Maybe to some, my kitchen looks so different that they assume it is way out of reach. “We’ll just do the normal thing because we could never afford that.”
What if I told you that the little touches here are the most frugal? That you’ll spend way more if you do it the conventional way? For instance, that a built-in, wired and plumbed island costs more than a custom-made furniture one?
Or that buying your hardware through the kitchen showroom costs a lot more than the way I did it, even though my knobs and pulls are solid brass?
Let’s go around the kitchen and see what I did, specifically regarding the hardware.
Remember, the design principles I had in mind for my 1860s kitchen were these:
- Using the space, which is funky and full of pathways and other obstructions making it quite inefficient in many respects, as fully as possible — which really did mean customizing the cabinetry to the quarter of an inch
- Trying to keep a classic “unfitted” look
- Choosing materials that are as real as possible and where possible, in keeping with the place and time (New England, 19th century)
- Compensating for the total gutting of the room (other than the fireplace) with an “implied evolution of styles” so that we didn’t end up with a “time stamp” that would date the renovation to a certain year’s trends
- Keeping in mind that I did use this kitchen for almost a quarter of a century and know what kinds of things will make me crazy and what kinds of things I like, and not be talked into things that are not for me
Since I knew I would have a built-in fridge, the appliance pulls were a must. You need their sturdiness and size because these doors have a suction seal and will be yanked on multiple times, a day hopefully forever.
Overall, from my Pinterest investigations, I had decided that the general look I wanted was brass (with a little mixing of metals in the materials for the faucets). It seemed the most fitting, given the criteria above; I like the warmth and so on.
I remembered various voices saying that you want the things you touch to feel good: real, solid, not prone to peeling or cracking. The finish on the ceiling lamp by the door is far out of sight and you’ll never touch it. It’s okay for it to offer a general nod to whatever look you’re trying to pull off: the Lowe’s $40 schoolhouse fixture is going to do the job — I don’t need the $200 Pottery Barn version.
So I was willing to go big for the appliance pulls, and keep in mind that the last time I bought a knob for my kitchen was when I ran down to Home Depot to get a porcelain one to replace one that broke and it was maybe $3. We are talking a combination of not going into this market with either experience of what I needed or familiarity with current prices (which of course have skyrocketed even when you account for the usual increases).
In other words, I was super out of touch.
For all these reasons, early on in this process I had major, major sticker shock when I realized that one, (1), A SINGULAR pull would cost at least $40 for something rather unaesthetic and completely unsatisfactory from Home Depot and up to $160 for the solid brass that of course I craved. Each.
I needed three.
I went through all the stages of grief, including wondering if they could be DIY’ed using towel racks (not really and would still cost a lot: wow, towel racks are expensive!!) and spending days and days searching for alternatives.
Finally I ascertained that these Massey appliance pulls, 12″, from Rejuvenation in aged brass were the ones I wanted. But no way, no way was I going to pay $420 plus shipping.
For days I searched online, and finally I put in the exact thing I was looking for (“3 Massey appliance pulls Rejuvenation 12” aged brass) on Facebook Marketplace. And lo and behold, up popped a listing for exactly that!
“Bought too many, new in box” for around $50 each which was pretty good but — I saw the listing had been up for 17 weeks. So I offered $30 each and I would pay for shipping (saving myself an hour’s drive to the city, which I would have made if necessary). The answer came back, “how about $125 and I pay shipping.”
Um… yes. I’m still not sure how I got away with that, but phew! (Keep in mind that designers overbuy and are happy to unload afterwards.)
Now, the thing I think most people do is just get all the pulls and knobs from the same line.
But each Massey pull is $16-65.
Each knob is around $14. Count up all the ones you will need and you see how much it all ends up being? Don’t get me wrong, they are beautiful.
But I couldn’t help think there must be some other way to get that hardware. I could accept, reluctantly, that the appliance pulls needed to be appliance pulls. But the rest of it?
Surely those brass knobs have been around forever? Why are they so much?
I found a guy near me on FBMP who was selling the Home Depot version of the knobs — which is the “around forever” version and just fine — for a few bucks less each, new in the box.
I bought a couple of boxes off of him.
But I did want something like those Massey drawer pulls or something other than knobs for the lower cabinets/drawers. I like this kind and wanted one for the spice/oils/vinegars pull-out by the stove:
Maybe it’s just me, but I like having just one. I don’t generally want to reach under for this type of cup pull for all the drawers, particularly the ones I know from experience I will use with wet and possibly even floury hands. Anyway, it wasn’t cheap. I can’t remember now why I decided to order and keep this, but there it is.
Finally I found what I was looking for: the pulls I wanted, but that aren’t official “kitchen hardware” — in fact, they are window hardware!
They are called Sash Lift/Door Pulls, and for the lower drawers I got these, that are around $10 each (better than $20 for the Massey ones!) and these for the upper drawers — they are slightly smaller, and here’s another place where the contractor raised an eyebrow, but at the time (not now, apparently) they were several dollars cheaper and I prefer the slight variation, both in size and in shape. I think the eye rests with it.
I like them because they are easy to clean around, which is going to be necessary with me as the cook, and they don’t have anything sticking out to catch your clothing — the rounded aspect is also key for sanity. They are timeless and in fact would have been in the old-fashioned hardware store in the center of town back in the day.
I also needed new doorknobs in places. Again, you can run up your bill here. This classic style at House of Antiques is upwards of $150.
By now I knew to run to FBMP, and I found a guy practically giving away these simple but satisfying ones that add the elevated touch, for about $2 each — I put one on my front door too:
There is a deadbolt lock above, so the knob didn’t need a lock.
When you are doing a renovation costing tens of thousands in repairing rotting beams, tearing out faulty wiring, and re-doing wonky plumbing, it can seem like it doesn’t matter to spend $500 here and $500 there, but it does! You will, regardless. So you have to be strict with yourself where you can!
By the way, this Pinterest board has a lot of the items I ended up getting — vs. this one, which has all my inspiration pictures.
On to our links!
bits & pieces
- I recommend reading this little article about C. S. Lewis on making reading a hobby (and of course, he was one of history’s greatest readers) with your rising high school student. Give him something to aim for!
- How the Bible and the Liturgy Illuminate Christian Marriage — Peter Kwasniewski with another jam-packed talk and I don’t just say that because he starts with a quote from me!
- I’m sure you’ve encountered someone who has used a surrogate or casually mentions someone they know who did. Please be convinced of its absolute evil. People need our visceral yet well informed reactions. They need to know something is repugnant and unacceptable.
- Here’s another something to read aloud with the family — it’s so funny! Translation can be so funny!
- For the price of a month’s disposable diapers, you could buy a permanent supply! Not to mention if you buy them second-hand! I know the cost of having a baby seems so high, but there are ways! Cloth diapering can seem impossibly out of the realm of possibility, but once you just try it, you realize it’s not what you thought at all. It’s much nicer for baby and for the parents too.
from the archives
- Our guide to Father’s Day gifts!
- A post about a historical novel that also has general tips for homeschooling (don’t you find the end of your school year the most inspirational for next year? jot your ideas down somewhere where you will find them in September!)
liturgical living
From today’s Office of Readings: Mary Stored Up All These Things In Her Heart
follow us everywhere! share us with your friends!
Here is my affiliate link to my Amazon page — the only affiliate thing that goes on here on LMLD, which is why the page loads quickly and you don’t have to keep closing pop-ups etc! Thank you for opening it and shopping if you are so minded — as some have asked me. If not, don’t worry one bit!
My book, The Summa Domestica: Order and Wonder in Family Life is available from Sophia Press! Also in paperback now! All the thoughts from this blog collected into three volumes, beautifully presented with illustrations from Deirdre, an index in each volume, and ribbons!
My “random thoughts no pictures” blog, Happy Despite Them has moved over to Substack! — receive it by email if you like, or bookmark, so you don’t miss a thing! The old one is still up if you want to look at the comments on past posts. It will take me a while to get things organized, but you’ll be patient, I know!
My podcast, The Home Truths Society, can be found on the Restoration of Christian Culture website (and you can find it where you listen to such things) — be sure to check out the other offerings there!
Stay abreast of the posts here at LMLD, when they happen:
Consider subscribing to this blog by email. We would love to pop into your inbox! The subscription box is on this page on the sidebar!
We share pretty pictures: Auntie Leila’s Instagram, Rosie’s Instagram, Deirdre’s Instagram. Bridget’s Instagram.
Auntie Leila’s Facebook (you can just follow)
The boards of the others: Rosie’s Pinterest. Sukie’s Pinterest. Deirdre’s Pinterest. Habou’s Pinterest












Great job! I confess to getting obsessed with finding unlacquered brass vs. polished. My husband drew the line at removing the polished finish ourselves on dozens of pieces of hardware. But I did well on eBay for several items! That Perrin and Rowe faucet that is/was everywhere a couple of years ago I got brand new on eBay for a great price. Possibly a designer unloading a client reject. Who knows. But it’s so pretty and didn’t come with a sinking feeling of guilt a la Meg Brooke’s silk. I agree with you on mixing metals on the faucets. Big brass faucet is a little much for me, but I love my brass cabinet hardware! In our area Craigslist is still viable, and we have a couple of building materials only kind of thrift stores in our city that are hit or miss but when it’s a hit it’s a big one. Oftentimes the thrifted stuff I find I like much better than the overpriced stuff from China you get through the showrooms.
There’s no judging in what we get obsessed with! The appliance pulls were my bag of hot dog buns (Father of the Bride!!) — they just sent me around the bend! I suppose if I hadn’t found the ones I did I would have been forking over. For me it was the brass switch plates and push buttons, but I was able to take advantage of a 25% off sale (so keep your eye on that House of Antiques site if you really want something on there!)
I love your kitchen touches and at the end of the day, the artist has to do what she has to do 😉
Oh yes! There are regularly discount codes available for spending over $100 or something like that through Retail Me Not! Even with the discount too easy to meet that threshold. Judicious use of special knobs etc. adds a lot of character! I’ve asked for a bathroom doorknob for a birthday present lol.
Would you be willing to share the total cost of your kitchen renovation?
I would but who even knows??
Sometimes it’s just better not to know the total cost. Like, seriously.
Seriously…
Some kitchens are a matter of replace the cabinets (or even fronts), change appliances, update systems, and painting… this one was major addressing of beams under one side of the house, replacing failing windows and doors, totally gutting the room, redoing the systems… not only would I not know what part of it is the kitchen and what part is just the house, I wouldn’t know where to start. And probably the number would be shocking if we just had the kitchen in mind, but also not helpful, as we wouldn’t be comparing apples to apples!
Seriously. The major money all goes to the stuff you don’t see, but have to do, and is so individual to the house as to be irrelevant to anybody else. And costs of materials, labor, etc. varies so much by area that’s of limited usefulness to have a number on as well. Like Leila said, we all do what we gotta do with the resources we have!
Sometimes a friend who lives in a new build is redoing the kitchen and I can’t believe how simple it all is LOL — old house problems!
I cloth diapered for ten years and very much preferred it, but at our new house the diapers just aren’t coming clean and I’m at my wit’s end with stripping them and washing them more often. They smell foul when they shouldn’t. I tried brand new ones (I use prefolds) when my baby moved up a size but the problem reappeared within weeks. I’ve had to switch to disposable diapers but I wish I could switch back. Anyone have any advice? I feel like there has to be a solution to this.
It sounds like it could be a water hardness issue or a detergent buildup problem! I have read that stripping diapers at every sign of trouble is not always the solution, and often the problem is that you are using too much detergent.
Hi Leila, I noticed in some other pictures that you changed your hearth tiles. Could you tell us about that sometime? Random, I know! I hope it gives you joy to know how invested we all are in your kitchen!
Oh yes! I will! Thanks for reminding me!
Have you seen the Fluff Love University website? I’m a novice at cloth diapering, but I’ve used them, they seem to have really good info re washing diapers. The problem likely has to do with the hardness or lackthereof of your diapers. The website has really detailed info, including how to test your water, how full to have your washer, types and amounts of detergent, etc. I hope it helps!
Are there actual “worksheets” that I can type on re: menu making?? I seem to remember there being something like this, and I am trying to streamline my meal planning rather than thinking “What should we eat?” every single week from scratch… An excel spreadsheet of some sort? Did that exist or am I imagining it??? Thank you!
No, there aren’t… originally I had a half-baked idea that I would make spreadsheets, but then I realized it was just even simpler than that.
Instead I give you a step-by-step way to set up your binder. If you want to do it as a spreadsheet, you can, but mine is really a few lists, as outlined in the posts.
OK, thanks! I am going to try to do spreadsheets so I can have multiple categories on one meal (“cheap” “Friday” “summer” etc), but I may have to ask my Excel-master husband for help 🙂
I did it in Word and made columns. That way the menus stayed together and I could fit more on one page.
Thank you for the CS Lewis link! My oldest has always been so reluctant to study a book with a pencil in his hand, no matter what we’ve done to convince him… It’s very clearly the most effective way to understand and remember a lot of information.
And the Hedgehog Moss Farm piece about translation pitfalls… oh my, I have my own stories! The man who would become my husband once said, early on in our acquaintances, that I had a “standing dinner invitation” from him. It was the most puzzling thing I had ever heard, I imagined America must have restaurants where you only stand, and that’s where he thought he’d like to take me… 😀
That’s so funny! Of course, you certainly CAN go to a restaurant where you just stand (like at a ballpark!). And that’s the fun of America!
Love your kitchen Leila. Don’t divulge the costs . Every project is such a Journey Into The Unknown even for the most well prepared . I always like a ballpark and work from there.
This is a gal who is paying for a new chimney rebuild 🤦🏼♀️, after having just replaced the well pump. 🤦🏼♀️. Old homes . Oof
It’s just … overwhelming!
If you are into cloth diapering, you might also consider for yourself reusable menstrual pads. I have had my set for a few years now and I was surprised at how well they work and how easy they are to care for. This is the set I purchased and I can attest to many of the positive reviews on absorbency and comfort. I can get by with using just using the 10 piece set, but I would recommend the 16 piece set for those who have heavy flow days and/or for nights.
https://www.amazon.com/Teamoy-Menstrual-Super-Absorbent-Comfortable-3pcs%C3%9711-6/dp/B078S6KRX2/ref=mp_s_a_1_3_pp?crid=2K4Q9PTDG0NA&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.cqmBKehQLhe1yOAkUX3JFds22FNBSFwEdjZY7TPQ-qcpgl1K0dePKAPs8xRvXluIJ7xeQtJKoL6Af-TS5zSgq1eGDwbyBbZlw4yNa-gVCTMMi-29_4Og5X-yFperf0swPWVOtG6OSCPMyyGcWaGxq86ExOyVArhZwUUgZ6Gkccb2tQBM17RnD5qKcBUvcspecihLqKFE6V-iPgFfepg-8w.WL7rtzG6tsytnfg68vf72AkaPEQrLUTL8CjPDDl4LcQ&dib_tag=se&keywords=reusable+menstrual+pads&qid=1718471712&sprefix=reusiable+mens%2Caps%2C291&sr=8-3#aw-udpv3-customer-reviews_feature_div
Thank you!!! I requested the soapstone info—and yes, we are going with soapstone! And now am going down the pulls/knobs/handles rabbit hole so this is extremely helpful! I am always so inspired and uplifted by your posts. Thank you, thank you!
Oh great! Glad to be of service! XOXO