is very popular for his metaphorical language among my set.
Oh man though, you sparked a feeling, Yes don’t show your 6 year old star wars. My kid’s best friend is getting this. Last year it was starwars (and they even watched the prequels, the horror). Now they are moving on to lotr. My kid keeps asking to read it. Sorry buddy you have to be older. Really enjoyed the Tolkien list, though I so think that all of the tales from the perilous realm are worth reading.
Oops that is what i get for posting before reading the comments. I see you talked about the knox thing. Carry on
Haha — I am not rejecting Knox! I just don’t think it’s a translation that replaces others. Certainly not KJV!! See the Mankowski article for his main critique. It’s very interesting.
Agree! We use the wonderfully done BBC radio dramas of The Hobbit, and later, LOTR as a first introduction. I think they were made in the 80s but are still available to purchase on Audible. Ian Holm, at the beginning of his career, reads Bilbo!
As an English teacher, 15 years at high school, now working in a middle school, this is music to my ears! If children understand the beauty and patterns of language, so much else will fall into place for them. Obviously they need to learn the rules of how to join compound and complex sentences, commas, clauses, and all the rest. However, it comes so much more easily, and is almost second nature, when they’ve read and had steeped in their hearts beautiful things.
Case in point: a group of seventh graders at my school who are particularly “pop-cultured” yesterday failed completely to add similes to sentences. They simply haven’t been exposed to works of art that use this type of imagery. Likewise, some of my eighth graders find Ursula LeGuin’s writing style “Shakespearean”. Which, of course, it is not, but she uses great vocabulary and complex sentence structures, so there you go!
You are correct when you assert that if children aren’t steeped in beautiful language early on, it is VERY hard to teach later.
Auntie Leila,
Your blog, alongside the Summa Domestica, has been my go-to resource for so many things in this first year of my marriage and now in the first few months of my pregnancy. Reading your posts truly feels like I’m sitting at the kitchen table with an auntie, which is especially beautiful because I live across the world from my family. I am so grateful my pastor’s wife recommended Summa Domestica to me back when I was about to get engaged, experiencing their beautiful Christian home and family and wondering where I might start learning how to cultivate our own home culture.
Anyway, I just want to leave a comment on this post to say that, as a Protestant (although I consider myself simply a Christian who believes the Bible is the authority and who seeks to lovingly obey Jesus in all things) reader, I really appreciate that you use the KJV rather than the Catholic translation because it makes your posts more accessible to our wider Christian family (me included!).
Thank you for all you do and the impact you’ve already made on me and my new (and newly growing) family!
You’re so welcome!
I just want to go on the record — again — as using the KJV AS WELL AS other Catholic versions — the Douay-Rheims and the RSVCE (Ignatius Bible) especially for study.
In my books I reference all three, depending on the context.
The Ignatius Bible has excellent study notes.
Brilliant and beautiful post! I whole heartedly agree Auntie Leila!
I just ordered, through your link, the KJV (both volumes) here to Canada for our HS year & can’t wait! We currently have used other translations for our memory work, but I am looking forward to making the switch. I didn’t know there was a Catholic version. This was delightful news indeed!
As a person who loves the poetry of language all I can say to your post is – BRAVO!
I hope many can heed the truth in your words always so eloquently written. You truly are my favourite.
Well done!
Thank you!
I had a friend just a few days ago ask for recommendations of “non-KJV” translations, and I just didn’t have the time to sit and try and explain why she might want to reconsider. I think I’ll pass along this article, thank you so much for it!
There are many thoughtful ideas presented both in this post and in the comments regarding scripture. This discussion calls to mind a lesson from the late Father John Hardon, where he explained that a quick and easy way for Catholics to determine the faithfulness of a scripture translation is to compare Luke 1:28. He went on to explain that those which use “Hail, full of Grace”, are more aligned with Catholic doctrine regarding Mary’s Immaculate Conception and generally tend to be more faithful throughout.
Luke 1:28
Douay-Rheims 1899 American Edition: 28 And the angel being come in, said unto her: Hail, full of grace, the Lord is with thee: blessed art thou among women.
Luke 1:28
Revised Standard Version Catholic Edition: 28 And he came to her and said, “Hail, full of grace, the Lord is with you!”
The Holy Bible – Knox Translation: 28 Into her presence the angel came, and said, Hail, thou who art full of grace; the Lord is with thee; blessed art thou among women.
Luke 1:28
King James Version: 28 And the angel came in unto her, and said, Hail, thou that art highly favored, the Lord is with thee: blessed art thou among women.
As a cradle Catholic I’ve witnessed the gradual and subtle alterations of language within the Church over 6+ decades, which makes me ever so grateful for wise counsel of souls like Fr. Hardon. While various translations of Scriptures have their merits and ought not be banned or completely discarded, it is certainly prudent and worthwhile to be aware how easily basic understanding of certain truths can be altered or eroded by seemingly minor translation differences.
A priest on EWTN once said in the 1990s, “All social engineering is preceded by verbal engineering.” Whether comparing prayers of the Mass or scripture translations it can be very enlightening how much basic knowledge of certain truths can so easily be manipulated or changed by the most simple and subtle changes.
I certainly have no desire to debate or disagree with anyone. Just sharing a few tidbits in the hope they might be as helpful to someone else as they have been for me.
Fr. Hardon had a lot of wisdom. His tip reminds me of something Fr. Fessio told me: You can look at Psalm 1 to know if it’s a good translation. If it doesn’t say “Blessed is the man” but rather “Blessed [or happy] is the one”, the Christological meaning of the verse has been taken away. (The KJV passes this test 🙂
It’s true — the KJV says “highly favored.” To the modern ear, this sounds like the withholding of a superlative. We would want to say MOST favored one. And of course, I don’t make the claim here that the KJV is the perfect translation (it’s not!) or the only one (I specifically say it’s not!). Only that it offers us a richness and connection to our very own culture without which we could not consider ourselves educated.
I don’t think a Catholic, who says “full of grace” at least 53 times a day, will be misled (nor do I think hearing “highly favored” tends to deprecate Our Lady — one thing you can say for Anglicans who keep their ancient language is that they have a devotion to her precisely as the Mother of God — sometimes more than Catholics!).
But I do think that same Catholic will lose something if he is not familiar with the KJV… something essential to his formation as an English speaker and heir to our glorious literary tradition.
There is a sublime Christmas carol that uses that text that I would not want my children to be deprived of, though it doesn’t say “full of grace”: The Angel Gabriel https://youtu.be/pliqObTHxUQ?si=alavJ3cK9IMqIAgA (the lyric is “most highly favored lady” – maybe to fit the meter? 🙂 )
You might be interested in this article about the word in Greek:https://www.scotthahn.com/blog/fullofgrace
“This phrase “full of grace” is actually one word (kecharitōmenē) that can also be translated as highly favored one. It’s a unique word that doesn’t appear again in Scripture, a word that reflects the uniqueness of Mary herself.”
Would I ever want to stop saying “full of grace”? Certainly not! Never! But for me, it’s not a deal-breaker when it comes to including the KJV on my bookshelf and citing it for certain well known and well loved verses, embedded in our collective memory.
This year I’m having my older students (7th and 4th grade) spend ten minutes a day copying the Gospels out of the KJV. Not sure where that brainwave came from but it seems relevant to the discussion. 🙂 We are pretty slow so we may switch over to the Psalms at Christmas. I don’t want to have to think too hard about what we cover, more just absorb here. I think we also have absorbed a great deal of Scripture simply by attending the TLM, but it’s helpful to know chapter and verse at least sometimes!
Reading and performing Shakespeare is at last starting to work it’s way into our family culture. That first magic moment was this past May when we had a particularly busy day ahead of us. We were reviewing the schedule and to-do items when my seven-year-old quipped: “MORE matter for a May morning?!?” 😀