I finished Pippo’s sweater!
Finishing something always surprises me. A baby sweater actually just doesn’t take that long, even if you count getting spacey and having to rip stuff out. Which, apparently, you must if you’re me.
I do love how knitting a baby sweater in the round, top-down, is a magical experience. You cast on a certain number of stitches, divide them, and very shortly you have a neck hole, yoke, and the beginnings of sleeves!
Now, this pattern features a placket opening, which was very appealing to me. You cast onto your circulars (I used bamboo) but go back and forth at first, with the seed stitch for the neck and the first and last 5 stitches of the placket.
Okay, you expert knitters bear with me, because I realize that you instantaneously see my issue and can offer me solace and advice, I have no doubt. But I have to explain what happened to the rest of you, who happen to be still reading. Non-experts, since you are stuck here, I will point out that when you go back and forth — as opposed to knitting in the round — you knit one row and purl the next to produce the stockinette stitch (the smooth knitting). Later, after the placket is done, you join the sides and knit in the round, which means you just knit. Around.
So go back and look at that photo again, up top. It almost looks like there’s a yoke in the pattern (a visible one, I mean, not the conceptual one that only refers to the geography of the garment). The texture of the knitting is different, not because it’s a different stitch, but because it’s done back-and-forth-wise until the point under the placket where I joined the sides.
I didn’t block the sweater, since it’s cotton and alpaca and I thought blocking might be useless. Is that why I have texture issues? You should know (anyone who is going to tell me why I have this yoke appearing) that I purl with the Norwegian purl.
So far I have not met anyone else –even among Continental knitters — who uses this method of purling. But I learned it because I have an aversion to pulling the yarn in front for purling. You’re going along knitting one and purling one, and you are wasting all kinds of time moving that yarn back and forth, and, more to the point, you (if you’re me) are forgetting to move the yarn back and forth. This results in frustration at your incompetence. And ripping. I prefer just leaving the yarn in back. The Norwegian purl allows you to do that.
I learned this method using a different Youtube video that is not anywhere near as clear as this one I’m posting here, but was the only one available at the time. It took me an entire Superbowl and part of The Sound of Music to figure out how the heck to do it.
However! Does that put a little twist in the stitch? Or loosen it up? I’m not going to give it up! I don’t care what you say! I do wonder if it would be as noticeable a difference in wool. Do you think a washing will magically true things up?
Anyway.
To continue. If I had thought it through, I would have maybe realized that when I was done I was going to worry that the placket idea, so very comme il faut for a mature person, might not actually work when your head is one third of your body and every bit as wide as your shoulders.
I did not, however, think it through. Which means that there is no buttonhole for the otherwise easily added button.
My vintage button stash to the rescue! I have only to ask the button-stash gods for a manly little toggle button — you know, one shaped in a way that enables it to poke through the existing stitching — and they graciously deign to provide me with one.
If the sweater should be found to work without it, then it can be removed without any difficulty. If, as suspected, it’s necessary to prevent the required large opening from causing shoulder-sliding, this particular button works without a buttonhole.
Another note, if this isn’t boring you to tears: I like the seam-fashioning, which is produced by my decision to form the increases by picking up my stitch from the in-between-stitches yarn (does this have a real name?).
After all, this sweater is meant to be a Cali-baby one — a mere fluffy layer to protect him from the ever-gentle but perhaps freshening breezes. I think that if you were making this for, say, a New England baby, you would not want airiness. You would want to do an increase that doesn’t produce holes. The pattern, however, only lightly touched on the increase question, leaving the specifics up to your (possibly inexperienced) imagination.
I’m proud of myself for charging in regardless, as usually I wring my hands over lacunae of this kind.
My final issue (hello? hello? anyone?) is that I didn’t like how the decreases of the sleeves worked in this pattern, so I made up my own, putting in more. Possibly my dissatisfaction goes back to those sneaky two stitches per section that found their way in there (why oh why can’t I remember to count?). If you want to know what I’m talking about, check my Ravelry notes. Yes, there are more notes. Frightening, I know.
In any case, this was by far the trickiest part of the sweater, in that having cooked up a decrease that I liked the shape of, I then had to remember what I did and replicate it on the other side. Will you be surprised if I tell you that gave me some trouble? Never mind.
Back to the wedding quilt! I think I’m on the last square, but don’t actually have the courage to look. Not that I don’t still have the border and binding….


I actually like the very subtle yoke (having squinted to see it), but my guess is that it's just a very subtle gauge difference between when you're knitting in the round, and when you're knitting back-and-forth– which would be there no matter how you purl. (The purl stitches in the video don't look twisted to me.)
What a great sweater! And in quite the coincidence, was just reading Elizabeth Zimmerman's pattern for a sweater with placket last night before bed.
I am by no means an accomplished knitter – I'm happy making scarves and hats, but I do use the Norweigen purl. That's how my grandmother taught me when I was in my teens and when I was reteaching myself a few years ago I was so frustrated w/ purling b/c I knew I wasn't doing it how I had been originally taught (and I kept twiting the yarn causing it to snap). I stumbled across a youtube video (probably the one you refer to) and the light bulb went off of “THAT'S how I'm supposed to be doing it!”. It works great for me! The only downside is I can't figure out how to double knit w/ the Norweigen purl method and I so want to make these pot holders http://offthehookastronomy.blogspot.com/2009/08/s…
Love the sweater. Pippo will be so handsome.
I too love the top-down sweater knitting and my first was very similar to yours, except for a larger child and a hood was added later. But I understand all that about the back and forth and then joining in the round (and I had the hardest time getting that join to look natural — you did a good job). My very amateur 2 cents about the yoke (which I do not think you are going to notice at all once it is on him) is that your stitches above (the back and forth) are more loose than your in-the-round stitches. Blocking (actually probably just washing) may tighten them up if there is any cotton or wool in your yarn. That Norwegian stitch is crazy, lady (and I think it's only natural that those stitches are going to look a little different than regular knits which are easy to keep nice and tight)! I am a Continental knitter and I think that stitch looks WAY harder than the “normal” purl, but I do a funky thing with my left index finger when I purl that makes it looks like I am doing something else, so what do I know?
Re: Norwegian purling – I think part of my brain just exploded. I've suddenly found myself knitting an entire scarf for my husband in seed stitch (do I regret this decision now? Yes.), so I tried it – there's no way I will ever be able to get the tension right with all that twirling around.
Anyway, I knit continental and don't do a Norwegian purl, and I get those lines, too. I just made a pair of wool soakers and they're knit partially back and forth and partially in the round and you can see where I switch over to circulars. But I haven't blocked them yet so I can't tell you if it helps.
(I think that type of increase is called make 1 left/right depending on whether you do it from the front or the back.)
Rebekka, I'm not sure if this means your head exploded in a good or bad way 🙂
Yes, the tensioning takes some practice, but once you get the knack of it, it goes so quickly.
And a little bird tells me that if you do stockinette in the middle of the length of the scarf and keep the seed for the ends (however far you've gotten) — who will know, what with it being wrapped around his neck and only the ends showing anyway! 😉
Very cute sweater!
Perhaps the extra finagling that your style of purling takes could result in slightly larger stitches, but that being said, just about everyone knits and purls at different gauges. If this really drives you crazy, you could try two different sizes of straight needles, or learn to knit backward (people do this, though I can't really wrap my mind around it). I don't think that's worth the trouble, though, because I say it will absolutely even out in the wash and blocking.
There's a passage in one of Elizabeth Zimmerman's books where she talks about the marvel of all the old time knitters being such perfectly even knitters, and she despaired that her knitting could ever be so even. Until she realized that it wasn't the particular skill of the knitter that made items to smoothly even, but the amount of time and service and washing that they'd been through.
It's very pretty, regardless of all your trials with it. And yes, baby sweaters knit up so fast, they're a pleasure (at least, the one I did years ago was a pleasure!)
Beautiful sweater! Such a pretty blue. I'm in no way an expert, so no help from me on the yoke or decreases. But I have to agree with Barbara; that the Norwegian purl stitch is crazy. I'm also a continental knitter and it does look like way more work. I'm going to sound completely nuts here, but I don't mind the purl stitch. I'm doing a pair of legwarmers for my daughter right now and it's in a k2p2 ribbing. And I don't feel any time wasted going back and forth. I'm moving along quite nicely. But also like Barbara, I do my own thing with the purl stitch. Using my thumb to secure down the yarn as I'm pulling it through. Sounds weird I know, but it works for me, lol. 🙂 Also, I think if you're knitting continental the purl stitch doesn't feel so awkward or time-wasting. At least that's what I've been told. I've never even tried English. I love continental too much…that and I don't like change. 😉
Kelly, I do knit Continental and I guess I am more up for twisting around than moving the yarn forward. Once you get the hang of it, it's no trouble. And did you know that apparently there is a Russian method of knitting? I need to find out more about that. And what about Irish Cottage knitting?? Everyone has her own method 🙂
That adorable sweater is going to look even more adorable on Pippo!
Re the yoke: The “uneven” fabric is due to the tension at which you knit vs. purling. Most people purl a little looser than they knit (no matter their method) and this results in the looser rows. You can try either knitting looser, or purling tighter to fix it. Soaking and blocking usually helps ease it a bit depending on fiber. An alpaca/cotton might bloom enough to smooth it out. My fix is I try to always knit in the round! 🙂
Re the increases: Yes! There is a name for picking up the stitch in between – it's called “make one” (m1). If you'd like to avoid the holes next time you can twist the stitch after it is picked up by knitting into either the front or back leg. You can also make the resulting stitch “lean” to the left or right depending on which way you pick it up and twist it.
This site: http://www.knittinghelp.com/videos/increases
helped me a lot for working out increases and leaning them one way or the other.
Again, love the sweater! 🙂
I was just reading about this very phenomenon! (The different texture problem) According to Elizabeth Zimmerman (you know about her, right? She's the Leila Lawler of the knitting world!) the problem arises because our knit tension and our purl tension are slightly different. So you get a tighter, looser, stretchier, or whatever kind, of knit fabric when you knit back and forth, and something different when you knit in the round. That's her theory, and it makes sense. But these little inconsistencies are really only noticeable to the eye of the knitter. Everyone else sees a gorgeous heirlooom baby sweater!
I also wanted to join the thank-ers for your last post. You are so practical and wise. Thank you.
I just realized that I said exactly the same thing as Meg above. Sorry!
Wow! I didn't know that. So neat! I'm sure they all have their benefits, too. I know it would do me good to explore each one and be a little adventurous, but I really don't like change (plus I'm a big chicken, lol).
Goodness! I do love knitting! Everything about it is fun. Even talking over the minutia of stitches, buttons, yokes and methods. I'm even reading a book right now on knitting and knitter's quirks. I feel a bit obsessed. 😉
I know, Kelly! I just wish I had people around me to show me their techniques! Watching Youtube videos kind of drives me crazy 🙂
The sweater is lovely, and such a pretty (ahem, *handsome*) color! I always have this problem with back and forth knitting as well and I knit with my yarn in my right hand and purl normally with the yarn in front. One way I found that helped a little was to consciously knit my knit stitches a little looser to match my looser purls. This helps some but I often forget when I am in the rhythm of knitting to make my knit stitches looser. Just recently, however, I taught myself to knit backwards, as in I don't turn my work around to the purl side I just knit back across the front (knit) side of my project. For me this involves sticking the left needle through the back loop of the stitch on my right needle and wrapping the yarn (still in my right hand) around from the back over the left needle and pulling this through to the front. Slide this completed stitch onto my left needle and repeat with the next stitch. I am sure there are youtube videos for this sort of thing for continental knitters as well, just look up knit backwards or something similar. This GREATLY improved the look of my stockinette so that I don't have the difference in texture you describe. For some reason I can keep the tension much more consistent this way.
So. I learned to knit English (or American, or right-handed, however you want to put it) and then I discovered Continental knitting after I already had made quite a few things. I also quite naturally, because I learned to knit from books, twisted each stitch as I knitted it in flat knitting but didn't in circular knitting. I actually only realized I twisted stitches when I read a description of how to twist stitches to make a pattern and went, “uh, but that's just knitting”.
Anyway. Yes, you're twisting the stitch a little bit when you purl that way, but you can fix it by looking at the stitch before you knit it on the other side–you might have to stick your needle in a bit. Might I just add, that just because you knit Continental most of the time, that doesn't mean that you have to do it all the time. You can learn to knit English *just* for ribbing, seed stitch, and other things where you have to flip the yarn to the front all the time. It's a lot easier with English knitting.
Now, having learned both, I knit English on ribbing, seed stitch, and cables, and Continental on everything else. Oh! and if it's a straight purl row I use my thumb to tension the yarn in continental knitting.
Ask for clarification on anything. I know that wasn't very cogently put, I have a baby holding my thumb as I type.
A bit– I mean stick your needle in a bit differently. 😛 The grabby baby is asleep now, sorry about that.
It looks to me like your purling tension is just a wee bit looser than your knit. Your stitches don't look twisted to me. It will probably block out – it isn't that noticable anyways.
I knit continental too, and I've tried the norweigan purl, but never enough for it to be faster. So I stick with my “combination” knitting where the purls are twisted, and untwist them when I knit the next row.
Lovely, lovely. You do know that will be an heirloom? And the “frustrations”: those are the special touches that make this piece unique and handmade!
Don't know if you care for future buttonholes, but have you read about Elizabeth Zimmerman's Afterthought Buttonhole? I'm doing it on a newborn knit dress. Here's the tutorial I used: http://annypurls.blogspot.com/2006/05/annypurls-o…
Your work is gorgeous.
Rachel– “Open-knit surgery”! Too funny. I didn't know about it, and now the sweater is in California!
I'm not a knitter, but I still read these posts because you're funny. 🙂
Oh man, oh man, oh man. My lack of practice in knitting is making me frustrated. I ahve not, as of yet, made anything other than pretty scarves with different patterns. I should be grasping this by now, and I'm not.
This is a good, git up off my rear end knitting post for me.
All I heard was blahblahblahknit. blahblahblahpurl. But the part about “the entire superbowl and part of the sound of music” nearly killed me! So funny!!
And from a complete novice, I think the sweater looks great and I thought the yoke was supposed to be there. 🙂
My grandmother knits with Norwegian purl, my mother knits continental, and I do both. Everything I've ever knitted has always had that little bit of texture in it, but it always seems to wash out by the second or third trip through the laundry.
I read for the frustrations, not the knitting, because I like the process of working through the frustrations.
Elizabeth Zimmerman says just to “dab at it” with a steam iron. I'm not sure where I remember this from, but more than once she talks about using a steam iron for a gentler, easier blocking. I think these garments do get evened out with washing and even simply wearing.
I love your button solution. What an unusual little button!
I am going to try the Norwegian purl! What fun! Myself, I knit backwards sometimes when there are whole rows of pearling. I can go more evenly back and forth without turning it around, than purling back. But it certainly wouldn't be a quick fix for uneven stockinette because going backwards was terribly awkward at first. I don't see why one couldn't mindfully adjust the tension to make it even, but I haven't myself.
It's adorable. And I read your whole post – I was very confused. This is why I stick with sewing 🙂
(I do have a tiny little goal to learn to knit socks, though. We'll see.)
Wow! What a wonderful sweater! I, too, knit Continental. I might have to try Norwegian purling. It looks very interesting.
Thanks for the post. Great read!
I think it's already been mentioned, since I'm doing a fly-by, and don't have time to read all the comments, but I think the reason for the mock yoke is indeed because when you do the back and forth motions of the Norwegian purl, it stretches the loop that you're purling just slightly. You'll find the same thing when you do an M1 by kf&b in the same stitch. That poor little stitch just gets stretched a bit. My guess is with the cotton in it, if you wash it, it'll be fine. Love your longer posts, by the way.
I love your little sweater; my favorite baby sweater pattern is also a top-down raglan sleeve with a seed stitch placket. I have the exact same problem when I knit back and forth, only worse. it almost looks like the stitches are zigzagged, like I did it on purpose. The only thing I've done that helps is to Continental one side and Irish Cottage (like the Yarn Harlot) knit the other side. Somehow that smooths everything out. It doesn't seem to matter which side gets purled and which knitted. I think the problem lies with the posts, and some mysterious tension issue thereof.
Beautiful sweater! I'm sure Pippo will enjoy wearing it and his mother will enjoy looking at it even with those slight imperfections.
I'm just a beginner knitter so I can't help with the technical difficulties but I'm amazed at how brave you are to just jump in. I'm more of a “dip the toe in the water” sort of knitter so I'm still knitting much easier stuff. 🙂
Such an amazing sweater. You are so brave to forge ahead like that! I can't wait to see pics of Pippo in it.
I've never heard of the Norwegian purl, and I'm not a continental knitter, but I'm going back to the kitchen where my knitting is and try it!
I'm also a very lazy knitter (not that you're lazy, just I'm “not a continental knitter” and “also a lazy knitter) who finds gauging and blocking tedious. I have found, however, that blocking does magical things and it's totally worth the effort. I'll probably find the same is true about gauge, someday.
I read every word and wasn't bored at all. I love this sweater and the colour. I have a New Brunswick baby, but I would probably increase like you did because I like the look of it. I'd try blocking. I think it will help. I have the same issue sometimes because my purl is looser than my knit stitch. I think I might cast one of these on!
Beautiful sweater and in my favorite color. I was taught to knit by an Aunt of mine when I was 7 years old when she visited one Sunday. Years later I came across a leisure world pattern called “The Great Sweater of the 1940s” . It was developed for volunteers to make for the fighting men and for refugees .. It was supposed to be so simple that any one with a basic knowledge of knitting could turn out a sweater. Starting with the ribbing at the bottom of the front. you knitted up toward the neck, continued up over the shoulders and knitted down the back till you finished the bottom ribbing, then picked up stitches at the armhole and knitted outward to the wrists. After the sweater was sewn, the neck stitches on holders were picked up and knitted to make either a crew neck or turtle neck. My oldest daughter and I turned out very acceptable sweaters on our first try and I went on to knit 4 more sweaters. I lost it somewhere in one of our moves and it is no longer in print. I contacted Leisure Arts and theywere kind enough to run me off a new copy. I wish that they would reprint it. I love your blog – I truly could have used it when I was a newly married 18 year old in 1953.