Most frugality/financial experts say that extended warranties on appliances are not worth it. I tend to disagree, especially with the workout appliances get in a big family. And I think that most experts don’t consider big families that much…maybe they have in mind a typical couple who go out to eat a lot and don’t bother with the dishwasher anyway. Not folks like me who run it twice a day when everyone’s around.
Last year I paid about $230 on warranties for my dishwasher (10 yrs old), fridge (2 yrs old, manufacturer’s warranty expired), oven (8 yrs old, lots of expensive-to-replace computer parts), and dryer (6 yrs old, very simple machine but expensive to replace, as are they all). I figure the washer is a workhorse and I’ll take my chances.
My theory is that just a service call for any one of these will get close to that.
Last week, the dishwasher and dryer were not working well. (They had not been working well for a while, but I wasn’t paying attention.) Two guys came, separately…
Total: $417 for parts and labor — maybe more, because I’m not sure if the dryer part on order is covered (it’s around $23 and he’s coming back next week).
This seems worth it to me. And this happens every year with something, and even if nothing breaks, you are entitled to a maintenance call, which extends the life of your appliance. Why is our society okay with making, buying, and using a $2000 range with a fancy motherboard that breaks after 2 years? The repair is more than a new oven costs, so out it goes, into the landfill! Several people have recounted such stories to me. I was so relieved I had the warranty last year, when my oven broke down. No way do I have even the $1000 to replace it from the Sears outlet where I get all my appliances.
Even when you buy from the outlet, the manufacturer’s year-long warranty is good, so I don’t buy the extended one until that time passes. Some people don’t realize (even the technician doesn’t always) that you can extend the warranty later. And, I regret to say, I have come across a salesman or two who made me feel stupid for insisting on this fact (they make money when they convince you to buy the extra coverage). But it is a fact.
Anyone have thoughts on this? Am I missing something?


This is timely as we bought a refrigerator and washer/dryer last summer. How does one extend a warranty? Is there a company you recommend?
I don't know about extended warranties, but your post reminded me to be grateful for my 35 year old oven. When I married my husband 16 years ago and moved into his house, I inherited "Goldie." She has no expensive computer parts, has worked very well for all these years, and I've been able to get parts and do a couple of minor replacements/repairs myself.
I think this is great advice! We never used to pay the extra money for warranties, yet as our family grew – it just seemed to make sense!I have used the warranty on my W&D three times – easy, piddly things, but it would have cost us a lot of money. Yet with the warranty, I just called them, they sent the repair man, he fixed it and was on his way! No worry on my part whether or not we could afford a service call that week.I even buy the warranties they sell with small appliances at Wal-Mart and such. I bought a steam mop (LOVE IT) and it broke within a few months. It was replaced, no questions asked. Needless to say, we quickly purchased a second warranty!I do believe it has to do with a larger family that is home all day. We use our appliances *every* day, some numerous times a day. These warranties seem to be worth the money~
Susan, I just call Sears and get it through them. You don't have to have continuous coverage. I have briefly attempted to find alternatives, but came up with nothing.CarlynB, it's so true. The old ones stood up and did their job without a lot of nonsense. If I had had a way to fit a Garland or other vintage stove in my kitchen, that's what I would have done. Michigan Momma, I know! just the service call is never less than $100 — before they spend any time at all.
In the past year we have had replaced under warranty: two iPods, a portable DVD player, a sweeper, the motor in the dishwasher, and the compressor in the air conditioner. We had to pay for a new computer monitor because we failed to buy the warranty, and a new stove because we didn't continue the coverage. With big families, stuff breaks. I've never been sorry for the money spent. If you can't afford to replace an item (and sometimes it's just a year), buy the warranty.
We do have a larger family (5 kiddoes), and I run the washing machine at least twice a day. The dishwasher loads are inching towards twice daily. Maybe in the summer when everyone's home. The fridge is constantly being opened.However, I'm blessed to have a husband who has been able to fix all our appliances. Our oven has broken several times, and he replaced the whatsit that broke. Same with the washing machine, dishwasher, and the fridge. However, the seal on our fridge split and we decided after 10 years that it was time to replace the fridge. This wasn't the only broken item, just the last in a long list of items and complaints about the fridge. We talked about getting the extended warranty. I don't like spending $2,000 for an item with only a year warranty; I think that's ridiculous. But, my husband has been able to fix everything so far, including the brand new steam cleaner that I broke. If my husband weren't handy, I would definitely get the extended warranty for peace of mind.
Sears' "Maintenance Agreement" also includes a free yearly preventive maintenance visit. I call in and a guy comes out and tunes up the washing machine and cleans it so it runs better.This does not cover damage from rats, which is what killed our previous washing machine.
We recently bought a large freezer and a new washer, and I bought the extended warranty for both of them. Our washer is run almost constantly, two or three times a day. The freezer warranty covers up to $300 of lost food if it fails and the contents all thaw.I figured the same thing – if even one little thing goes wrong, it will cost more than the waranty to fix it.Also the maintenace call on the freezer means they will come and vacuum the coils, etc. and take care of the washer for us. We can watch and learn how the pros do it for when our warranty runs out.
Well, you have me thinking. I have gotten "burned" on some warrantied items in the past and so I have not done any extended warranties lately. However, you have me thinking that I should re-evaluate this. We are going to be in the market for a stove in the near future and that may be worth the $$. Hmm.
We've wised up to the ways of warranties over here, too (oooh, how alliterative)! When we refinished our kitchen, we saved so much money going vintage on the stove (an appliance so hearty I believe it would withstand a nuclear blast) that we decided to splurge on the dishwasher. We got the kind that is supposed to be able to handle someone accidentally leaving an entire cake in it. Not sure how you could do that accidentally, but anyway…because it is so "fancy" we got the warranty. Good thing, too, because we had a repairman out at least twice in two years to fix the dang thing. Turns out, you can't believe everything you see in commercials and the dishwasher can't really handle more than the smallest, softest bits of food.So, I'm still scraping plates, but at least I didn't have to get hit in the wallet in order to learn my lesson about false advertising. Thanks to my warranty!
If you pay for your item with a credit card (of course you wold pay it off too)that sometimes extends the warranty. My washer and dryer electronic on switches stopped working a month past the 2 year warranty. However, they are covered another year because they were purchased with a credit card. Costco also automatically extends warranties on appliances.
This is an angle I hadn't thought of – the "we're home all day with lots of people" angle. We have a tiny family. . . our only child is a girl and she's not that hard on things. Plus Papa Kitty is handy. But it sounds like a great idea that works well for you!
oh, you got me on a rant with the whole "Why is our society okay with making, buying, and using a $2000 range with a fancy motherboard that breaks after 2 years? The repair is more than a new oven costs, so out it goes, into the landfill!" AMEN! What happened to reduce, reuse, and recycle, and just plain making something that won't die in a year!? Glad to know I am not the only one frustrated by this waste!
Definitely, yes, we do extended warranties! In our house the delicate things like cameras and the like get them, too. I've been blessed with a child who is especially gifted at helping me to die to any tendency toward putting too much value on "things." Know what I mean?
Oh, and I wanted to tell you that we got our pysanky kit from Baba's Beeswax in less than a week (great service!), and my kids are blowing eggs and preparing dyes at this very moment. I can't wait to see how they do with it!
Thanks for a new perspective on this. I come from a family of handymen (and married one, too), so we don't get warranties. But I didn't know about the maintenance calls, nor have I thought about the harder use I might be giving the appliances.Someone told me (I wish I could cite that better!) that companies make a lot of money on warranties, so that's why they eagerly offer them.
Thanks for the post! I am coming to see the wisdom of it.My first set of appliances lasted a long time with little or no repair, 20 years on a washer and 18 on both washer and dryer. So I didn't buy any warranties on the new ones. I replaced the frig with one that broke three times in the first year ( and it was just a plain frig) and the washer is 2 years old and I need to call a repairman out for it. My son and I have fixed some things, the dishwasher seals, etc. but we don't do refrigerators! AZ Mom
This is a hard call for me. We just (as in 3 days ago) purchased a new W&D. Our "old" set, which is still sort of running, lived for 11 years, but with lots of problems (we didn't have to pay for repairs as husband is handy). I think about paying hundreds of dollars a year for 11 years and realize that we would have spent the same amount of money as we did for a new set. I don't know… maybe the warranties are less than they are when they offer them at the sale? We have always declined extended warranties on our computers (they're macs after all) and when my machine developed a problem with the display, it was out of warranty. When we went to the Apple store, they fixed it (i.e. restored to like new condition on everything, not just the display) for a flat fee that was about the same as their extended warranty. It was the first time we ever had a problem and I was glad I had not been spending $300 every other year.But I will admit that in the year (that over the course of 2 months) our dishwasher, oven, cooktop, television and ceiling fan all died, I kind of wondered if we should have extended warranties (they were all older appliances.) I am not/was not convinced, but I definitely wondered since it was so rapid-fire.I agree that having a large family changes things and I always consider that my appliances get twice the use as the "norm" so I consider that the W&D were actually 22 years old by amount of use they got.
You are a wise women.We bought a fancy washer and dryer set (cabrio). The $800 washer broke down 2 years later. The cost to repair was $500. It now sits in my garage. We are using a very old washer (no frills) that a friend gave us for free. It works great!I'm still sick about my washer- I was so thrilled to get that thing (it is huge and spun the clothes practically dry)Yes, I think you're right about the extened warrenty! They don't make applliances to last like they used to.
This post really hit a note with me. Due to the weird logistics of my kitchen, the only range that we can install is made by JennAire. Pricey!! The mother board in my 9 year old stove has fried twice already, not being able to withstand the heat from the regular use of its own self-cleaning cycle. The repair man asked how often we clean the oven. When we reported that it requires cleaning every couple of months, he guffawed. He did! Apparently we are not expected to actually cook in our oven more than once in a blue moon, and then only to heat up some sort of prefabbed meal in a disposable tray that won't make a mess in the oven. The fact that my oven is used daily, and sometimes more than once a day, puts our family way off the charts of "normal household use". Extended warranties are our friend!
Another cost effective warranty option is through our local natural gas supplier. I pay $12/month in addition to my gas bill, and all of my gas appliances are under warranty for parts & labor: the hot water heater, the dryer, the stove. I used the Sears warranty on my scratch & dent refrig for the first few years & then let it go. No problems. My washer and other dryer were purchased used and still take a kickin! My local repair man informed me that the electronic control panel is the most frequent repair he does, "get the old fashioned buttons and knobs if you can, they hold up better." And I always review Consumer Reports, even when buying used. (Who knew Cuisinart wasn't Cuisinart anymore?)
I want to rant like Kamper about how poorly items are made. When my last dishwasher died, the repair was just $100 short of what a new one cost. I was promised the old on lene would be recycled, but when the new one was delivered, the unsuspecting guy told me the old one was headed to a landfill. GrrrrrrrAnd I agree with usage. When my beloved Dyson died and I called customer service, the lady could not believe I vacuum everyday. I live in the Maine woods with my kids and neighbor kids running in and out and we have 2 dogs. Of course, it needs to be done every day! I got a 5 year warranty the next time. Lesson learned.
We've never used an extended warranty that we had bought so hence we never buy them. We are currently in the mode of- when an appliance breaks, you replace it with something free from freecycle. Our current dryer was picked up from freecycle and we feared it would not be a good find when my dh picked it up and water came gushing out. However, he was able to use parts from our old, nonworking dryer to make it work. It's the best dryer I've ever had and didn't cost a thing but the gas to go pick it up. Currently dh is using an old washer and dryer to make himself a tool chest with drawers. If you have someone handy I don't think the warranties would be worth while b/c you are only paying for parts.
Okay, so from what people have said, I think we can draw a few conclusions and make some distinctions.First, definitely don't buy the extended warranty until your appliance's manufacturer's warranty has run out (here I'm talking about the big-ticket items). You don't need continuous coverage, by the way. You can even let a year or more lapse.And actually, I think the odds are that something straightforward like a dryer with KNOBS (not computers) will either break down the first year or be good for a few years. It's AFTER the few years that you want the warranty, and you can get it, trust me.I also think it makes a difference if you live somewhere where the power goes out a lot, which is hard on an appliance.Second, there is a big difference between your typical couple who plan to live somewhere for a few years and hardly use their washer or what have you. After a while they are out of there anyway, so chances are they will be okay without warranties.In fact, this is how the companies make money on the warranties. Many people forget they have one and just get a new appliance; many move before the thing breaks; many just stop using the appliance — I know lots of people who say "oh, don't use the dishwasher, it doesn't work"!(They might be bogged down by the paperwork they envision, but the truth is you just call Sears and they have all the info there. You can ask them, "I have a warranty on my dryer, right?" and they will tell you.)So if these things get heavy use and you would like to have a long life out of them because you are staying put, you have to think of the wear and tear over time and the replacement cost.If you have someone handy AND are able to find appliances that don't have computer-operated controls, then it seems like the warranty isn't worthwhile.However, I'd like to point out that even if hubby can fix it, his time is worth something as well. Unless he's very speedy and clever, you have to consider the opportunity cost.Maybe paying someone else about $100 a year (less per appliance — I can't remember the exact amounts — if you do longer warranties and more appliances — they do give you a break) to fix things is worth it if hubby can make more than that in the two hours it takes him to fix it (not counting running to the hardware store for parts, breaking something else as he's fixing it, and marriage/family counseling).Don't even get me on the subject of why the appliances are made to break down. It seems like at some point the companies woke up and said, "why are we making things to last for decades? Stupid us."This makes me angry, but unfortunately it is the situation we're in now. I think if more people were savvy about taking care of their things, the companies would have to find another way to make money, such as going back to making things that last!By the way, I have had my dishwasher for ten years. Until this year I used it at least twice a day, often three times — and it has a large capacity and I'm a whiz at packing it.Not only has the warranty paid for itself many times over just on the repairs, but the repairman told me that I should keep it going as long as I can b/c the new ones, to be "environmentally correct", recycle water — even for the rinse! — and don't get dishes as clean (although mine doesn't use much water). He said it was in good shape and I would be very disappointed in a new one! And, I do not rinse my dishes, Pippajo!!
Auntie Leila, can I buy an extended warranty (say for my dishwasher, washer, fridge, etc.) if I don't have the original paperwork showing when I bought it? And if so, where do I go to purchase such a wonderful thing? We use our appliances ALL THE TIME (three little boys are tough on the washer!) and I've thought before that I wish I had a warranty.
Dear Emily, Consulting my tired brain, I find that I have had no trouble. I just call Sears ( 800 – 4 -MY- HOME, and they really should pay me for all this business; Lord knows I have tried to avoid giving out this information here before getting that call setting up direct deposit, curses)and ask to have an extended warranty on said appliance. I seem to recall that they ask for the model and serial number. They don't care where you bought it. Try and see. But don't do it if they are under a year old.